The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air M4 vs Apple MacBook Pro

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air M4.

Apple MacBook Air M4Apple MacBook Pro
Owners with an opinion573902
Positive verdicts78% of 4662% of 3276
Positive/negative since 202436/10945/592
Happy after 3+ years0355
Longest happy owner1 yrs16 yrs
Praised forperformance and portabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forreliability and repairabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air M4: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I use both the base M4 Mac mini and an M4 MacBook Air for Final Cut Pro, Photoshop, and Fusion, and while they're not as almost-always-perfectly-smooth as my Mac Studio, they're about 100x better than the experience I used to have on my old Intel MacBook Pros in the 2010s. I edit 4K ProRes and H.265 footage, sometimes with multicam (up to 4 streams) and color adjustments, titles, etc. It's only after stacking 3-5 effects before things can stutter, really. Or if you try doing something CPU-intense in the background _while_ running some heavy creative software. I just don't do that.
Apple MacBook Air M4: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I bought an M4 Air about a year ago for under 1000$, it beat out my 2019 Intel MBP by quite a lot. I fully expect the air to last me at least another 6 years or so for my use case. The thing is a beast. Compare this to a Dell laptop I bought when I started college, that thing was 850 dollars and died on me within 3 years. For Apple, I could justify spending more (maybe even 20% more) considering both Apple computers I’ve had feel extremely fast. The only reason I dropped the 2019 MBP was battery fatigue (and I probably could have repaired it for 100$ and gotten another 3-4 years out of it. But the new air was just too attractive).
Apple MacBook Air M4: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
Fully agree. I used to have a company issued MBP M3 Pro, and when I switched roles I got myself base M4 Air. Can't complain at all in the past year, I do feel throttling at times when running longer tasks, but for 99% of the time I don't feel I need anything better. And I do work as a software developer, so anyone doing lighter usage not in this camp will feel the same. M5 Air should be pretty much the same.
Apple MacBook Air M4: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
Currently have a 14" M2 Pro and a 13" M4 Air in front of me. The Pro keyboard is loud and clicky and I much prefer the softer feel of the Air's. Its also half the weight and the battery seems to last twice as long. Screen is 3024x1964 @254 pixel density for the Pro. The Air says it is 2560x1664 @224 but interestingly if I do a full screenshot the resultant image is 2940x1912(?). The Air screen seems brighter, but who goes outside in the sun these days for any more than 10 minutes?
Apple MacBook Air M4: NeutralApple MacBook Pro: Recommends it
Not really - I bought an M4 Air to check how my dev ecosystem (.NET) would run on the ARM/Apple silicon and while its usable its noticeably slowing me down in my day to day with Rider. I will be getting the M5 pro because the performance is a bottleneck for me (even incremental builds take a while). Also I regret not getting at least 30gb ram (Amazon only had 24gb configurations) because with docker running I constantly hit the memory pressure thresholds . Which is not to say that the Air is a bad device, its an amazing laptop (especially for the price, I have not seen a single Windows laptop with this build quality even at 2x price) and the performance is good - that if I was doing something like VSCode and node/frontend only it would be more than enough. But also people here oversell its capabilities, if you need anything more CPU/Memory intensive PRO is a must, and the "Apple needs less ram because of the fast IO/memory" argument is a myth.
Apple MacBook Air M4: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Apple is in the process of fixing Tahoe which was a regression from Sequoia the previous release. Tahoe is decent with 26.4 though from what I am hearing. Either OS version is far far better than regular Windows 11 though. Apple’s real differentiator is their silicon. M series chips are just incredibly good and you get a full workday out of them on battery. The M1 Pro I still have at work is easily the best laptop I have ever used. For side projects I use an M4 air with maxed out RAM and it has no issues with anything I have thrown at it.
Apple MacBook Air M4: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
I run qwen models on MBA M4 16 Gb and MBP M2 Max 32 Gb, MBA is able to handle models in accordance with its vram memory capacity (with external cooling), e.g. qwen3 embedding 8B (not 1B!) but inference is 4x-6x times slower than on mbp. I suspect weaker SoC Anyway, Apple SoC in M series is a huge leverage thanks to shared memory: VRAM size == RAM size so if you buy M chip with 128+ Gb memory, you’re pretty much able to run SOTA models locally, and price is significantly lower than AI GPU cards
Apple MacBook Air M4: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Once you bump the RAM and disk, it's not too much of a leap to a Pro. 13" M4 Air, 24GB, 512GB - £1,399 14" M4 Pro MBP, 24GB, 512GB - £1,779 at Costco. For that you get amazing speakers, way better screen (with correct scaling), more performance, better chip, better battery, better mics, TB5 ports and HDMI/SD ports.