The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs System76

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air.

Apple MacBook AirSystem76
Owners with an opinion1931312
Positive verdicts79% of 165369% of 280
Positive/negative since 2024657/19049/23
Happy after 3+ years15133
Longest happy owner14 yrs20 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryreliability and performance
Criticized forreliabilitybuild quality and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I bought a System 76 laptop a few years ago and stuff like this is why I went back to Apple. I was always dealing with one weird thing or another. One day it decides it wont wake from sleep if I have it in clamshell mode, another it decides it can't find my bluetooth peripherals. I finally rage quit when my webcam went down for no reason. I spent 2500 bucks on that thing and gave up on it in less than a year. Meanwhile, I have a 2015 MBP that runs like a champ. My new M1 air goes 2 days without a charge and I never have to think about dumb shit like waking from sleep. Oh and theres the resale value. I can't give away my S76 but I bet you if I put that 2015 MBP up on craigslist, it'll still fetch me a few hundred bucks... When I was a younger man with more free time I would have fought the good fight but these days? I just want my shit to work.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
Once the fanless M1 air came out, I could not use anything else. I pray the rumored 15 inch M2 air is also fanless with huge battery life and more ports. My S76 laptop just annoyed me. It was fine for a linux machine, but there was just so many little details, build quality, etc I missed from the mac. I also found a few bugs in their custom pop packages and I reported them. The first engineer that responded was honestly pretty rude and implied I didn't know what I was talking about. A second engineer responded and said in fact one of the things I reported was true and hard to fix unfortunately. About a month later I noticed an update went out that fixed the other thing I reported.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I own a System 76 laptop (the Oryx) and ultimately bought a MacBook Air m1 to replace it. I'm not sure how many people know this, but S76 doesn't make their own hardware and instead uses repackaged Clevo laptops. These machines are cheap, ugly, and heavy. Nothing about them feels particularly high quality. They charge a premium price so I'd expected more and was disappointed. Knowing what I know now, I would have gotten a Framework laptop for a first class linux experience. All that said, PopOS is my distro of choice. They really got a lot right there IMO. If they can get it together on the hardware front, might be worth another look in the future.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I strongly disagree with your assessment. First of all I don't know what kind of frankenstein Windows environment you are running to get those sorts of issues so lets put that aside. With Linux the issues are fundamental to how the OS is designed and maintained. Several of these issues were fixed only to come back one or two releases in the future. These sort of terrible regressions don't inspire confidence. You have listed excuse after excuse to justify these failures when in reality both other OSes have had these functions worked out over 10+ years ago. 1) I have heard this excuse before that I should stick to official Linux hardware. I have had issues with Thinkpads as well and some of these issues happened on a Thinkpad. I have also been hesitant to jump onboard System76 or Purism because their systems just look like junk and in 2021 when we have stunning Mac laptops with beautiful trackpads and retina displays and me entering my 30s I just don't have the stomach to spend hundreds of dollars on laptops that look like they came out of the mid to late 2000s. In the case of System76 they are rebadged Clevo systems from what I understand(could be wrong about this). So in reality I am paying for QA for this year of distro with no specific guarantee that I won't start hitting the same issues a few years down the road when the regressions start to come. There is no garuntee that System76/Purism will fix some small regression in a multi year old system. They suffer from the fact…
Switched from the Apple MacBook Air to the System76System76: Likes it
As a former Mac user, I'm really happy with my System76 linux laptops. The only tradeoff is the terrible built-in speakers. My Lemur is lighter and has better battery life than my Macbook Air and has been bulletproof despite my ill treatment. Each of my Macs, however, have had various hardware failures or the famous keyboard recall on the horrible touchbar Macbook Pro. I also prefer matte screens to glossy, so that's a win for me, but ymmv.
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralSystem76: Neutral
-MacBook Air 1.2GHz quad-core Intel (use as a home entertainment center) -Intel NUC i5 with 32g RAM (use for my self-hosted stuff) -M1 Max MBP (use for daily driver, usually) -System76 Thelio with 5950x and 64G RAM (use for heavy compute and US-based streaming) -Raspberry Pi (pi-hole DNS) -2014 MacBook Pro 16G RAM (old daily driver—incredible longevity)
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralSystem76: Neutral
I own a 14" System76 and a 13" MacBook Air and I hardly find any difference while working on the two. Its even more jarring especially because the Air's resolution is far worse (Non-retina vs full hd). I have always wanted to try out the Dell XPS 13, but its way too costly. For me, the choice is between a 13" laptop or something lower (12", perhaps).