The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Microsoft Surface Laptop

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook Air.

Apple MacBook AirMicrosoft Surface Laptop
Owners with an opinion193179
Positive verdicts79% of 165353% of 68
Positive/negative since 2024657/19019/23
Happy after 3+ years1510
Longest happy owner14 yrs2 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryperformance and build quality
Criticized forreliabilityreliability and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
Strawman. Because Apple designed it well. Metal’s not an issue. My legacy 2013 MacBook Air still looks and feels and opens like new. I was looking at Thinkpad Auras today. There are unaligned jutting design edges all over the thing. From a design perspective, I’ll take the smooth oblong squashed egg. Every PC laptop I’ve touched feels terrible to hold and carry. And they run Windows, and Linux only okay. Apple MacBooks are a long mile better than everything else and so I don’t care about upgraded memory — buy enough ram at purchase time and you don’t have to think about it again. Memory upgrades aren’t priced super well, granted, but I could never buy HP Dell Lenovo ever again. They’re terrible. I’ve had all of them. Ironically the best device I’ve had from the other side was a Surface Laptop. But I don’t do Microsoft anymore. And I don’t want to carry squeaky squishy bendy plastic. Most of all, I’m never getting on a customer support call with the outsourced vendors that do the support for those companies ever ever ever again. I’ll take a visit to an Apple store every day of the week.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
It's so bad that Microsoft is actually going to start preloading Office on boot to speed up the application start times. It was quite the shock to me recently when I had to use a Surface Laptop (the ARM one). Snapdragon X Elite & 32GB of RAM and took almost double the time to get to the desktop from a cold start compared to my M2 Air. Then even once everything was loaded, interacting with the system just did not feel responsive at all, the most egregious being file explorer and the right click menu. And I have my own gripes with macOS feeling like it's slow due to the animations and me wanting to move faster than it can. Windows used to happily oblige, but now it's laggy. Microsoft is too caught up in shoving Copilot everywhere to care though.
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
Ditto, I wouldn't quite say it flies on my M1 MBA, but performance is by no means frustratingly laggy. I use Inkscape a lot on both my MBA and Surface Laptop and it is much more frustrating on the latter device. The lack of support for fractional scaling is an annoyance on my 150% scaled Surface. The tiny UI has to be remedied by pinning a .bat to my taskbar and disguising it as Inkscape, with the following code: cd set GDK_SCALE=2 start inkscape.exe And within Inkscape using the Minwaita-Inkscape theme and 80% font scaling to scale back the otherwise-now-too-big UI. On both my Mac and PC, the main frustration once the UI is scaled correctly is that often closing pop-up windows (i.e. Document Properties) simply doesn't work. Sometimes using Inkscape's tab close button rather than the MacOS/Windows close window button works, but other times the whole app will freeze up and crash when attempting to close these pop-up windows. Have had this issue for multiple Inkscape versions now, hoping the devs find a way to fix it.
Switched from the Apple MacBook Air to the Microsoft Surface LaptopMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
I know that Windows 11 doesn't get a ton of love on HN, but I have successfully replaced my M1 MacBook Air with a Surface Laptop 7. The build quality is great, and I even think that the Surface's haptic trackpad is superior. However, I don't think anything on the market beats the Macbook's speaker quality.
Switched from the Apple MacBook Air to the Microsoft Surface LaptopMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
I picked up a Surface Laptop 2 a week ago, as a replacement for my older MacBook Air, and so far I’ve been pleased with it. The hardware may not have the fit and finish of a MacBook, but it’s still slim, lightweight and attractive in its own way. The screen is great. And that keyboard...just works. The article doesn’t mention the Surface product line, it doesn’t contribute much to Microsoft’s revenue, but it allows the company to present itself as a new Microsoft and demonstrate what’s possible with Windows.
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Neutral
It may still work. The prism emulation is pretty good, almost on par with Rosetta2. I have the surface laptop 7 with the X elite in it. The only thing I've ran into that outright didn't run was MSSQL server. It's not my main machine, that is still an M4 Macbook pro but I hop on it occasionally to keep up with what Windows is doing or if I need to help someone with something windows specific. I've got WSL2, Docker, VSCode, etc. all running just fine. It's decent, but not amazing. Feels a little slower than my M2 Air I have but not much, most of that is probably just windows being windows. Would be nice to be able to get Linux running on one of these
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
I have an M1 for personal use, and recently got a Surface L7 for work. Build quality wise, its the closet thing you're gonna find to a macbook that runs windows. I also run a custom Windows desktop and a synology NAS, so I like to consider myself mostly agnostic.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
An equivalent-specced Surface laptop would be the following specs: - 13" or 15" screen - Snapdragon X Elite (which still doesn't match M3 performance) - 16 GB memory - 512 GB SSD Surface laptop price is $1399 (13") or $1499 (15"), which is $100 cheaper for the 13" vs the equivalent MBA, and $200 cheaper for the equivalent MBA 15". The Snapdragon X Plus, which is what it looks like you priced out, is quite inferior to the Elite and even the older Apple M1/M2 series chips. This is all to say that neither is a bad buy, depending on your needs.