The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Dell XPS

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air.

Apple MacBook AirDell XPS
Owners with an opinion1931659
Positive verdicts79% of 165348% of 583
Positive/negative since 2024657/19072/97
Happy after 3+ years15149
Longest happy owner14 yrs20 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryreliability and performance
Criticized forreliabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
The camera on the Surface is nowhere near as good as on my M1 Macbook Air, either. That seems to be a weird blind spot on laptops in general, it's very obviously an afterthought on my personal Dell XPS as well.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
The Macbook M2 Air running Asahi Linux is easily my favorite Linux laptop ever, far superior to any Thinkpad or Dell XPS I've owned, imo. I think things like Thunderbolt and some DisplayPort features are missing, but I have never needed this as it is purely a laptop for me. But it has everything else I could want: suspend/sleep, proper frequency scaling, great GPU drivers, USB/wifi/bluetooth, speakers, brightness/keyboard settings, etc. The webcam works I think but I haven't tried it. The battery life is great, though macOS is still quite a ways ahead in that department.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I was given a 2023 Dell XPS 13 for work. I was pretty stoked to go back to an XPS after using one in 2019 for work. For some reason, the MOBO was dying slowly after a year. My other coworkers also reported similar problems. Lenovo-wise: My personal Thinkpad X1 Extreme was a champ for 7+ years, and a few P series I've used over the years since 2021 were also great. At the end, I just built a desktop and use a Macbook Air. So far so good.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
My older Dell XPS Windows 10 laptop was due for an upgrade, and it was new enough that it supports Windows 11. Microsoft's end-of-life of 10, constant prodding to upgrade and Dell's terrible redesign of the XPS series made me look at my options. I ended up with an M4 MacBook Air and couldn't be happier.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I loathe macOS but stick with it mostly for the hardware. I use a beefed-up 16-inch M3 Max for work and a baseline 15-inch MacBook Air for writing and OSS work. I love the Air’s hardware and wouldn’t trade it for anything. Before switching to Mac, I was running a maxed-out 16-inch Dell XPS and enjoyed using Ubuntu and Pop!_OS on it. But the hardware just wasn’t there—the trackpad felt cheap, and the keyboard would creak. There were just too many small issues for such an expensive device. Otherwise, macOS is bloated, slow, and has horrible window management. I also prefer GNU tooling over BSD, and having to install everything separately is an extra hassle. Plus, it’s getting more restrictive over the years, which I’m not a fan of.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I had a 2021 model. It was pretty poor in all aspects. Slow, laggy on the desktop just clicking around. Loud when doing anything resembling work. Very poor audio. Bad keyboard. 4 hour battery. I switched to a new M1 MacBook Air and it was like going from a Cessna 150 to an F-15. Everything on the M1 MBA was decades ahead of the XPS. Everyone and their brother now sells a much better product than XPS, and often for nearly half the cash. I picked up an Asus Vivo last year. Very nice product, half the cost of the XPS they had on offer, but with the same specs and screen. It feels like it was engineered as a unit, much like the MBA. The XPS in comparison is a parts bin special.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itDell XPS: Likes it
I discovered that in a weird limbo: I updated to Windows 11 on an "old" XPS 13, and never used that device again in Windows. Several years later tried to use Windows 11 there for a specific purpose and it says that I don't have the required hardware. It is interesting that around this time (COVID age) I started using the MB Air M1 and couldn't connect many external monitors while my "old" XPS 13 could be plugged to any Thunderbolt dock and works incredible well, even without configuring anything special in Linux. I don't think this is a benefit for a Microsoft strategy but that many people there should be layoff. It is completely contrary with their current developer strategy. Also, privacy-wise you cannot now for sure if they are sending your keystrokes via telemetry... as a negligence.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itDell XPS: Likes it
I've seen reviews of the latest 13 inch Dell XPS and it's both more powerful and less energy hungry than the M3 in a MacBook air. It uses the Snapdragon Elite X ARM cpu. It also blows the latest mobile i7 ultra 155H on the same XPS 13 in performance while lasting almost 20 hours (compared to Intel's 6). The comparisons are made on software that runs on both (Geekbench, handbrake) but it's clear that there is a huge momentum building for windows on arm.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Neutral
I wonder when they will deliver. I started using Apple when the M1 was launched, the battery duration and the no moving parts (e.g. fan) in the Air plays in a different league. I continue to have a love "relationship" with my "old" XPSs but I can only use them plugged or buying a new battery every year... BTW the Thunderbolt support on the 2018 XPS continues to be superior to Apple now (e.g. more monitors) but the battery duration is a lifechanger.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Neutral
People evacuate with their luggage because in times of high stress, we fall back on habit. What do we do when it's time to leave an aircraft? We make sure we have all our belongings with us! That's just one reason why it's important to listen to the safety briefing, even if you've heard it before. The repeated drill helps us to remember what to do, even when there's added stress.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
Bizarre bitterness. You really think nobody is buying Macs on their merit? Maybe you're European and apple products cost a lot more where you live? In the states, base model MacBook Airs are frequently ~$800 on sale. You can get an official refurb MacBook Air or Pro with 16GB/1TB for ~$1300 from Apple's website right now. Those machines are priced competitively when compared to Dell XPS, new ThinkPads, etc. They also have much better battery life, screens, and overall build quality compared to those machines. Also MacOS is, for all its faults, normie-accessible unlike Linux and ad-free unlike Windows.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
16GB base would be nice but given Apple wanting to keep the entry price as low as possible I can't see it happening for a few more years. On the plus side I do find the 8GB unified memory design makes an 8GB Apple Silicon system "feel" like a 16GB Intel/AMD system in terms of memory use. It isn't identical and you can notice the difference at times but an 8GB Windows/Intel laptop such as a Dell XPS side by side with an 8GB MacBook Air and the Air feels a far better machine over all when using it normally.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
Dell XPS spec’d to meet the 15” MacBook Air requires the nicer screen which makes it $2,000, the screen is higher resolution than the MBA but it’s 100 nits less bright. MacBook Air is $1,700 after adding memory and storage to meet the XPS. The MBA is $300 cheaper for a laptop that is thinner, the same or better specs in almost every category, miles better better build quality (plastic trash vs aluminum) and actually has a network of stores throughout the world. So nowhere close to the 15” MBA, but I appreciate you trying. The T15 isn’t available so I’ll look at the T16. The cheapest T16 is $1,570. The comparable MacBook Air is $1,500. The T16 has a 300 nits low resolution screen, slow DDR4 RAM (didn’t know they made RAM this slow these days), and is made of cheap plastic. And again, no worldwide network of stores to support your device. So you’ve really failed to come anywhere close to the specs, build quality or support system of a MacBook.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Neutral
Apple provides a clear and beneficial point of difference. They are vertically integrated and now with Apple silicon, have arguably the best productivity laptops on the market. My M2 Air, lets me do all the personal dev and admin work my XPS 17 does, but I can easily go several days without a charge. My work provided MBP will easily go all day on a single charge and have plenty of charge left. Linux provides easily the best dev environment, is free, gives you all the control you could possible want, runs on lots of hardware and is speedy even on old hardware. Most of the internet is probably hosted on some flavour of linux, and open source frameworks so it's easy for you to do the same. Windows is good for games and if you need to use Excel? It also has the best drivers for my printer. Am I being unfair here?
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I can confirm that various Dell XPS 15 models and Microsoft Surface Book 2 and 3 models are just not usable without the power plug for my software development (and very rare gaming) needs. I also need the power plug for a simple thing like a Microsoft Teams meeting that last longer than one hour. Compare that to my MacBook Air M1 which runs for a full day easily. Also, standby works. With Dell I learned it's better to always shut down.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itDell XPS: Likes it
I've been using XPS 15 for many years and always felt that the trackpad experience is better (definitely in terms in accuracy and precission), and my encounters with partner's M1 air always make me question if I'm doing 'it' wrong (even after playing with the laptop for a whole day). This frustration once led me to search for turning off the acceleration setting, which, last I searched, wasn't easily tweakable. Anyone shares similar feeling when it comes to the trackpad?
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I've noticed they have gotten worse. After three bad MacBook Pros in a row, I bought a used 2015 MacBook Air, which has never given me a problem. The pros all had battery/power issues, shutting down randomly several times a day. The keyboards were also horrible. I've been a Thinkpad fan for years, and I use a Carbon X1 with Linux outside of work. No complaints about that, though I do wonder if it's as physically durable as the older, bulkier models. I've noticed Lenovo is putting out more consumer grade laptops now. I don't know about their quality, but it doesn't seem as high as their professional line. My son has a Dell XPS 15, and had to replace a loud, failing fan after a year. I suppose manufacturers face a lot of pressure selling to consumers who don't know what to look for in terms of quality and don't understand why two visually similar machines with similar specs would be priced so differently. The low-end machines in Walmart look just like the high-end machines at Best Buy. The business grade machines from Lenovo, Dell, and HP have incentive to be higher quality because businesses often buy them with high level service plans. Lenovo, Dell and HP really don't want to send techs into the field to service laptops if they can avoid it, and the best way to avoid that is to build a good product.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I'm curious; what external devices are you always needing connected to your laptop? What is this "extra hardware" and "accessories" that you need (and which you seem to think most people also need)? In my case, the port expander is smaller than a phone, and I rarely need it. My laptop has 2TB of drive space, so I don't need external storage except occasionally at home to do a physical backup. But my important data is frequently syncing to the cloud, so I don't need to travel with a backup drive. So more than 99% of the time, all I need is the laptop (and usually internet, which I have via wifi or mobile phone hotspot. And with one 65W Anker power adapter, I have 2 USB and 1 USB-C power so I can charge my laptop, phone, and a third small device if necessary. The MB Air is very thin, pretty light, and very rigid. That makes traveling so much more pleasant compared to the bulky heavy XPS 15 I previously had. Yes, I only have 13" display now instead of 15", but the difference in screen real estate isn't very significant.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
MBA 16gb / 256ssd - It has pretty much ruined other PCs for me - it runs rings around my work provided Dell XPS / I7/ 32gb - and it has completely replaced my tablet (the instant on feature / battery life and size rendering the tablet obsolete) - I wish I'd got the 512gb model - I only use docker for postgres but I've had no problems - I usually run Webstorm, Figma, countless Chrome tabs Spotify hooked up to a Samsung Ultrawide 5120 x 1440 and it doesn't skip a bit.