The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook M1 vs Apple MacBook Pro

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook M1.

Apple MacBook M1Apple MacBook Pro
Owners with an opinion2113902
Positive verdicts73% of 18062% of 3276
Positive/negative since 202458/21945/592
Happy after 3+ years4355
Longest happy owner4.1 yrs16 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwarebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook M1: NeutralApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
100% agree. If you don’t like that Apple products are expensive to repair, don’t buy them or suck it up I came to terms with it, mostly. I buy AppleCare. I’ve had my screen on my M1 Mac replaced twice. I agree with the sentiment tho. I had the rubber foot come off the bottom of a MacBook Pro, Apple wanted $350 to replace that $1 part. I found other solutions
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
> My favorite memory of my M1 Pro MacBook Pro was the whole sensation of “holy crap, you never hear the fans in this thing”, which was very novel in 2021. I had that same "wow, no fan" when I got my M1 Mac (still have my 2014 Intel MBP and the fans come on almost immediately) > this dang thing still seems to just shrug at basically anything I throw at it. Unfortunately, this year I started playing with stable diffusion stuff, while it might be possible to optimize, what I have (automatic1111 and comfyui), is slow and my fans come on. Slow = 6x to 12x slower than friends with gaming PCs.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I had the 2019 i9. The power difference and the cooling difference is astounding from the 2019 to the M1 (and the M1 is faster). I actually use my laptop on my lap commonly and I think the i9 was going to sterilize me.
Apple MacBook M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Lithium ion batteries that can handle a thousand to several thousand charge cycles and only see 80% reduction in capacity have been available for ten years. My 2013 Macbook Pro has just such a battery, rated for 80% capacity after 1000 cycles, and it lasted over 6 years before the battery's internal resistance rose enough that heavy load would cause a brownout and the machine to force sleep. Yet they are not in widespread use; most devices have prioritized capacity/weight/size over longevity, Apple included. My current M1 has lost 10% of its capacity after just 120 cycles and less than a year of ownership, even using a utility that allows you to set a limited maximum charge level to preserve the battery. And the battery is less accessible, less replaceable. Battery companies and device manufacturers don't care. There's no incentive for anyone involved and consumers have gotten used to replacing devices every few years. Solid state batteries with 10k charge/discharge cycles are never going to happen for the same reason incandescent bulbs are purposefully manufactured by every single lightbulb manufacturer to fail when they figured out a hundred years ago how to make them last forever. We need something like a e-waste import duty, tax, fee, or 'recycling deposit' on devices with non-replaceable lithium ion batteries.
Apple MacBook M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Recommends it
It's still a Mac. But the i love the MacBook pro series from 2016-17. With ssd. Before they took away all the plugs. If my m1 would break I would probably just buy one of those from a reputable refurbished company. They are affordable, often between 500-800 (mostly dependent on hard drive size), and great specs. My new m1 theoretically is better, but I experience much more issues. And if any issues I can deal with the refurbished company, of which some offer great service.
Apple MacBook M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Sheesh, did you skip the MBP 2015? That's the best one they ever made, even to this day. I've been using MBP 2015 since then and just recently "upgraded" to M1. The MBP 2015 is still a better machine, better screen and keyboard. I can type waayy faster on the 2015 with less errors and the screen is better on the eye strain. The whites on the M1 are BRIGHT. I don't need a flash light shining at my face. Turning down the "brightness" doesn't address the problem. That just makes the whole screen darker or but the whites are still as bright. I'm still learning the laptop, maybe there is a contrast setting. Oh, and the trackpad on the 2015 doesn't feel like sandpaper. On the M1, the tip of my finger is numb most of the day. Anyway, for such a fanboi and you skipped the best MBP. Bummer for you. I can't imagine going from 2015 to 2016 and being satisfied with that. I'd have returned it the same day.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
8GB was a sad amount of RAM back then, and it's still a sad amount now. Ditto for the storage. I'm not complaining about the CPU at all, it's fine. I use an M1 daily, and for work just an M1 Pro and both are fine. I know there's a RAM shortage. But if RAM didn't matter, Apple wouldn't have stopped shipping 8GB configurations in the rest of their line. Starving these of RAM and storage is the way they've chosen to protect their fat margins of the MacBook Air. Which is fine. I just think these are best recommended only with a giant asterisk that they're for web tasks only, exactly like a Chromebook.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
I find this thread amusing. My M3 MacBook Pro just works. My family's iPhone 15s just work. My iPad Mini 6 just works. My wife's 3 year old iPad just works. Her 3 year old MacBook Air just works. My kids 3 year old M1 MacBook just works. I am an old man. My MCSE was on NT 3.51. I wrote my first code in 6502 ML. The first production network I handled used SNA. The level of Apple kit just working is a so far beyond anything I have experienced in 30+ years of being in tech.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Hm, I find that comparison a bit off. As a lover of both, Thinkpads (original IBM and Lenovo followups) AND macbooks, I would like to say that it IS possible to maintain macbooks, at least the older ones. My 2012'er MacBook Pro is holding up, parts like the sata-cable and worn out fan were replaced and the ram was upgraded. My Powerbook 530 hat replacable parts, even the G3 Pismo(?) one and an white ibook g3 is also serviceable if you're patient. Same happend for the thinkpads 360, 570, 600, X41t, X61s, T60, T61... hell. We even had chinese colleagues ordering for motherboards for us from china with changed firmware to run 201'er boards in X200 tablets. I became frustrated on thinkpads when Lenovo tried to mimick Apples lightweight AIO design and their first chicklet keyboard frustrated me. I changed all to apple then, because if both do weird things, why not using the more power efficent M1 (imho, maybe that has changed.) Do you remember the old thinkpad bios? Where the pointer was a flying duck? Do you remember opening a thinkpad and everything was labelled with colors and had small handles to change components quickly? Do remember changing ram on a powerbook? And do you remember how hard it was to find a new scsi disc drive for them? Recently, I got an nearly mint T420 at work as I needed something for a mobile job and I just felt my love for the black boxes again. Damn, I miss those days but I also would miss my retina (apple) or 4k screen (Lenovo) if I had to decide bet…
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Due to things like this I’m quite wary of buying a high end Apple machine as workhorse even though I’ve become a big fan of their products. Though I’m currently using an M1 and 2018 MacBook Pro without any problems they are company issued so I haven’t paid anything. Of late I’ve been getting this idea of building a high end desktop PC with Linux as a daily workhorse and use the lowest end MacBook for cases when I have to move around the house or work from office. When I’m paying $3000+ I expect local shops to be able to repair and service them without the manufacturer throwing a tantrum.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
PC laptops with similar build quality cost the same or more. x86 machines only compete when you don’t consider power consumption (which really matters for laptops). It’s so bad that most top end x86 machines won’t even try to hit those peak numbers unless the machine is plugged in and then only for short periods of time. My M1 beats most x86 machines even after it throttles and it’s over three years old now. My M3 Max machine blows away the x86 machines I run into and it does it while still having good battery life.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
FWIW, I've had a M1, M1 Pro, and M2 Max laptop (different work/personal machines) all with fans, but I've never heard them turn on in several years of development work, no matter how many windows, apps, etc. I had open or how many things I was compiling. The only times I heard the fan turn on were when the GPU was heavily burdened, like AAA games, especially when they're emulated in Rosetta or Wine. But for everything else, the fans never came on. These days, I suspect they'd come on for AI training (but I never tried). Just anecdotal data for anyone contemplating an upgrade to one of the fanned versions. They tend to be more powerful than the non-fanned versions, but in regular everyday use you would likely never hear them. I didn't even know they had fans until I tried to play graphics-intensive games on them.
Apple MacBook M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I like the aluminum bodies of macs, but I hate the flat keyboards. In my view, no laptop brand has had a good keyboard since the Thinkpad T420. In terms of build quality, apple laptops are pretty good, but I can't stand macOS and apple keeps fucking with their ports. My Inspiron 16 has a good glass screen and a pretty solid aluminum body. It's got all the ports I want (HDMI, USB-A 3.0, SD card reader, USB-C, and a 3.5mm headphone jack). Personally, the macbook pro my company issued me is one of my least favorite laptops I've ever used. I also had compatibility or performance problems with x86 based software when I got my first M1 macbook, I don't know if they're improved anything since then
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
In the last six months I have purchased: 16 inch M1 Max ~4k Apple Watch Ultra ~800 Air pods pro 2 ~250 13 inch M1 16 GB ~2000 = 7000 dollars. A huge spend and I don't regret one single purchase. Each subsequent product interfaces extremely well with the ecosystem. I no longer carry my phone with me 80% of the time. I bring my watch and usually have a laptop if needed.