The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Asus Zenbook

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air.

Apple MacBook AirAsus Zenbook
Owners with an opinion1931109
Positive verdicts79% of 165376% of 99
Positive/negative since 2024657/19018/8
Happy after 3+ years15111
Longest happy owner14 yrs10 yrs
Praised forperformance and batterydisplay and performance
Criticized forreliabilityreliability and ergonomics
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Likes itAsus Zenbook: Doesn’t like it
I have an M4 air. It’s a nice machine, but I do miss the non-reflective screen of my earlier Asus zenbook (similar size, weight, fanless, decent ergonomics, matte screen, but bog slow). It seems the M5 air still has non non-reflective screen option, which is very unfortunate.
Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itAsus Zenbook: Doesn’t like it
For anyone else curious, the A14 is slightly larger, but a bit lighter, than the MacBook Air. When I think “teeny-tiny”, I’m expecting it to be physically smaller than the Air, so I feel a bit setup for disappointment by that headline. I don’t know that I’d use that term with any 14” laptop. The details on all of that can be found here: https://www.asus.com/us/laptops/for-home/zenbook/asus-zenboo... https://www.apple.com/macbook-air/specs/ Unless I desperately needed Windows, I think I’d go with the Air. I tend not to like copycat products, and even the Asus tech spec pages feel very Apple inspired. I actually used conventions from the Apple site to find how to switch to the Asus tech specs.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itAsus Zenbook: Neutral
Screen on my Zenbook has touch layer, that makes glass a bit thicker I guess. And yes I keep it in stuffed in backpack and sometimes drop it. It is a tool, not museum exponate! I had other laptops that left fingerprints. But Macbook Air had glass so thin it would randomly pop from temperature difference (well known issue)! Nobody is forcing you to carry brick around. But some people like to carry brick and Apple should make a new model just for them (MacBrick). Is "wash your hands before use" mentioned in macbook manual? And how do you even clean keyboard on Macbooks? That thing falls apart with a bad look, and it costs like $800 to replace. I can not imagine removing key caps just to clean it up!
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itAsus Zenbook: Doesn’t like it
Sadly, Qualcom's performance is still laughable compared to Apple's M1. You can get a Macbook air for around the same price that runs twice as fast (and probably has better speakers). If you intend to run Windows, you'll also run into slower x64 applications more often than with a Mac. I'm really not sure what the advantage would be for picking a Qualcom processor over getting an i3 or lower end AMD APU. Someone really needs to step up ARM processor design because no matter how much I detest Apple's business practices, I can't deny that their ARM chip is far superior to the rest of the market.
Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itAsus Zenbook: Doesn’t like it
I tried the Zenbook for a year, but the GPU didn't listen to sleep/lid close events even after trying several fresh kernels, the Wifi wakeup on linux sucks compared to macos (even with the mDNSresponder desaster), the trackpad was much worse. In the end it burnt/overheated because of the overheated GPU. The casing was also too edgy, I constantly did hurt myself with the right hand. A fully upgraded MacBook Air is still the best. (i7, 500GB HD, 16GB RAM) I got several of them. Lenovo is too heavy to carry around. Even a MBP is too heavy and bulky for me. The Elitebook has no 500GB HD available and also only 16GB RAM.
Switched from the Asus Zenbook to the Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Air: Likes it
> You could buy a faster Intel or AND machine for less money Yes, but Apple has a great combination of high performance (laptop-wise), long battery life and high portability. Before I had the Zenbook series where you had the high end with the i-5 chips that died in 2-3 hours, or the low end that lived 5-6 hours but could barely play a video in 1080p (IIRC, from memory). With the Air for example I have it all; very long battery life, pretty high performance (more than enough for what I use it), super portable, and a great keyboard+trackpad. The only thing I'm missing is Linux :)
Switched from the Apple MacBook Air to the Asus ZenbookAsus Zenbook: Likes it
I've seen your post as a comment before. For India, I recommend buying Dell / Lenovo if you really want on-site repairs for cheap, otherwise I recommend Asus. I recently bought Asus Zenbook 14 Oled (12th gen) over M1 MacBook Air and I absolutely love it. It has 75Wh battery, excellent speakers and with a nice 90Hz 14inch display. However, I can't use Fedora on it since sound over speaker doesn't work yet. Dell's Inspiron 14 is a decent purchase for around 65k ( with on-site & accidental damage warranty ) On a side note, my gaming laptop MSI GF 65 died and I was able to walk into a service centre in Bangalore, and they literally replaced the motherboard for free and returned it in 3 weeks. The entire process was extremely simple.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itAsus Zenbook: Likes it
My last experience is an Asus Zenbook - long-lasting, thin and light, with plenty of RAM 32, windows 11. Switched to Mac Air M1 6 months ago and it's much better: faster, no heat, no fan, instant start, no glitches with the lid closed, etc.