The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air M2 vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air M2.

Apple MacBook Air M2Lenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion2342732
Positive verdicts84% of 19975% of 2366
Positive/negative since 202488/18686/273
Happy after 3+ years0281
Longest happy owner1 yrs25 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryreliability and performance
Criticized fordisplay and portabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
The Macbook M2 Air running Asahi Linux is easily my favorite Linux laptop ever, far superior to any Thinkpad or Dell XPS I've owned, imo. I think things like Thunderbolt and some DisplayPort features are missing, but I have never needed this as it is purely a laptop for me. But it has everything else I could want: suspend/sleep, proper frequency scaling, great GPU drivers, USB/wifi/bluetooth, speakers, brightness/keyboard settings, etc. The webcam works I think but I haven't tried it. The battery life is great, though macOS is still quite a ways ahead in that department.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Other than my work laptop (a horrible, horrible Dell Precision), my laptops hardly ever leave the house: MacBook Air M2, Lenonov X220 (Linux) and HP 17 (Windows). I still prefer the sleek and light one over the others.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I'm writing this on a 2013 MBP. This specific machine is slightly bent and endured being hit by a car. Those other laptops that you mentioned, that aren't made out of aluminum would be dead. I've also had a few Lenovo T410s (circa 2010). I would say the quality and spec of those T410s isn't up to par with MBPs of similar era. Their CPU fans fall apart. They tend to overheat. The hinge breaks- plastic. The display and audio quality is worse. Software support also sucks. At some point newer versions of Windows just don't have good support, the webcam from example doesn't work in modern Windows. On the Macs though you can still run fairly modern OS and everything works. I would totally take a 2010 MBP over a Lenovo Thinkpad of any type. (EDIT: from the same era) I've also used top of the line Dell laptops over the years and a Lenovo Yoga. Way way back I used to have a desktop color Macintosh of some sort (I forget the model, a 68k, maybe IIci ?) and as PCs were getting tossed in the landfill for years while the Mac kept going and running most new software. I just bought my daughter a laptop and decided to go with the MacBook Air m2. Great value for money IMO. Not sure what's even close in terms of performance, build quality, battery life etc. This should easily last 10 years.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
You're talking about best laptops. Parent said physically best. I don't think the answer is subjective - Apple most definitely makes far better laptops physically. The M2 Air is astonishingly light, while being made of metal, as opposed to the ThinkPad's (cheap imo, but subject to debate) plastic. Don't see what the argument is.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Thinkpads are solid devices but they’re really falling behind in screen and trackpads. Most higher end Thinkpad models have 1080p screens with 300-400 nits of brightness at most. The base M2 Macbook Air is 2560x1664 with 500 nits brightness. And it’s cheaper than a Gen2 Thinkpad T14. And of course, all Thinkpads can’t hold a candle to Macbook trackpads
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Hear, hear. M2 MBA 16/512GB here after buying Thinkpads exclusively since 2010 and even modding to get 51NB X62 and T70 boards installed into X61 and T61 Thinkpads. The mba wipes the floor with them all and I wish it was close. I want to go back to my trackpoint but don't want to deal with the fan noise, heat, battery life, or battery loss while suspended.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Did flashing it with Linux have any impact on battery life? The main reason I switched from a Thinkpad T480 (2017) to a M2 Air two months ago was the horrible battery life of the Thinkpad. The M2 has been lasting me almost two days of work, compared to only 3 hours on the Thinkpad. But I miss quite a lot from linux
Apple MacBook Air M2: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Two external monitors. Even in clamshell mode with the internal screen off you can't do that. And the M2 MacBook Air at $1200 USD is hardly entry level. It's not even the cheapest MBA Apple sells because the M1 is still available. Loads of corporations and businesses will give employees base model ThinkPad Twhatever or Dell Latitudes (that cost less than the M2 MBA and drive more than two external displays too).
Apple MacBook Air M2: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
My super light and thin [1] Carbon X1 Thinkpad from about 5 years ago has 16gb ram, half TB SSD and still runs like a champ with 200 tabs open. It's just strange to see a premium brand product not being able to compete with same-category class products from a half-decade ago. [1]: Lighter, in fact, than this MB Air M2
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
>The ThinkPad 13s will start at $1,099 This $1099 config better have 16GB Memory and 512GB by default. Otherwise it is a machine that cost about the same as MacBook Air M2, with lower Display Res, slower CPU and GPU and No Touch ID. This is perhaps for the first time in history Apple has a better "spec" machine for the same price. With the scale of iPhone and iPad, Apple is now at a point where the whole PC industry can no longer compete. And that is excluding things like speakers, trackpad, and thunderbolt port. >A spokesperson told Ars Technica that its business customers are being more open to the aspect ratio. Biggest lie ever. People want 16:10, but for years the industry shove 16:9 to your customer because it was the cheaper panel. > Arm Cortex-X1 cores at up to 3 GHz For Context, the Single Core GB5 Scores Arm Cortex-X1 cores at up to 3 GHz = ~800 Apple M1 ( A14 Core+ ) = ~1700 For PC Laptop counterpart, a 800 GB5 score you are looking at something like AMD Ryzen 7 4700U if it was limited to run at ~10W. So not too bad. Apple is the outliner here.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I had the same with X230. A lovely laptop that still serves as a home server after 10 years or so from being bought, and it was already used, post-lease machine back when I bought it. MacBook Air M2 is also great machine btw, if you don't mind the macOS
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I have the 15 inch Macbook Air M2 and would agree it may in fact be the perfect laptop, and I have had hundreds. Trouble is... I don't use it. In fact I just bought a used Thinkpad off ebay to replace it for 99% of my work. People generally don't think cheap and expendable are features but I would argue that they are. I need a product I'm not concerned to drop or scratch or have stolen or spill a drink on. I need something I can replace without tears that I can sleep next to and use while in the bathroom. That's not an $1800 Mac
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I was a ThinkPad maximalist in my personal computing life for the last 5ish years. This year, I needed to interview for jobs without having access to a "work" laptop for the task (i.e. an overspecced MacBook Pro). Faced with the prospects of subjecting my ThinkPad/vim machine to video calls, I more or less immediately decided to fork over the money for an M2 MacBook Air. Unfortunately for my identity as a person invested in my principles, it's been a delightful experience. I'm glad that I have my ThinkPad (and its stack of batteries) in the closet – it'll always be there, and work exactly as I want it to. But I can already tell I'm going to drive this MacBook into the ground over the next 10 years. I know that I won't be able to repair it when it (eventually) degrades, but the diff of convenience in day to day ops pays for that inconvenience, in my experience. YMMV.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I don't upgrade my computers (or my phones) as much anymore so serviceability isn't as important to me. I have both a MacBook Air M2 and a T480 and I love the flexibility. Most of what I do is on the M2 but every once in a while, I run into edge cases such as printer drivers that only work on Windows or upgrading video production firmware.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I've been a diehard Thinkpad user for over a decade now (X201 my first back in 2010). Apple M2 Air is on another level despite not having a trackpoint. Just to add to your list: the aluminum shell feels nice too. Paired with the cpu it just never heats up, which used to be a drawback by acting as a big heat sink.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Man I wish System76 or Framework or someone else could make hardware as nice as Apple. I just ordered an M2 Air which I will be primarily running Linux on. I'm replacing my Lenovo T480s (which was a great laptop) because I want _nice_ hardware. There are just so few options that even come close to competing with Apple.