The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Apple MacBook Pro M4

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook Air.

Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Pro M4
Owners with an opinion1931105
Positive verdicts79% of 165356% of 88
Positive/negative since 2024657/19049/39
Happy after 3+ years1510
Longest happy owner14 yrs1 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryperformance and battery
Criticized forreliabilitysoftware and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: NeutralApple MacBook Pro M4: Likes it
This solidifies my satisfaction with my choice of a mid-spec’d M4 Pro to replace my M1 Air. I wanted more RAM, so I went with the middle option with 24 GB. Similarly, I mostly care about single-core performance, so the Max didn’t seem like a huge deal. I’m still getting used to the weight of a 14” Pro vs. a 13” Air, but the additional screen size is terrific. The only thing I’m unsure about is the matte screen option. I saw screenshots that seemed as though contrast gets blown out, so I kept the glossy. I’ve seen others say at normal laptop viewing angles, this is not the case.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M4: Likes it
Linux on Mac Pro 5.1 from 2009 and 2017 MacBook Air, both working perfectly. I prefer actually both to my corporate issue M4 one with MacOS. I'm not a fan of the Mac UX, but the hardware seems pretty damn good and the lifespan extends with it. If I'd have no limitations though I'd prefer the Framework, but not very clearly.
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralApple MacBook Pro M4: Neutral
I have the Q11 too (and I fully agree with your appreciation of it), but I'd like to say that I never had this issue with the keyboard. I _do_ have it connected to the laptop (tested both on a M2 macbook air and a M4 Pro macbook pro) through a `ThinkPad Thunderbolt 3 Dock Gen 2` -- not sure if that may be what's avoiding your problem.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M4: Likes it
You still need ridiculously high spec hardware, and at Apple’s prices, that isn’t cheap. You can easily run models like Mistral and Stable Diffusion in Ollama and Draw Things, and you can run newer models like Devstral (the MLX version) and Z Image Turbo with a little effort using LM Studio and Comfyui. It isn't as fast as using a good nVidia GPU or a cloud GPU but it's certainly good enough to play around with and learn more about it. I've written a bunch of apps that give me a browser UI talking to an API that's provided by an app running a model locally and it works perfectly well. I did that on an 8GB M1 for 18 months and then upgraded to a 24GB M4 Pro recently. I still have the M1 on my network for doing AI things in the background.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M4: Likes it
I went from a base M1 Air to a mid-spec’d M4 Pro. My main reasons were the 14” screen size, and the lack of a wedge shape for the new Airs (I loved the wedge). IMO, 14” is the perfect size for a laptop that actually sees time in your lap. My 13” Air was fine, but the extra inch is just enough to make a difference, while not feeling overly bulky. Re: refresh rate, it’s nice, but I wouldn’t miss it most of the time. I have my external monitor for my work M3 running at 120 Hz because I can, not because I need it.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M4: Likes it
Once you bump the RAM and disk, it's not too much of a leap to a Pro. 13" M4 Air, 24GB, 512GB - £1,399 14" M4 Pro MBP, 24GB, 512GB - £1,779 at Costco. For that you get amazing speakers, way better screen (with correct scaling), more performance, better chip, better battery, better mics, TB5 ports and HDMI/SD ports.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M4: Likes it
Yeah, I love Framework (disclosure, I invested in their community funding round) and I pre-ordered the desktop and have strongly considered upgrading my Intel laptop of theirs to an AMD mainboard (or just getting a whole new unit since I'll have to get new RAM and would like the higher DPI screen) and compared to other Windows or Linux options right now, I think they are pretty strong for thin and light HOWEVER I would be a liar if I said I think it can compare to a MacBook Air right now. Which to be honest, is fine -- plenty of people want something different from a MacBook Air, whether it is the ability to run Windows or Linux without compromises (tho VMs on Apple silicon are pretty good, it's not going to be ideal for everyone), the ability to upgrade storage, or just wanting repairability. But the battery life on a MBA is not something Framework or any of the Windows laptops can compete with right now. I thought we might get there with Qualcomm's Snapdragon chips last year -- and maybe the next iteration will (and ARM64 chips have their own trade-offs for Windows and Linux (whereas if you're committed to Mac, those trade-offs don't exist anymore)) -- but right now, unfortunately, Mac is where it is at for the true all-day performance and battery place. Even there, however, I would specify that it is the MacBook Airs that have the best battery life. My 16" M4 Pro with 48GB of RAM has great battery too -- don't get me wrong. But my original 14" M1 Max and the 14" M3 Max I r…