The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Apple MacBook Pro M1 Max

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook Pro M1 Max.

Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Pro M1 Max
Owners with an opinion1931282
Positive verdicts79% of 165380% of 224
Positive/negative since 2024657/19083/27
Happy after 3+ years1519
Longest happy owner14 yrs7 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryperformance and noise
Criticized forreliabilityreliability and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Recommends it
I got an M1 Max studio w/ 64gb when they first came out and I love it. Price was obviously a lot more reasonable at the time. I’m fortunate to have dedicated office space, and there is definitely a nice psychological effect to having a desktop in a specific spot and “going to the office”. I’ve since purchased an m3 MacBook Air as my thin client and for lightweight travel use, and when my wife needs to take a call in the office or whatever I pop out to the living room and either hop on Remote Desktop or SSH into my Studio. Highly recommend this setup. If you’re primarily doing thin client on a local network, a neo should be fine for that (and to use as a media player/communicator around the house). That said, I have been eyeballing Omarchy…
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
As mundane and common as the information I’m about to share may be, it’s the reality of MacBook ownership for many - dare I say most? I don’t buy new MacBooks. I get them refurbished from MicroCenter, Apple, or elsewhere. In 2024, I picked up a 2021-released 14” M1 Max MacBook Pro w/ 2 TB and 64 GB for $1800 from Microcenter. Because Apple is so hostile to repairs, I have been paying for AppleCare+ and will continue for some time. But I don’t see myself truly needing to replace this machine for another 2-3 years. It’s my daily driver for BBedit, some IDEs, music apps, Firefox with dozens of tabs, Mail, Messages, iTerm2 with half a dozen tmux sessions. True - my computing needs are not demanding. But for those of us who offload commuting to remote servers and mostly use thin clients, the computer is a joy to use. I’ve been dabbling in Ableton Live Suite 12 Lite, which came with my Native Instruments Komplete Kontrol S88 MKII midi keyboard, and this machine never breaks a sweat. The M-series are seriously as close to BIFL as a consumer laptop can be. Meanwhile, my wife’s daily driver is a 2013 13” MacBook Air w/ 128 GB SSD and 8 GB RAM. And an Intel i7 from that era. I won’t defend this though. She’s insane, and I don’t know how she lives with herself. I purchased it used from a Craigslist seller to be my daily driver 14 years ago, and it lasted until I upgraded to a 2020 M1 MacBook Air base model, which I later donated to a friend in need.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Neutral
I used an M1 Air with 16 GBs without issue for everything from Unity3D to multiple IntelliJ products without issue I did eventually move to an M1 Max MBP with 64 GB of RAM, but that was mostly from severely underestimating the uselessness (for my purposes) of locally hosted LLMs: as you said, 24 GBs is plenty for most usecases
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Recommends it
If price is not a concern I might recommend sticking to the laptop route. There is no noticeable performance gap on the Pro line with the fan (wife has an M2 Air and I definitely notice throttling in stuff like Lightroom) I use a 14" M1 Max as my daily driver with an external monitor. I absolutely love the versatility. I run small video transcode jobs in Premiere/AME or render out things in After Effects daily and I never hear the fan or have any performance/heat issues of any kind. I am comparing this to my Win10 5950x/RTX 3080 desktop also at my desk and while that is definitely faster, I do not feel like my MBP is too far behind. If cost is a factor I think the Mac Mini is the best bang for your buck. Especially if you still have access to a .edu (or just say you are in college) and knock an additional $100 off.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Neutral
I have the same complaint about weight I upgraded from the 13" M1 Air to the 14" MacBook Pro M1 Max While Blender performance (rendering especially) is much faster, I sorely miss the MacBook Air's portability. The 14" is built like a brick. Compile times are faster, video editing is nicer with more RAM in the Pro, but it's a really tough call given just how different the weight is
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
I got M1 Air first and then upgraded to a pro Max (64 GB). 1. I haven't heard any noise at all. My pro has been tucked behind my monitors during the last couple of months though. It's pretty warm where I live and it's not running hot. I had a few instances of lockups (VSCode most often) with my basic M1 Air. But the pro has taken everything I throw at it. 2. When I first got the air there were a few tools that had compatibility issues. All of those are ironed out now. Most apps I use these days have official M1 support. 3. I use lima, nerdctl these days and haven't any issues in running containers. I haven't had any issues with container performance either. 4. I'm planning to use this machine for quite a few years as well and I got the 64GB. In hindsight 32 GB could have been sufficient. Summary: Go for it. If you are flush with cash, go for the 64GB M1 Max but 32GB is plenty.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Recommends it
There's a few videos on this on youtube and countless blogs. Here's my general take. I have a company assigned m1 macbook pro 13.3 inch. It's a machine to make sure that M1 mac stuff works and it was the only M1 series laptop out when I started so I've done all my testing on that machine. Synopsis: It's great, great battery life, operating is slick, can't complain except there is only two usb-c ports and you need one for power. Would I buy an M series mac for personal use? nope, I bought an M1 ipad, which is an amazing piece of hardware that will only get better with iPad OS 16. Now enough about me, lets look at why your two choices are: 14" MBP M1 Max Pro OR Mac Book Air with an M2 in it. Why are those your two choices? First the big boy in the mix ... if you want a massively capable development machine to do all of the development things and it still be a portable laptop then the 14" mbp M1 Max Pro is your choice. The 16 is too big and if you must have the beefier Ultra, you should probably just wait until the new Mac Pro comes out or look at the studio. The 16" MBP is a desktop workstation disguised as a laptop. So if you're going to go all out with money, then stick with the M1 series, but get the 14" MBP. If you want the best bang for your buck and don't need all that extra horsepower than the M2 Macbook Air is up for order and starts delivering in a week. It's ultra portable, functional, future-proofed, and better design than the M2 MBP which is your only other M2…
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
I tried going from a 2018 MBP to M1 MBA in 2021 and had too many issues to make it my primary machine. Docker and Android development were particularly brutal to get going reliably IIRC. The M1 performed well for the things it could do, but I still needed the MBP (which constantly reached 100% CPU) for other stuff, so I ended up doing a horrible multi-machine setup with Synergy. That was a dark time in my life ;) Then tried again early this year with a M1Max MBP, and it has been the biggest step change productivity boost of my life. Definitely still some pain points, but the way this thing handles anything I throw at it is incredible. I'm mostly doing front-end dev (react native). Have a minimum of 2 IDEs, 1 iOS simulator, 1 Android simulator, Windows (ARM) Virtualbox, 2 browsers open at all times. And then add a mix of Docker, XCode, Android Studio, Zoom, Sketch, Affinity apps, Slack, Zoom, etc. I haven't ever heard the fan spin up. I was carefully managing what I had open on the 2018 MBP, and now I don't even think about it. The only thing I'm still running in Rosetta is Apple software: XCode and the iOS simulator, but they run smooth, so I don't even think about it. The MBA setup I was just flailing my way through. For the M1Max setup, I found this guide very helpful in my initial setup (mostly focused on a RN Dev): https://amanhimself.dev/blog/setup-macbook-m1/
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
I’ve felt the same way since way back then ever since reading about this guy’s setup[0], so I paired a 11” MBA with the quad core Mac Mini 2012. I’ve kept that philosophy over the years, the MBA was replaced by the 2017 12” retina MacBook and then again with the 13” M2 MBA. The Mini gave way to the 2018 Mini, then a M1 Max Studio. I even attempted replacing the MacBook with an iPad though that didn’t really workout. It’s the best of both worlds really, enough power to do everything when on the go and even more power back at the office. 0: https://elliotjaystocks.com/blog/a-note-about-my-new-mac-set...
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
I have an M1 Max Macbook Pro, and having used many employer's newer variants of M-series macbook's since then, I'm still very satisfied with my M1 Max but the air series is really good , and very light my M1 is now noticeably heavy and I don't think upgrading to another Macbook Pro is the move the resell value of the M1 did not hold, specifically the bumped up storage models. There doesn't seem to be a market for 8TB of space specifically, but the base 1 - 2TB holds its value because the baseline of the MBP holds its value M5 Max looks tempting if there is a very compelling tradein, but the M1 Max is pretty old so I don't have real hope of that, but I'll look. For AI Inference the difference doesn't seem good enough yet and necessary enough. I'll still need to use the cloud or aspire to have a specialized machine with more RAM or circuitry on my network.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
I'm still typing this from an M1 MAX MBP w/ 64 gig of ram. I ended up needing more memory so, I swapped to this machine instead of my M1 air w/ 16gig. Both machines are completely capable for most tasks I deal with as a developer. Do I like my work m3? Sure. I wish I had the old m3 air I had to give back. But I'm happy with my machines. It's funny that my ipad has a more current CPU than my two laptops.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
Yeah, I love Framework (disclosure, I invested in their community funding round) and I pre-ordered the desktop and have strongly considered upgrading my Intel laptop of theirs to an AMD mainboard (or just getting a whole new unit since I'll have to get new RAM and would like the higher DPI screen) and compared to other Windows or Linux options right now, I think they are pretty strong for thin and light HOWEVER I would be a liar if I said I think it can compare to a MacBook Air right now. Which to be honest, is fine -- plenty of people want something different from a MacBook Air, whether it is the ability to run Windows or Linux without compromises (tho VMs on Apple silicon are pretty good, it's not going to be ideal for everyone), the ability to upgrade storage, or just wanting repairability. But the battery life on a MBA is not something Framework or any of the Windows laptops can compete with right now. I thought we might get there with Qualcomm's Snapdragon chips last year -- and maybe the next iteration will (and ARM64 chips have their own trade-offs for Windows and Linux (whereas if you're committed to Mac, those trade-offs don't exist anymore)) -- but right now, unfortunately, Mac is where it is at for the true all-day performance and battery place. Even there, however, I would specify that it is the MacBook Airs that have the best battery life. My 16" M4 Pro with 48GB of RAM has great battery too -- don't get me wrong. But my original 14" M1 Max and the 14" M3 Max I r…
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
Until recently I owned both MacBook Pro 16 M1 Max and iPad Pro 12.9 with magic keyboard. I love MacBook Pro 16 for work either on desk with connected big display or on laptop stand. Occasionally I use it as a notebook flat on the desk, but don't really like it long term, it forces you to look down which is not comfortable. But I HATE MBP16 to use as a LAPtop, it's too big, I can stand it maybe for 30min, max 1h. So here comes iPad Pro 12.9 - lightweight (maybe not that light including Magic Keyboard), but it's great to use in laptop way, on chair, in bed etc. Great to browse web, scroll through videos and write notes or emails. I liked this form factor so much that I started to figure out how to make it a coding machine. That's problematic of course, so I ended up buying paid terminal App in App Store to connect over ssh/mosh to some server/other machine and use terminal with tmux/nvim etc. Installed nerdfonds, started using TUIs and it was working pretty well. But, I hate terminals for long term real work. I want to use heavy UI debuggers, click around/browse, move etc, my work is not only inserting text. I considered buying Asus Zenbook s13 OLED and install Linux on it to have two devices to use depending on my mood and physical position I wanna have. But, first, Zenbook is on Intel/Ryzen which means heat and fan noise, two, there are high risks my linux setup will require tweaks and care which I'm not interested in. In summary: I bought base MacBook Air 13 M2 and use it as…
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
Agreed - I picked up an MBA as a second device for a job and then switched my main laptop to an M1 Max for development, photography, music and usually all running at the same time (IntelliJ, Photo Mechanic/Capture One, Logic Pro) and the performance just isn't an issue, in fact, there are NO hardware issues at all, except maybe I could do with even more disk space. I once inhabited a performance-driven sphere, but it turned out that there was a ceiling on what I needed. Absolutely no doubt that many people who run different workloads will still be delighted with more performance, but for many of us, Apple are looking at a massive drop in upgrade sales soon...
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
When I went from my Intel MBP (was the prior gen) to my first M1 MBA it cut my java test suite times in 1/2. I dug in thinking something was broken, but nope, it was that much faster. As another poster said, I bought a M1 Max, 64gb when they came out and it still feels new speed wise. Unless something breaks, this computer should last a really long time.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
I bought a MBP 14 (max 32, 32GB, 2TB) Dec 2021 and I mostly don't regret it (probably should've only gotten 24 GPU cores and gone silver). Here are some pros and cons I don't think get enough play: - Turning on "Low Power Mode" when on Battery gives me roughly 10h of battery life. Functionally this is more than good enough for me. - Backlight leakage around the keys feels janky - It's pretty hard to pick it up unless you get it by the back vent, also yeah, it's heavy - The resolution is pretty weird. I wish it were really 4k, then bumping it down to FHD with an integer scale would make sense. As it is, the integer scale is 1512x982, which many websites think (including some you might build!) is a tablet. - Viewing angles on the screen are not at IPS levels. At regular usage distances you can definitely see a difference around the outer 1/3 of the screen. - Dark text on a light background is different than light text on a dark background. When I do `set bg=light` in Vim I usually need to use a thicker font or turn on antialiasing. I think most people should get the M2 Air (or the M1 even). I have a couple of reasons that going 14 max makes sense for me: I moved abroad and my brother and I keep in touch via gaming (a lot of Steam games, etc. work pretty well on it), and I'm planning on getting back into music. Otherwise, I would argue that: - the IPS screen on the Air is better for text - the Air's battery life is another class - the Air is much lighter - the Air's resolution i…
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Neutral
My personal laptop is an M1 Air (16gb)... for anything dev, I use VS Code + Remoting extensions and just work "on" my personal desktop (local or over vpn/wireguard). It means I can't really do much without an internet connection, but that's often the case anyway. I will say that a lot of the software I run in Docker has an aarch64 bundle... there are a few things that don't. There's now a beta version of Docker Desktop that includes Rosetta support, which should dramatically help for x86_64 images. I also have found that the FS I/O is not great, but getting better. (prior job was using M1 Max, current is windows+wsl)
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1 Max: Likes it
Can't say I'm state of the art, but I pretty much work on an M1 Max MBP all day, and I'm completely happy with it as a dev + art/design machine. Plus a tablet screen for drawing and sculpting. It's the best machine I've ever had. But then again I've only owned laptops since 1998. Still keep my 2014 Macbook Air on the desk just as a conferencing / music box. [edit] I also only work from my home office when I have to... the rest of the time I'll be working on the porch, at the kitchen table, out at a cafe, etc.