The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Lenovo ThinkPad T series

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air.

Apple MacBook AirLenovo ThinkPad T series
Owners with an opinion193110
Positive verdicts79% of 165390% of 10
Positive/negative since 2024657/1900/1
Happy after 3+ years1510
Longest happy owner14 yrs–
Praised forperformance and batterycomfort and software
Criticized forreliabilitybattery and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad T series to the Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Air: Neutral
Software Engineer, use it partially for private and professional purposes. In historical Order: Thinkpad X201, Then a Thinkpad T450s, currently a Macbook Air M2, usually in the biggest configuration. Usually I use it about 7 years. Not because it doesn't work anymore, but because it gets too slow for what I am doing with it. In one case it was the switch from C++/C# to Rust and the compile times became unbearable. The next switch might be because of LLMs.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad T series to the Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Air: Likes it
I'm still using my MacBook Air M1 with 8gb of Ram as my personal workhorse. It runs docker desktop and VSC better than my T14 whatever windows machine with 32gb ram. But that is windows and it has a bunch of enterprise stuff running. I assume it would work better with Linux, or even windows without whatever our IT does to control it. With Nvidia Now I can even play games on it, though I wouldn't recommend it for any serious gamers.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad T series to the Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Air: Likes it
That would also apply to Apple products then, and especially so to their laptops. I actually bought a MacBook Air recently and the thing that I like most about it is how comfortable the keyboard and especially the trackpad is compared even to high-end ThinkPads. And, on the other hand, the trackpad on my T14s is certainly quite sufficient to operate it, so this comfort that MacBook offers is beyond the bare necessity of function.
Switched from the Apple MacBook Air to the Lenovo ThinkPad T seriesLenovo ThinkPad T series: Doesn’t like it
They universally suck, and I always forget to take them. Same for LTE-to-WiFi hotspots. (Edited to add: one of the great things about a MacBook [Air] is supposed to be that you just throw them in your backpack, and you can be productive, like, anywhere, without having to worry about battery life, or anything. Still, 'lack of connectivity' kinda kills that dream, which means I still carry my ThinkPad T14 gen3 (despite its power management flaws) or Surface Go2 (Potato Inside ), where I would rather take my MacBook)
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad T series to the Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Air: Likes it
I would really like this. I opened up my 2018 t480 thinkpad with arch and xfce on it today, after half a year of using the M1 MBA exclusively, and I realized how much I truly miss using Linux. I don't get a good computingfeel out of macOS -- the last time I did was circa snow leopard. It's someone else's system that I'm allowed to use. The t480 is really noticeably slower than the MBA though it has twice the RAM. I didn't think there was anything wrong with that at the time, though. I have got a more powerful computer now -- but how much of that power is for me to wield?
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad T series to the Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Air: Likes it
I was a ThinkPad maximalist in my personal computing life for the last 5ish years. This year, I needed to interview for jobs without having access to a "work" laptop for the task (i.e. an overspecced MacBook Pro). Faced with the prospects of subjecting my ThinkPad/vim machine to video calls, I more or less immediately decided to fork over the money for an M2 MacBook Air. Unfortunately for my identity as a person invested in my principles, it's been a delightful experience. I'm glad that I have my ThinkPad (and its stack of batteries) in the closet – it'll always be there, and work exactly as I want it to. But I can already tell I'm going to drive this MacBook into the ground over the next 10 years. I know that I won't be able to repair it when it (eventually) degrades, but the diff of convenience in day to day ops pays for that inconvenience, in my experience. YMMV.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad T series to the Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Air: Recommends it
I guess it comes down to how much you enjoy tearing your hair out fixing other peoples bugs or dealing with their crappy hardware. I've used a 2010 MBA running OS X and Win 7 for the last 4 years. I max'ed out its specs back then and paid about $2k, including an Apple Care warranty which has since expired unused. I've had at least half a dozen Thinkpads before this, and none of them ever came close to surviving this long. My first Thinkpad was a 600, followed by a T20, etc. My last Thinkpad, a T410s, lasted less than 13 months before the LCD failed, same as a dozen others just like it around the office purchased around the same time. That's when I bought the MBA on my own dime. Part of it is this MBA hit a sweet spot in the upgrade cycle where SSD/CPU/RAM has proven good enough to keep for 4 years, and really shows little signs of slowing for most workloads, and could keep going strong for several years longer. But the physical hardware has held up astonishingly well. It's the most stable PC running Windows I've ever had. Thinking back on it... I don't think it has EVER blue screened, and I never reboot it except for critical updates. The only gripe I have with the hardware is the Windows BootCamp driver for the combined mic/headphone jack doesn't switch the mic on when you plug in a proper headset, so it's stuck using the internal mic. But the built-in mic is so good, I've never bothered buying the $20 USB mic to workaround the issue. It would be hard to tally the number of
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad T series: Likes it
Thinkpads typically have magnesium cases, not plastic, and the older models have rollcages so they can take a beating like no other. I have an m1 air and while it feels sturdy, I have no doubt that X220 can withstand much more abuse than my macbook. Also, I have no doubt the X220 is more pleasant to type on, because older thinkpads have keyboards that have no equal in the laptop space. I would say my macbook has a satisfactory keyboard, but it is clearly a step down from the T series thinkpad it replaced. Still though, the macbook is for me overall the better package than any thinkpad that was in my budget range.