The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air M2 vs Dell XPS

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air M2.

Apple MacBook Air M2Dell XPS
Owners with an opinion234659
Positive verdicts84% of 19948% of 583
Positive/negative since 202488/1872/97
Happy after 3+ years049
Longest happy owner1 yrs20 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryreliability and performance
Criticized fordisplay and portabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
The Macbook M2 Air running Asahi Linux is easily my favorite Linux laptop ever, far superior to any Thinkpad or Dell XPS I've owned, imo. I think things like Thunderbolt and some DisplayPort features are missing, but I have never needed this as it is purely a laptop for me. But it has everything else I could want: suspend/sleep, proper frequency scaling, great GPU drivers, USB/wifi/bluetooth, speakers, brightness/keyboard settings, etc. The webcam works I think but I haven't tried it. The battery life is great, though macOS is still quite a ways ahead in that department.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itDell XPS: Neutral
Apple provides a clear and beneficial point of difference. They are vertically integrated and now with Apple silicon, have arguably the best productivity laptops on the market. My M2 Air, lets me do all the personal dev and admin work my XPS 17 does, but I can easily go several days without a charge. My work provided MBP will easily go all day on a single charge and have plenty of charge left. Linux provides easily the best dev environment, is free, gives you all the control you could possible want, runs on lots of hardware and is speedy even on old hardware. Most of the internet is probably hosted on some flavour of linux, and open source frameworks so it's easy for you to do the same. Windows is good for games and if you need to use Excel? It also has the best drivers for my printer. Am I being unfair here?
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
> Unfortunately for testing, as mentioned, right now there is no Linux driver exposing the M2 SoC power consumption under Linux. Hopefully this will be addressed in time but unfortunately meant not being able to deliver any accurate performance-per-Watt / power consumption benchmarks in this article. But when such support does come, it will likely show the M2 indeed delivering much better power efficiency than the Intel and AMD laptops tested. Even under demanding multi-threaded workloads, the M2 MacBook Air was not nearly as warm as the other laptops tested. It's a night and day difference of the M2 MacBook Air still being cool to warm compared to the likes of other notebooks like especially Dell XPS laptops that get outright hot under load. The power consumption metrics should also be more useful/relevant once Linux has working M1/M2 GPU support in place too. I mean, you shove a fan on the M2 and it beats itself...
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I've had 2 Dell XPS's running Ubuntu, a 9300 and 9370. I very recently switched to an Air M2. The build quality between the XPS and the air is night and day. The 9300 flexed so much that when I picked it up with a single hand, the trackpad would click from the flex. After a couple years, the keyboard stopped working, the shell started to physically split and I had to tighten the case screws every week or so (there was a ~2-3mm gap in the case, to a point where the USBc wouldn't line up). My camera started to turn off at the slightest vibration/breeze. I find OSX painful. But between a mildly frustrating OS and crap hardware...for me, the air is an obvious better buy.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I switched from an XPS 13 to an M2 Air recently. The differences are striking. I have my XPS 13 browsing HN next to my M1 air. That's all the XPS is doing, firefox browsing HN. My M2 has multiple docker containers, a collection of office apps open, browsers, vs code... and so on. My XPS battery will barely last until 1pm if it isn't plugged in, and the fan kicks on for no apparent reason... It will last a little longer if I manually set it to "best battery life" but even that can be surprisingly ineffective for no apparent reason sometimes. My M2 Air will last nearly two full working days (I haven't pushed it that far but so far it appears it would make it), the battery life is crazy. I go into the office and I don't even think about plugging it in, I know it will do fine. I don't know what it is about macOS and using their M chips but the efficiency is amazing to me. I even had a docker container freak out on my Air recently. It pegged a CPU core to 100% for a good 45 minutes. Temp skyrocketed. But I was on another virtual desktop and I didn't notice a thing. The OS ran smooth, vscode, node and everything else was running smooth. It wasn't until I looked at the status bar that I saw the CPU and temp had skyrocketed. I found the container responsible, killed it, and temp dropped quickly. Even under non ideal situations the Air performed well. With my XPS the moment I put it down I think about where I can plug it in. If I pick up my XPS to quick order some Tacos an…
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
It starts at $1,449.00 for 1080p screen, 8GB RAM, 512GB SSD. Why would the average user buy this over the M2 Air? Average user = Not doing anything that requires Windows or Linux. M2 Air has a better screen, faster CPU (plugged or unplugged), faster GPU, more battery life, fanless, runs cooler, better speakers, thinner, and it's cheaper. Also, I think not having function keys is a mistake. Touch keys are just awful on a keyboard. In addition, if you want to do even light gaming, you'd want function keys
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
It starts at $1,449.00 for 1080p screen, 8GB RAM, 512GB SSD. Why would the average user buy this over the M2 Air? Average user = Not doing anything that requires Windows or Linux. M2 Air has a better screen, faster CPU (plugged or unplugged), faster GPU, more battery life, fanless, runs cooler, better speakers, thinner, and it's cheaper. Also, I think not having function keys is a mistake. Touch keys are just awful on a keyboard. In addition, if you want to do even light gaming, you'd want function keys.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
Having swapped from my beloved 15” 2013 MBP to a slightly tarted up M1 14”, I have to say how impressed I’ve been with just about everything. Most of my work can be done from native Apple silicon apps which feel refreshingly snappy and result in just incredible battery life, and even when I’m running x86 apps in rosetta, it feels faster than my old i7 machine. The thing is still build like a tank, the screen is amazing, the speakers sound great when I use it for music in various hotel rooms, I really do love it as a tool. I was similarly impressed with the M2 air I’ve bought my partner. Its fast, weighs nothing, and feels really solid. The minor imperfections with the notch and such fade into the background when using it, same as they do on my pro. If I had any issues, its that running a Windows VM feels like a dodgy trick when I need to, as they still don’t license it legitimately. For Apple’s part, they seem to have made a very solid machine for people who just want a good computer to do work on. Of course, if you depend on Windows software, it’s not going to be for you, and I feel like the world lost its best windows laptop when bootcamp died, but thats only my opinion. I hope one day the Dells and HPs of the world can make machines that feel as solid as the Macs, but over the years I’ve always regretted buying XPSs and Omens because they just didn’t quite make the bar.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itDell XPS: Likes it
Did you ever try Stadia on hardware similar to these laptops? I did, and to be honest I thought performance was excellent. On my Pixel Slate, my 2015 XPS13, and my M2 MacBook Air - all gave great performance with no observable lag or bandwidth issues, even when playing on WiFi and streaming Netflix at the same time over a 76Mb/s connection. The only time the experience degraded was, oddly, when using the Stadia-bundled Chromecast, which even had a wired connection. Sadly, like basically everyone else, I never trusted Google enough to buy into the ecosystem - and consequently bought a grand total of 1 game.