The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs LG Gram

Hacker News owners slightly favor the LG Gram.

Apple MacBook AirLG Gram
Owners with an opinion193136
Positive verdicts79% of 165388% of 33
Positive/negative since 2024657/19012/1
Happy after 3+ years1514
Longest happy owner14 yrs5 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryportability and battery
Criticized forreliabilitydisplay and sound
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itLG Gram: Likes it
But shitload of vendors won't bother and just sell you a "military grade" or, even in non-english speaking countriess, say a "MIL-SPEC Daniel Defense AR-15". They won't list every spec in detail. And they make good AR-15s (but not cheap). Anyone who thinks the triggers listed as MIL-SPEC from, say, Geissele here: https://geissele.com/triggers.html aren't totally fine is out of his mind. They're amazing triggers, widely used and loved. And they don't say which specs its passing (at least not on the main page): it's just MIL-SPEC. As a sidenote my very best laptop passes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MIL-STD-810 but most people will just say it's "military grade" or "MIL-SPEC". Guess what? Its screen never broke overnight like the one of my MacBook M1 Air did (the infamous "bendgate"). I can bend my LG Gram's screen and it's keeps working fine. I can let it drop. Friend who sold it to me stepped on it when he woke up once. There's a very big difference between saying: "There are shady vendors" and saying "Military specs do not exists and it's impossible for consumers to buy items passing military specifications" . Yes, there are dishonest vendors. Yes, military specs do exist. And, yes, it's possible for consumers to buy products passing (and even surpassing) actual military specs.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itLG Gram: Recommends it
> I wish there were a Linux machine with the hardware quality of a MacBook It really depends what you mean by "quality". To me first and foremost quality I look for in a laptop is for it to not break. As I'm a heavy desktop user, my laptop is typically with me on the couch or on vacation. Enter my MacBook Air M1: after 13 months, and sadly no extended warranty, the screen broke for no reason overnight. I literally closed it before going to bed and when I opened the lid the next day: screen broken. Some refer to that phenomenon as the "bendgate". And every time I see a Mac laptop I can't help but think "slick and good looking but brittle". There's a feeling of brittleness with Mac laptops that you don't have with, say, a Thinkpad. My absolute best laptop is a MIL-SPEC (I know, I know, there are many different types of military specs) LG Gram. Lighter than a MacBook too. And every single time I demo it to people I take the screen, I bent it left and right. This thing is rock solid. I happen to have this laptop (not my vid) and look at 34 seconds in the vid: https://youtu.be/herYV5TJ_m8 The guy literally throws my laptop (well, the same) down concrete stairs and the thing still just works fine. The friend who sold it to me (I bought it used) one day stepped on it when he woke up. No problemo. To me that is quality: something you can buy used and that is rock solid. Where are the vids of someone throwing a MacBook Air down the stairs and the thing keeps working? I'm trading a
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itLG Gram: Likes it
Are the screen more sturdy than on the MacBook Air M1? I really didn't like my M1 dying overnight after 13 months, when the base warranty had just expired and apple asked me 67% (!) of the price of what I paid the M1 to fix the screen. I didn't and I use it as a desktop since then, hooked to an external monitor. For comparison, my LG Gram can be casually thrown down concrete stairs [1] and shall happily keep working. I'm not asking for something as incredible as that LG Gram's screen (from a reliability point of view) but I'd like to know if these newer MacBook laptops have screens less fragile than the first M1 laptops. [1] Not my vid but it's my experience with that laptop. Cat can jump on it, previous owner did step on it while waking up: do that to a Mac M1 laptop and it dies instantly. But my "MILSPEC" LG Gram: you cannot really damage that laptop (look at 35 seconds): https://youtu.be/herYV5TJ_m8
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itLG Gram: Recommends it
> 12-year-old Thinkpad has outlasted two high-end Macbooks Nice! Our two MacBook Air from 2013 died at about the same time, about six months ago. Despite putting in a faster SSD and changing the battery: eventually RIP is RIP (and thanks for the 10 years). Our recent MacBook Air M1 lasted... 13 months. Upon waking up one morning the screen was fuxx0red. Meanwhile my 2017 LG Gram's screen is ultra flexible and sturdy and can deal with pretty much anything you throw at it, including its previous owner (a friend of mine) waking up one morning and stepping on it by mistake. You can also throw it down concrete stairs and it'll keep working fine: (skip to 0:34... video not made by me but it's basically my experience with that Laptop) https://youtu.be/herYV5TJ_m8 They're not cheap laptops. They're not "retina display". But, darn, can they take a beating. Not like the precious and ultra brittle porcelain that the latest Macbook are.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itLG Gram: Recommends it
Not GP but I'm very happy with mine. Can't speak for every model but I've got an old 15Z970 with 24 GB of RAM (from 2017 I think). LG Grams aren't cheap laptops. They don't have the retina display. But they're nice, lightweight (lighter than Mac laptops) and overall feel good. I'd say it doesn't feel as polished as the latest Mac laptops but it feels way sturdier. My M1 Macbook Air always felt like it's screen was brittle: some porcelaine to be manipulated with the greatest care or it'd break. And break it did, after 10 months, seemingly for no reason. While my 5 years old LG Gram is still going perfectly fine. I use it every time I'm not at my beasty desktop.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itLG Gram: Likes it
> There's an ongoing joke in the military, MIL-SPEC just means it's a piece of crap that's going to break pretty soon. Yeah well, my M1 MacBook Air just friggin' screen-died overnight ten days ago. On the other hand my military grade LG Gram is still working fine after years and years. I can hold the LG Gram's screen with both hands and start distorting it and it keeps working flawlessly: the screen is very flexible. That's how it was demo'ed to me and that's how I always demo it to people. That and it's lighter than a M1 MacBook Air (yup). It doesn't have a retina display. But it still works. I think Apple screwed up big times and I think these M1 laptops would never have passed any MIL-SPEC. They're brittle little things.
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralLG Gram: Likes it
I have moved from a 13" M1 Air to the 16" M1 Pro only because I wanted a bigger screen for traveling. I feel some buyer's remorse because it was more than twice as expensive, and I don't really care about the extra speed or memory (yet?). It's also really heavy, and I don't love its looks. What I'd absolutely buy is a 16" MacBook Air, like an Apple version of the LG Gram. Edit: For comparison, the 16" LG Gram with a discrete Nvidia GPU is exactly as light as the 13" M1 MacBook Air, and supposedly it has great battery life. And all those ports...sigh...
Switched from the Apple MacBook Air to the LG GramLG Gram: Recommends it
LG Gram 14 with i5 8th Gen with 8gb RAM and 256gb SSD. It has one extra slot each for RAM and SSD that I plan to fill later. Linux Mint 19.1 with dual boot to Windows that it came with - everything worked right out of the box. Things I love are 990grams weight, 14 hours battery (4.18 series kernel and mostly I use terminal, vim, Firefox; when I compile java applications regulalry, still get 9hours of battery); backlit keyboard and a very lovely FHD display (though the glare from lights is a bit more). It doesn't have dedicated graphics card and it doesn't feel sturdy like an all metal laptop - though it has survived several flights in a regular backpack in overhead compartment. I switched from MacBook Air to this. Mainly because the sharp edge in the front was getting tiresome while typing. Plus I didn't think any of the new Mac's are worth the outlandish premium for my mostly terminal driven work.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itLG Gram: Likes it
I carry an M1 Macbook Air (for xcode) and an LG Gram 17 running Kubuntu for everything else (which is most of what I do). The Gram is probably the best laptop I've ever owned (it replaced an XPS-15) - it's bigger (13" vs 17"), lighter (2oz less than the air) and gets crazy life out of the battery. When new, the Gram got 11-16 hours of battery (it now gets 8-10 hours) under development load (i.e running a node app, a go app and a Django backend, plus support servers). The Air hasn't been used as hard as the Gram, but it's battery gets similar performance. On the power management front, everything works on the air. On the Gram, hibernate is disabled, and sleep works (I've left the Gram in my bag over a three day weekend, and it was at about 20% on Tuesday when I opened it up). I ran Windows for about a week on the Gram and it did got less than eight hours of battery. No idea why.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itLG Gram: Likes it
> I'm almost ready to sell my DIY Windows framework and go back to mac. If you do so make sure to buy the longest extended warranty you can, covering the slightest tiny thing that can happen to your M1 Mac. Mine was a fine machine, zero bug, while the screen worked . These M1 Mac laptops have brittle porcelain screens. As someone put it here: it's the bend-gate all over again. FWIW I've got both a 2013 and a 2014 MacBook Air as well as a 4 years old (?) LG Gram laptop. They all have their screens still working fine and I'm pretty sure I know how to handle a laptop: these new M1 laptops are just fragile.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itLG Gram: Likes it
Just to give another opinion to restore some balance in the force... 10 to 11 months in the screen of my MacBook Air M1 died. It was working before going to sleep, had a protective case cover and when the wife woke up, the screen was showing garbage. I saw several pictures online of the exact same issue. As I had not one but two older MacBook Air, from 2013 and 2014 IIRC, that never had any issue I didn't even think about buying an additional warranty. Paid the M1 1000 EUR, Apple is asking 680 EUR to fix the screen. To add insult to injury they're asking 50 EUR to ship the broken M1 back. I'm done with Apple. Wife, who runs her SME using Google stuff (G Suite / workspace / whatever), now replaced her aging MacBook Air with a 300 EUR Chromebook and she's perfectly happy (obviously wouldn't work for a software dev but it's just to point out that a company can lose customers). There was no way she'd buy a new M1 after that "we'll fix your broken screen for 68% of the MSRP" episode. If you're serious about buying a piece of equipment as brittle as the M1 laptop, make sure to buy the best Apple warranty you can and make sure to have a plan B for when it'll fail. The M1 was a nice machine when it worked . It's brittle. Many people have the exact same problem as we did. So, yeah, give even more money to Apple by buying the best warranty you can because for all the marvel that the M1 is, it's very certainly not as sturdy as my LG Gram (my LG Gram is lighter and has 24 GB…
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itLG Gram: Likes it
> What happens when a Chromebook or your MIL-SPEC LG laptop breaks? Chromebook: if in warranty fix, if out of warranty, buy two more Chromebooks for the price of one M1 Macbook Air screen. LG Gram: LG has a pretty good repair network. My team (5) has been using LG Gram 17" laptops running Ubuntu for about a year, and one person managed to chip the paint (it's anodized black on a metal body), but that was about it. They've been surprisingly sturdy despite weighing a few ounces more than a 13" macbook air. Also, battery life is on par with the M1 air I carry for occasionally dealing with App Store issues.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itLG Gram: Likes it
So last week I was quoted, by Apple, 680 EUR to fix the cracked screen of my 1000 EUR MacBook Air M1. I'm giving them the finger but, to add insult to injury, I still need to pay 50 EUR to get the computer back. It's sad because I was satisfied by my two previous MacBook Air (non retina / non M1) and I was satisfied by my Mac Mini. But now the Apple love story at home is done. Now recommending Chromebooks to the 65 years+ around us (where we used to recommend Apple). In case there's any class action lawsuit in Europe over this new M1 bend-gate I'll be sure to join and donate to the cause. Typing this from my MIL-SPEC LG Gram, which is an actual proper, sturdy and lighter than any Mac laptop. This comment is what you reap for screwing people over.