The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Apple MacBook Pro M1

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air.

Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Pro M1
Owners with an opinion1931534
Positive verdicts79% of 165376% of 438
Positive/negative since 2024657/190137/47
Happy after 3+ years15120
Longest happy owner14 yrs6 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryperformance and battery
Criticized forreliabilityreliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro M1: Likes it
In my experience, Intel Macs have always been that way. Every one I had was uncomfortably hot. My work Intel MBP’s fans would runs constantly, because everything would send its CPU through the roof. I always felt like I had to treat them with kid gloves to avoid the CPU running away on me. Webex meetings and screen sharing would always spike my CPU and make everything unusable. I’d have to stop sharing to actually do what I was trying to show someone. All this was before Apple Silicon even released, when Intel was the preferred chip. It was garbage. This never happens anymore with the M1 Pro MBPs I have. I’ve never heard the fan spin up on my work MBP. I have heard it on my personal one, but I was actually pushing it, it wasn’t a random runaway process doing it, as was common on Intel. I’d take a modern MacBook Air over the highest spec’d Intel Mac Apple ever made.
Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro M1: Doesn’t like it
When you open up Activity Monitor, to the immediate left of the "Memory Used" and "Cached Files" that you see, you'll see the Memory Pressure graph that the guy above is talking about. On my 64 GB M1 Macbook Pro right now, I have 53.41 GB of Memory Used and 10.72 GB of Cached Files and 6.08 GB of swap, but Memory Pressure is green and extremely low. On my 8 GB M1 Macbook Air I just bought for OpenClaw, I'm at 6.94 GB Memory Used and 1.01 GB of Cached Files with 2.05 GB of Swap Used, and Memory Pressure is medium high at yellow, probably somewhere around 60-70%. You can open up the Terminal and run the command memory_pressure to get much more detailed data on what goes into calculating memory pressure - more than just the amount of swap used, it tracks swap I/O and a bunch of page and compressor data to get a more holistic sense of what's going on and how memory starved you're going to feel in practice. In any case - I've been absolutely mindblown at how fast my 3 8GB M1 Macbook Airs I just bought for ~$350 brand new have been - even with tons of Chrome tabs open, multiple terminal windows open, running OpenClaw and Claude Code and VS Code and doing a ton of development and testing, never once have they ever felt slow. Oftentimes they actually feel faster than my 64 GB M1 Macbook Pro, which kind of blows my mind and makes me wonder wtf is going on on my monster machine. Moreover, my M1 Macbook Pro drains battery like crazy and uses a ton of charge, whereas the Macbook Airs sta…
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1: Neutral
That's exactly the problem, tho - our hardware is playing a game of tag with bloated software, it always needs to keep up with the newest bloat. Buy, why? My computer is extremely capable already, why not use its resources efficiently to get the best out of it? I'm building an advanced block editor (like Notion) in Qt C++. It takes 0.78seconds to load War and Peace on my 2016 MacBook Air. Using the top of the line Electron app (MarkText) takes 34x longer! Also, the same text loaded using the best native macOS app (Bike Outliner), on a 2022 M1 Pro takes 1.5seconds. So, my 2016 MacBook Air is "faster" than 2022 M1 Pro just due to more efficient software.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1: Neutral
I use my M2 Air 16GB for app development. Runs Webstorm, xcode simulator, node servers pretty smoothly. llama.cpp also runs fast enough. It runs some games okay (like KSP). I have a dock & external monitor to switch between my Air and M1 MBP and I don't notice a difference in performance when doing the same tasks that I normally do, but games run smoother.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1: Neutral
With a remote workstation to actually build and run software on, an iPad / Android tablet almost works great as a thin client for a terminal. The biggest thing I missed on it were browser developer tools. The mobile browsers just don't have it. Needing a Mac to attach to it to run developer tools on just kills the "Pro" in iPad Pro for me. Maybe there's a decent third-party app for it now (Is Inspect Browser any good?), but there wasn't last time I tried it. Using a 14" M1 Pro now, which is the only thing work will issue to me. I pine for my 11" MacBook Air I had once upon a time.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro M1: Likes it
The difference between an M2 air (8gb/512gb) versus an M1 pro (16gb/1tb) is much more than I expected. * M1 pro (16gb/1tb) can run the model in around 3 minutes. * M2 air (8gb/512gb) takes ~60 minutes for the same model. I knew there would be some throttling due to the m2 air's fanless model, but I had no idea it would be a 20x difference (albeit, the m1 pro does have double the RAM. I don't have any other macbooks to test this on).
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1: Doesn’t like it
I have a 14” M1 Pro. I cannot look at the screen of this machine more than a few minutes before my eyes starts to give alarms. I have no problem with my Macbook Air. I see that no one mention a similar complaints in comments. Can you share your Displays settings? I have automatically adjust brightness, checked True Tone, checked Presets: Apple XDR Display (P3-1600 nits) Refresh Rate: 48 Hertz
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro M1: Likes it
I highly recommend spending a couple hundred extra bucks and getting the macbook pro instead of the Air. The Air has no fans and will throttle cpu extensively under medium - heavy usage. You will feel this and it is quite frustrating. I also recommend you get at least 16GB RAM. I own a 2019 Mac Pro and my M1 16" MBP blows it out of this universe on every metric. Docker runs fine, but you will need to add --Platform flag on some images to set the build platform as it will attempt to build for ARM if available. Other than that, it shouldn't require anything different.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro M1: Recommends it
Butterfly keyboard era. I have one as a work machine that sits around until I need VPN access. The keyboard is miserable, and the fans spin up when I open Slack. In contrast, my 14" M1 Pro is the best laptop I've ever used. Fans are inaudible, incredible performance, incredible keyboard/trackpad, battery is not a worry.
Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro M1: Likes it
I quite like my work M1 Pro, but (to help coworkers with Mac problems while I was using a ThinkPad) I had an M1 Air 8GB from work for a while and I honestly found it really pretty bad because of the RAM limits. It seems like there's a floor against which MacOS bumps pretty hard if you want to use the machine for development-ish stuff and it reacts really poorly to memory starvation if you get ahead of yourself. Having 16GB and up, though, an M1's fantastic. If I had to be resource constrained, though, I think I'd prefer something that handled Linux well.
Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro M1: Neutral
My experience with the Mac Mini M1 is the same. We bought a Mini for our daughter. I use it sometimes to benchmark stuff on the vanilla M1. I don't think the fan every spun up. I can get the fans to spin up easily on my MacBook Pro 14" (M1 Pro), e.g. when building a large project like PyTorch. Luckily, the fans are not very loud. I can't hear it at the office (plenty of ambient noise), though I can hear it sometimes in our home office. Passive cooling is one of the reasons I recommend people to get the M1 Air, unless they need 8 performance cores or > 16GB RAM. A completely quiet laptop is such a nice feature. I hope that they keep the Air passively cooled in the future. Edit: >= corrected to >
Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro M1: Neutral
Used an MBA M1 for a year before switching to a MBP 14" M1 Pro. The MBA is the best laptop I‘ve ever had. Fanless, light, insane battery life, always cool and blazingly fast. No noticeable difference between the M1 (8/7 16GB) vs. M1 Pro (10/14 32GB) in daily use, although I don’t usually depend on long running processes going full throttle. I believe the entry-level MBA is the best laptop you can buy when it comes to price-performance ratio.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro M1: Likes it
Haha same here. The M1 Pro is such a powerful machine and it still works great. I did buy a MacBook Air M5 for non work, and I think it’s about as fast as the M1 Pro, but the latter has 64GB of RAM so I can actually work. Will probably request a new one next year though, it’s time.
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralApple MacBook Pro M1: Neutral
This is a known issue and I am actively trying to find why this is happening. So far it's pretty good on Brave/Chrome. Tested on Macbook Pro M1 8gb RAM and Macbook Air M1 8gb RAM. Mostly likely because of M series of chips. All tests were done on Brave/Chrome. Does not work on iPhone 11 Pro Max and iPhone 16 Pro. Mostly likely because of A series of chips. Tests were done on Safari and Chrome and it crashes on both.