The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Dell XPS 13

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air.

Apple MacBook AirDell XPS 13
Owners with an opinion1931256
Positive verdicts79% of 165364% of 222
Positive/negative since 2024657/19023/22
Happy after 3+ years15122
Longest happy owner14 yrs12 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryreliability and display
Criticized forreliabilitybattery and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS 13: Doesn’t like it
Two aspects in which Apple's newest Macbook Airs fit at least my own "peak laptop" definition are: 1) no fans whatsoever 2) no coil whine when I plug my headphones in and stress the CPU The keyboard is exactly the right size and the right font for me, but I'll concede that muscle memory is an individual thing. I've owned Apple's laptops and keyboards made in 2005, 2007, 2010, 2015, 2019, and 2022, and they are very hell-bent on being consistent about key size and placement, I should give it to them. I'd like a Linux laptop that would beat this. XPS13 is a close contender because that 3840x2400 screen is the right kind of ratio and super crisp, but man, that fan noise and the coil whine are just killing the mood. Maybe Thinkpad X13s, but Linux support and its screen are both very meh at this point.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS 13: Doesn’t like it
How does this not answer your question? If the XPS was more expensive even before adjusting to inflation, than the answer is no: the macbook was not the most expensive computer I ever bought (both adjusting and not-adjusting to inflation). The Dell was XPS 13 (9350) bought Janaury 2016 for €2,105. The Macbook is M1 Macbook Air (the highest end model of which), bought June 2021 for €1,598. In both cases I wasn't trying to save money and was happily paying a premium for (within reason) the best laptop I could get, as far as I could tell from online reviews. I bought both of these directly from Dell's and directly from Apple's respective online shops. The latter is radically higher performance while also being much better in many other ways (build quality, battery life, reliability, etc). I promise you I'm not getting a commission from Apple, in fact there's a lot of stuff they do that I deeply dislike :)
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS 13: Doesn’t like it
I have the cheapest M1 Air model for personal use and it's been great. Although I wouldn't have gotten it if my old XPS 13 (Intel i5 gen 8 I think) didn't have such a bad touchpad and a bad feeling keyboard compared to this. One thing that I didn't see mentioned yet is that for Podman to work there is some fiddling required. At least when installed through Homebrew in a non-standard directory (my homebrew dir is under my user home), qemu just wasn't able to start the container VM and I had to find a way to install Podman with an older qemu version (pre-7.x) for it to work at all which involved downloading the homebrew formula and stabbing it with a fork
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS 13: Neutral
My experience of 4 years with Linux on Dell XPS 13": - WiFi stability issues with the Killer WiFi NIC were so severe at some point that I bought an Intel WiFi NIC only to learn that it's not replaceable in 9370 (but it is in 9360). A bit later I bought an external USB WiFi dongle which brought some connection stability while trading off connection speed. I sank some time into understanding and debugging firmware, without good results. A script that pings the router in a loop and reloads the connection when needed makes YouTube usable, but downloading any large files without retries was a major headache for a long time. Now it's less of a headache: maybe the firmware has finally caught up. - Sleep on Linux can be indeed unstable; sometime I find my laptop out of battery after sleep, apparently because it wakes up on its own from time to time. - Camera position below the display makes it very awkward for video calls. If I'm not mistaken, this was solved in newer models. - Keyboard is quite pleasant to use, but its build quality could be better: plastic keys started to peel off after four years. In comparison, a twice as old MacBook Air keyboard still holds together very well despite heavy usage. - Trackpad has been working well for me on Linux, I'm satisfied and don't have any complaints (I might be a very undemanding keyboard-oriented user though). - The laptop screen is high quality, but its narrow aspect ratio feels a bit off, I'd appreciate more vertical space. - My main mo
Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itDell XPS 13: Neutral
I spent over $4,000 each on the last 2 MacBook Pro models. Good screen, bad keyboard, heavy. This year I spent $15,000 on a Mac Pro and love it. I also bought the 2019 Dell XPS 13, which is ok. But my favorite computer purchase this year is a refurbed 2015 MacBook Air with an i7 and 1 TB SSD for $800. I tried to move away from MB Airs starting in 2017 but they remain my favorite coding environment. Screen not as good as a Retina but it works at 2560x1440 on an external monitor when I care. Slips easily into a backpack, great fit and finish, obviously plenty fast for full stack web dev.
Switched from the Dell XPS 13 to the Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Air: Likes it
Yes, it was. Previously, I had an XPS 13” that was pretty decent, and then an Intel Air, which was even better. I bought an M1 Air, base model, at launch, and was blown away. For once, a manufacturer wasn’t lying about battery life. What Apple has achieved with their SoC is nothing short of revolutionary. They make the best laptops by any conceivable metric, and it isn’t even close.
Switched from the Apple MacBook Air to the Dell XPS 13Dell XPS 13: Likes it
I previously had two MacBook airs, and then switched to the XPS 13 & Ubuntu + gnome. And presently I have been given a MacBook Pro for a recent job. From a software perspective, I now love the XPS. And all the hardware on that model more or less worked out of the box. And any minor issues, I was able to fix with some tweaking. Which was annoying at the time, but always granted me a stronger appreciation for and understanding of how my computer worked. 18.04 to 20.04 upgrade was a pain, had to re-apply many changes I’d made during the initial install. But since then it’s been smooth sailing again. No day to day problems. Things I once missed about OSX, I now realise are better on gnome. Capability to snap / move windows around with keyboard controls. But the MacBook keyword is just damn nicer. And the touchpad. Tho I hardly use that now. I use an external keyboard, but I’ll probably buy a Mac external keyboard for my XPS now, as the recent move back has been a stronger reminder of how much nicer they are. Gaming and music production are the only things I haven’t been able to do on the XPS. Not that I do any gaming anymore. And the focus rite 2i2 worked straight out of the box with reaper, which was cool. Tho if I were doing anything more serious I’d just get a Mac. Would not touch windows. All in all, for dev, I’m happy with the XPS and Ubuntu.
Switched from the Apple MacBook Air to the Dell XPS 13Dell XPS 13: Recommends it
I've had the XPS 13 for almost a year now for home use and it's been great. The form factor is pretty much perfect for me and it looks super sleek. Performance for coding is good, and even some games like Rocket League work pretty well. I had a 13" inch Air previously, and while the Dell trackpad is not quite as good, I much prefer the XPS. The only downside that should put people off is the coil whine. Mine is thankfully present only when compiling large projects, but some people do report a constant whine. Also, I had to get the larger resolution screen which means you need to scale your desktop to be able to read anything. Another trade off is the 2x TB connection, but apparently it works OK for even external GPUs, something I've considered. All in all, it's pretty well rounded for it's size and I'd recommend anyone looking for the form factor to consider it.
Switched from the Dell XPS 13 to the Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Air: Likes it
I had been trying to find a decent developer's laptop for some time, and it led me to the xps 13 "developer edition" (the predecessor to this one). Keep in mind that I really wanted to like that laptop. However, in the end, I went back to my macbook air. There were just too many small headaches to deal with. I'll list them here. I'd like to know if there are any improvements this time around. I'd be curious to know if they're going to do another "developer edition" for this new model. 1) The touchpad sensitivity was way off in ubuntu, and I couldn't use normal configs to tune it properly. Sounds like they fixed it. 2) The wifi range was very poor compared to mba. 3) Battery life was not as good as mba. 4) Ubuntu wasn't very good at scaling high dpi resolutions on smaller displays. The mba I have doesn't have a high dpi, and I don't need it for my work. FWIW, the retina class displays in the mbp all are perfect. 5) The mba are better balanced. The xps13 was a little wobbly since the weight was not well distributed. It was also slightly harder to open and close. Honestly, all of these things add up. Darwin isn't a "true" *nix, but it's close enough for me. If I'm off the mark on these issues these days, let me know.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS 13: Likes it
At that time I enjoyed my X220. To be sincere, the form-factor and practicality moving from home to work and having the dock. Then the XPS 13 was more perfect for me because I could attach three external monitors and have power just via a single Thunderbolt cable (no more custom docks). The crux for all of these was the battery daily duration and replacement after a few years. In that context the MacBook Airs excel at a point that more expensive and powerful Apple notebooks such as the MacBook Pro cannot sustain a "marathon" without a charger. The issue with the Airs is that you cannot currently connect three external monitors (without doing very hacky things), but this is just a question of time. Also, this obsession from Apple about not having touch screens in notebooks because they also sell iPads is disturbing. Finally, an XPS 13 with good battery support (assuming ARM) and good Linux power handling will, probably, be the best notebook available. (would love if they remove the XPS 13 fan and there are more non-moving part notebooks)
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itDell XPS 13: Doesn’t like it
> There was another Intel related issue with this laptop also; the gpu would freeze/panic intermittently, multiple times a day. I had this on my Dell XPS13 (9310) as well, although in my case it was a few times a week, maybe .5 times a day. It also seemed to almost always trigger when kwin was animating something, particularly switching to another virtual desktop, but never when playing any games. I can't imagine why, but the problem mostly went away when I turned off all animations in kwin, and seems to have gone away completely sometime about a year or so ago. All in all, it's still a better experience than the Macbook Air I was using prior to having this XPS13... That damn Macbook loved to vomit onto the screen and lock up without warning. No dust, thermals seemed fine, battery was healthy... no clue what was wrong with it. And without many exposed settings to fiddle with.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS 13: Likes it
My older laptops died quickly, with pretty bad hardware faults within 2-3 years. After those first few laptops, I have a 2011 MBA that's chugging along fine (manually replaced the battery), as well as a ~2016 XPS 13 9350 (also manually replaced the battery) and a 3 year old Gigabyte gaming laptop that are all working fine. So for me I'd say mean time to failure has been increasing.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS 13: Likes it
Yeah. To each of their own, but I was actually surprised that the verdict in the end was "When combined with an iPhone it makes for an unbeatable user experience." I loved Macs after using my 2012 Air for five years (my parents used it until last year) and MBP 2015 for work. Then they got me MPB 2018 and that was enough Apple for me. It was absolutely terrible. I don't care how many times I have to reinstall Arch to my Dell XPS 13, it's still a better experience.