The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Apple MacBook Pro M2

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air.

Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Pro M2
Owners with an opinion1931127
Positive verdicts79% of 165375% of 106
Positive/negative since 2024657/19046/21
Happy after 3+ years1512
Longest happy owner14 yrs15 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryperformance and battery
Criticized forreliabilityergonomics and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Doesn’t like it
Currently have a 14" M2 Pro and a 13" M4 Air in front of me. The Pro keyboard is loud and clicky and I much prefer the softer feel of the Air's. Its also half the weight and the battery seems to last twice as long. Screen is 3024x1964 @254 pixel density for the Pro. The Air says it is 2560x1664 @224 but interestingly if I do a full screenshot the resultant image is 2940x1912(?). The Air screen seems brighter, but who goes outside in the sun these days for any more than 10 minutes?
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Doesn’t like it
2013 was the peak for me. iPhone 6 and Macbook Air 2013 the last good devices. i have macbook pro m2 at work and just typing into the terminal is laggy. plus random crashes, apps refusing to start no legacy app support. my windows 10 is much much more stable. their phones being turned into a super fragile glass brick with no consideration of hand ergonomics is peak hubris. and the face ID, pure marketing gimmick that doesnt evenb work better than fingerprint or basic camera unlock. they are purely marketing company now.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Doesn’t like it
Despite the name "MacBook Pro", this isn't the same lineage as the 14" MBP, remember. For years, there have basically been two lines of MBPs -- the 13"/15" line with four USB-C ports that later became the 14"/16" line, and the 13"-only line that always had just two USB-C ports, more limited CPUs, and a variety of other limitations. The move to Apple Silicon has weirdly made this distinction even more stark: now the 14"/16" line has the new design language and new internals (and ports), while the 13" one, despite being one of the first M2-based laptops, retains the old design language, very similar internals going back to the Intel days, and the same two USB-C ports. Also, with the move to the M1 (and now the M2), there's virtually no reason to buy these over the MacBook Air. The Air has MagSafe, a better camera, a better display, better speakers, a better microphone, a better webcam. This low-end "Pro" has, uh, the Touch Bar. And a fan. (Which seems like it may not help the thermals.) From all appearances, this laptop exists solely to hit a price point with the name "Pro", primarily to appease enterprise customers that won't buy Macs that don't have the "Pro" badging. I would't be surprised if the M2-based Airs, which move the Air to the new design, actually have better thermals despite being fanless.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Doesn’t like it
Time will tell what this issue is but the person reporting it is leveraging controversy to get clicks here. I suspect manufacturing issue. The SSD performance problem on the 256Gb models is a massive problem though. Although after all this I'm still not sure why the M2 MBP exists. By the time it's useful it costs nearly as much as the MBP 14" for the same spec which is far superior. And if you want to cheap it out, the M1 MBA is probably a better deal because it's far cheaper and perfectly adequate.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Likes it
I use both macOS and Linux (NixOS + gnome/niri) regularly. When everything is working properly--and, to be clear, I'm talking about the macOS side--I see almost no difference between the two operating systems. I'm on a ThinkPad on one side and an M2 Macbook Pro on the other. The only meaningful difference not attributable to something like different screen size is that Apple displays are damn good, and their speakers are otherworldly. I was running Asahi/NixOS on a Macbook Air for a long time, and that experience was also top notch--only battery life was a few percentage points worse on NixOS--but the aarch64 software situation and emulation experience were just not there. I expect they've improved a bit since. If someone would make a quality laptop that doesn't look like a Honda street racer and has excellent audio, I'd be very happy.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Likes it
If you place 1mm thermal pads between the sinks and the case, the CPUs/GPUs won't throttle as readily. At least for my M3 MBA (check your actual clearance). I replaced a MacPro5,1 with an M2Pro — which uses soooooo much less energy performing similarly mundane tasks (~15x+). Idle is ~25W v. 160W
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Likes it
>I ditched MSFT stock a few years ago in favor of AMD I bought equal amounts of MSFT and AMD, about four years ago. Haven't touched any of the AMD, yet... and was thinking maybe I should sell it all (also don't like AI-integrated things, fellow Old Man)... but now that GPUs are so expensive I haven't pulled the trigger, yet. Until a few months ago, AMD had been break-even for my then-three-years of holding. >I am ditching is a 2006 Xeon dual core Mine is a 2009, and honestly was held together with patches/glue (not literally). Also very stable after boot-up, but boots were becoming 50/50. I migrated off of Xeons (as my main machine) Jan 2023, when Apple released their M2Pro "Silicon" models. I also got a 15" M3 Macbook Air. Both machines make great internet browsers. I hate modern macOS, but it is usable when you block apple/icloud (entirely), at the host level. No update nags, no cloud storage BS, no problems. All my serious writing/paperwork happens offline, on quite antiquated equipment (oldest being my Smith Corona c~1946). Very happily awaiting the return of in-person meetups, as generative AI video begins requiring such social connection.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Likes it
One key thing not mentioned is OS support. I own an M2 MBA for personal use, and have an M2 MBP at work, specifically because they feature macOS. I realise that is not to everyone's taste, but it is mine, it's where I'm productive, and what I enjoy using. This is a spec-point worth something to me as a result. For those who prefer Linux, that may be a spec point worth something too! I love many things about the Framework laptops, and hope Apple learns from them on those things, but ultimately I'm still on Macs because that spec point is worth so much to me.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Likes it
Macs were long hindered by Intel processors to have long battery lifes AND/OR good performance. Two examples of MacBooks I had: The 12" MacBook. Great form factor, bad software (graphics driver code was especially poor), poor keyboard, lousy battery life, slow CPU & graphics. Similar size now with the 13" MacBook Air, but much better. The i9 MacBook Pro. Too heavy, not enough cooling, extra GPU chip (in the laptop) with lots of power demand, Thunderbolt chips with lots of power demand, CPU with lots of power demand, fans were often on (for example with anything which uses the extra GPU). Now a 16" MacBook Pro with Apple Silicon is virtually silent AND fast. I currently have a Mac mini with M2 Pro, a MacBook Pro with M2 Pro and the new iPad Pro M4. All are very snappy and virtually silent. They use very little idle power and don't get warm in normal use. The i9 MacBook Pro would produce a lot of heat when attached to an external screen and doing a "simple" video call, due to the power hungry additional GPU needed to drive the external screen.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro M2: Doesn’t like it
It’s not in my experience. “Normal users” are starting to run into this issue as I can anecdotally pass along (browsing, google suite, slight photoshop use, etc). I actually had lots of reservations before I “green lighted” those first gen M1 MacBook Airs at 8GB across family and friends. Unfortunately I unreasonably fell for the rather over hyped reviews across the board (“I want to believe”). It’s especially on me as my last private intel MBP before my “maxed out” M1 MBP wore out its on-board SSD after only 4 years and that one was large (1TB) with ample memory for the time (16GB). It’s running my personal “hack on Linux” from the SD card slot since so it’s somewhat cool but yeah.. My current work machine, a M2 Pro MBP at 32GB actually has less usable memory than my sluggish i9 MBP had - due to unified memory. We know the CPU/GPU is great but the memory story really isn’t, my system is palpably less responsive with a couple of documentation / bad web interface Safari tabs too many… RAM configurations are just prohibitively expensive even for “well off” companies / purchasers at this point so it’s often a struggle to fight for more. I’ve been a big Apple / Mac fan and loyal customer since Panther but we shouldn’t turn a blind eye here. These constrained memory configurations - even when streamlined OS / system software optimizations are in place (are they? still?) - are probably playing a good part in their great margins but they do need to go with the time (bloated websit…
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M2: Likes it
Fwiw, I have a 16" M2 Pro and had a close call with losing it to water damage, so I picked up a M2 Air and it is FASTER than the Pro for most of my jobs (electron/Xcode dev). The Air is so much lighter that I much prefer it to the Pro. The Pro now lives at my desk via TB, and the Air in my backpack for pretty much everything else. Weirdly, when I look at GeekBench browser I see that the M2 Pro should be faster, but at the time I've got screenshots of it being a Pro @ 2.7 GHz and Air @ 3.5 GHz... and I just checked again right now (at my desk) and the Pro is running at 3.29 GHz, so the dynamic CPU scaling must have had an effect. Yet, the actual work doesn't lie, and everything feels super snappy on the Air. Truth to YMMV.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro M2: Doesn’t like it
Considering the shared GPU memory, 8 GB is going to be very limiting going forward. Also, this Mac is very likely going to have the same slower SSD like the recently released 13 inch M2 MBP. This means you have to upgrade the SSD as well, if you care about performance. I would not recommend buying an MBA with base specs.