The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Apple MacBook Pro 2015

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Pro 2015
Owners with an opinion193184
Positive verdicts79% of 165382% of 74
Positive/negative since 2024657/19024/6
Happy after 3+ years15110
Longest happy owner14 yrs8 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryperformance and reliability
Criticized forreliabilityvalue
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro 2015: Likes it
I have had two MacBook Air m1 failures in my family that has started to change how I recommend purchasing a mac. They have 1 year warranties and one had logic board failure around the 18 month mark. It’s possible they last 7 years (I have a 2015 mbp that is going strong) but also it’s possible any high end brand lasts that long (I have an Hp envy that is running strong as well). The repairability of a MacBook m1 is basically zero. I’m too afraid to buy a new logic board because of the T2 chip). Anyway, a 1 year warranty is absurd on a product that expensive that you shouldn’t be having problems with. The tiny warranty is a scam to get you into AppleCare plus for hundreds more, so factor that into the price you pay as well. I feel like I’m responsible for recommending the m1 to my cousin that got fried this last week
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro 2015: Likes it
If it's a M1 Macbook Air there's a very good reason you've never heard a fan! Blows my mind how it doesn't even have a fan and is still rarely even anything above body temperature. My 2015 MBP was still going strong for work when I bailed on it late last year but the transition purely on the heat/sound emitted has been colossal.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro 2015: Likes it
I loved my 2015 MBP too. I recently replaced it with a used MBA M1, 16GB, 2TB. It's insane how much faster it is, how long the battery lasts and how cool and silent it is. Completely different worlds.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro 2015: Likes it
I loved my 2015 MBP, probably the best machine Apple made, overall, until arguably the 2019 16" (read: after the butterfly keyboard debacle) Traded it for an M1 Air in 2021 and was astonished at how much faster it was. It even blew away my 2019 16" from work. You're going to be even more blown away!
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralApple MacBook Pro 2015: Neutral
I made some side by side photos and videos (that I don't want to share because of privacy) of Macbook Pro 2015, M1 Macbook Air 2020, 16" M1 Macbook Pro 2021, and the front facing camera of a cheap android phone. My conclusion: - the only good camera is the front facing camera of the cheap android phone - the 2015 MBP camera has low resolution and lots of noise, but the image at least looks natural - the images from the M1 Macs look very similar. They added extreme smoothing to hide the noise. The result is that there is no details at all in the images. Skin looks unnaturally smooth and facial hair is a blurry mess. When you move your head, there are weird artefacts near the eyes. - comparing M1 Macbook Air 2020 and M1 Macbook Pro 2021 looks similar, except the smoothing seems even stronger on the 2021 Macbook Pro - even in perfect lighting the resolution of the camera is very low. There is no way this is actually a 1080p camera. The 720p image of the 2015 Macbook Pro has more detail than the cameras in the new Macs. - the only good thing about the cameras in the M1 Macs is the low light performance. The algorithm is pretty good at producing a usable image even in very low light. It's really not a good camera. It really sucks. Everything else about this laptop is perfect: The display, the speakers, the keyboard -- everything is wonderful, apart from the fact that whenever I facetime with someone I look like a blurry mess.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro 2015: Likes it
> For me, its enviromentally insane to buy such a device that is nearly unrepairable. I would generally feel the same, the only reason I don't is that Apple laptops tend to last a very long time for me and get replaced due to becoming obsolete, not due to becoming nonfunctioning. My 2011 MBA was in use until 2016, my 2015 MBP is still in use and due to be replaced soon. The lifespan of one of these devices is roughly 5 years in my use case, and I usually hand them down to someone else that needs a decent computer but where my use cases have outgrown it. I know one I handed off is still being used 10 years after it was purchased and it still works "fine" for some value of fine. That's not an argument against repairability, but to say that a well-made product often has a longer lifespan than a useful lifespan for its original owner.