The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air M2 vs Apple MacBook Pro

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air M2.

Apple MacBook Air M2Apple MacBook Pro
Owners with an opinion2343902
Positive verdicts84% of 19962% of 3276
Positive/negative since 202488/18945/592
Happy after 3+ years0355
Longest happy owner1 yrs16 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryperformance and reliability
Criticized fordisplay and portabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
I have an M2 Air 24GB/1TB that has been such a beast that I haven't touched my 16" Pro in months. I have four browsers running, with a ton of tabs in Brave (daily driver) and I'm sitting at 21/24GB utilization with all sorts of apps running (granted, Docker is not at the moment, but it still doesn't make it sweat). I had ~8 pro laptops in a row going back to the late 2000s, but Apple Silicon has changed how I work. A future 14" OLED that was similarly light might turn my head, but if I had to replace it today I'd just buy another M5 Air with at least this much RAM. [FYI I never installed Chrome after M1 came out. Brave has been rock-solid for over a half-decade now.]
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
I have a maxxed out 24G M2 Air that serves as my main portable (I also travel with a big 64G MBP). The inch matters a lot, and the Air’s screen edge is thicker, and it’s substantially heavier due to not having the terraced/tiered battery structure. I still have a MacBook9,1 with kubuntu on it I use for certain things sometimes. The small one really is so much more portable, even moreso than an iPad Pro with a keyboard cover (which is surprisingly dense).
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
Yeah, I've opened Activity Monitor and confirmed that it's Zed and/or the Python instance that Zed is spawning (via a 3.11 venv). To be fair, Zed is running just fine on an M2 MacBook Air. I just wouldn't expect a code editor, with minimal features enabled, to bog down a 2019 MacBook Pro.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
I was also a mid-2012 MBP user. I eventually got the M2 MBA because I was investing in my eyesight (modern displays are significantly better). I was never impressed with the touchbar-era macs, they didn't appeal to me and their keyboards were terrible. I think this M-series macbook airs are a worthy successor to the 2012 MBP. I fully intend to use this laptop for at least the same amount of time, ideally more. The lack of replaceable battery will probably be the eventual killer, which is a shame.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I used to always buy MBP's, but the new gen are all those super thick and heavy models. I tried one and couldn't get used to the thickness or weight. At that point I may as well get a desktop. I ended up buying M2 new MBA (from intel MBP), screen size similar enough, thickness good, weight good. And M2 is fast enough for 99% of the things I do. I did max the RAM to 24GB and wish there was more sometimes, and would love a faster SSD. Bot overall very happy.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
Macbook Air M2, all over again. Best goddamn laptop I've ever owned. I had a MacBook Pro Retina from 2012, which was replaced by a 2017 model through a warranty hack (though it worked flawlessly). The 2017 started losing keys on its 3rd keyboard replacement, but was really speedy still. Then I got a 2017 Macbook 12" which was perfect for backpacking. I didn't like syncing two laptops so I gave the 15" MBP to a friend. Eventually it struggled with playing YouTube Music while working, so I gave it to another friend. ...so I got the M2. Holy smokes is that thing good. It fixed everything wrong with the 2017 model AND improved things I didn't ask for. I'm not a diehard Apple fan, but I'm a diehard MacBook convert.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I have 2x intel macbook pro's that are honestly paperweights. Apple Silicon is infinitely faster. It's a bummer because one of them is also a 2018 fully loaded and I would have a hard time even selling it to someone because of how much better the M2/M3 is. It's wild when I see people building hackintoshes on like a Thinkpad T480 ... its like riding a pennyfarthing bicycle versus a ducati. My M2 Air is my favorite laptop of all time. Keyboard is finally back to being epic (esp compared to 2018 era, which I had to replace myself and that was NOT fun). It has no fan so it never makes noise. I rarely plug it in for AC power. I can hack almost all day on it (using remote SSH vscode to my beefy workstation) without plugging in. The other night I worked for 4 hours straight refactoring a ton of vue components and it went from 100% battery to 91% battery.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I don't think buying a new Macbook (or any computer) sooner than after 5-7 years of use is pretty meaningless for most cases. But going for a 2017 one is simply strange considering the differences in all areas. I switched from 2019 Pro to M2 Air and it's simply wonderfull. It's twiceas powerfull and completely silent and cold. 2019s Pro was good, but it's not nearly as fast for photo editing and hot as hell even if you just code in nvim.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I have the 15" M2 with 24GB. It's fantastic. I'm mostly doing web dev, and was thinking I'd use GitHub Codespaces if local Docker didn't work out (either because of performance or because of arm vs intel issues), but turns out that Docker runs very well on the M2. So well in fact that it's pretty nice to do dev work locally again (I used to do my work on the dreaded 2016 MBP, butterfly keys and all). So I can recommend the M2. The things I miss are more than 2 USB ports and to a little extent an HDR screen (the screen is good, but it's not as good as, say, an iPhone Pro or the MacBook Pro). I also haven't tried using it with more than one monitor, and I've heard that's not possible. I'm also not a fan of magsafe and would have much rather been given a USB-C cable to charge. I hope the new EU legislation kills magsafe but I doubt it (hot take, I know). If you're looking at the 16" MBP, then you should probably go to an Apple Store and just try lifting it up first. It's super heavy. I wouldn't want to carry that thing around.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
I personally use a 16" 2023 M2 Max MBP maxed out and it is honestly god like. However a good friend of mine uses the latest M2 powered Air with 16GB RAM and a 1TB SSD (the 24GB upgrade so a stretch too far for him) and I have to say it is a damn good machine and I could use it without much trouble. It doesn't throttle nearly as much as you would think for a fanless unit. Obviously it isn't as fast and he does hit swap when under a heavy workload whereas I am yet to hit swap but I also have 64GB vs his 16GB. So to answer your question. Yes I think the Air is an excellent development machine for 'up-to and maybe a little over' a "heavy-medium" development workload. If you're doing a lot on the machine then you will hit its limits for sure but if you're just running Xcode and a simulator or two, etc. or PyCharm and docker, etc. you will be just fine. If you're doing anything GPU heavy it isn't a great option but other than that I highly recommend it. However I suggest you look at the total price once you add in 24GB RAM and more SSD storage (at least 1TB imho) vs the 14" MacBook Pro. There isn't a huge difference between them yet the 14" Pro is basically as good as my 16" for most things. Especially if you can find a good returned unit on sale cheap via the Apple Refurb store. The machines are as good as new, same warranty, etc. Well worth checking out.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
I use my M2 Air 16GB for app development. Runs Webstorm, xcode simulator, node servers pretty smoothly. llama.cpp also runs fast enough. It runs some games okay (like KSP). I have a dock & external monitor to switch between my Air and M1 MBP and I don't notice a difference in performance when doing the same tasks that I normally do, but games run smoother.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
I'm convinced that the M2 MacBook Air is by far the best portable work device. It's got enough horsepower yet light enough to not break your back over. Previously, I've been carrying the latest 15inch and then 16 inch MacBook Pro since 2012 when I travel. I have an iPad Pro 12.9 with the magic keyboard as a device that's not purely for work but honestly, it's been collecting dust and I use it perhaps once a week to read news on the couch. It's pretty much a glorified note taker, a way to browse pictures/videos on a bigger screen, and respond to non-serious emails. For what I'm using, I don't think it's worth the $999+ price point.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
I "downsized" from a MacBook Pro 15 with high specs (i9, dedicated GPU, 64 GB RAM) to a MacBook Air M2 and don't regret the decision. I don't feel I'm missing out on anything except when I want to run a VM locally (Win 98 SE to play retro games). I think the M1/M2 chips are so good that there is no reason to want to upgrade as often and the baseline chips are good for 95% of the workloads people have.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Recommends it
If price is not a concern I might recommend sticking to the laptop route. There is no noticeable performance gap on the Pro line with the fan (wife has an M2 Air and I definitely notice throttling in stuff like Lightroom) I use a 14" M1 Max as my daily driver with an external monitor. I absolutely love the versatility. I run small video transcode jobs in Premiere/AME or render out things in After Effects daily and I never hear the fan or have any performance/heat issues of any kind. I am comparing this to my Win10 5950x/RTX 3080 desktop also at my desk and while that is definitely faster, I do not feel like my MBP is too far behind. If cost is a factor I think the Mac Mini is the best bang for your buck. Especially if you still have access to a .edu (or just say you are in college) and knock an additional $100 off.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
To me this sounds like issues on the Adobe side. I worked for 6 months on an M1 iMac with 8GB ram - it ran Xcode, iOS Sim, figma, slack, safari, terminal, calendar and zoom simultaneously for work on a large iOS app with zero issues. I used it because it was faster than using my i9 MBP 16” with 32GB of RAM - the MBP would be blasting its fans constantly with the same workload. Now I’m on an M2 Air and I don’t see myself needing to upgrade in the next 2-3 years.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
Another vote in favor of the Air for most people. I have an M2 Air with 24gb and a 16" M1 Pro or Max from work with tons of RAM and while I'm aware the 16" is vastly superior in a lot of ways on paper, in practice I hardly ever notice (or actually can't tell). The M2 has been powerful enough for everything I've thrown at it and then some; CaptureOne, dev work in Scala, fairly large Rust projects in VSCode, the occasional VM, 3d modelling, never felt bogged down. 24GB has been plenty for me and I've been kinda worried since I had more on my previous machine, but even with a bunch of containers and a VM here and there plus hundreds of tabs, half a dozen VSCode windows, CaptureOne in the background, a bunch of electron apps, ... it holds up just fine, with room to spare; not sure how that's possible, but I'm pretty sure it's managing to fit almost as much into 24gb than a previous Intel did into 32gb. Having no fan is an absolute game changer not just because of dust, but this way I can have the machine running near its thermal ceiling for extended amounts of time without going crazy from the fan noise, very handy when gaming, which I wouldn't want to do on the other Macbooks for that reason. I had to put a CPU indicator into the menubar because there's no way to hear high load anymore, so it's very easy to miss that Steam has crashed again and is now keeping all cores maxed etc. The silence really nice when using it in a quiet space, e.g. for tethered shooting without disturbin
Apple MacBook Air M2: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
I just got a MBA M2 (16 GB RAM) about a month ago. I picked it up the day before heading out of the country for a few months. I set it up that day, and everything worked fine. The next time I opened it, I was out of the country. The trackpad no longer worked. At all. Nothing worked to fix it. Apple support was only able to apologize and tell me to bring it in for repair the next time I am in the U.S. I managed to use keyboard shortcuts to pair it with a Bluetooth mouse, so at least it’s not a brick. Anyway, I’m just annoyed and wanted to gripe. So far, I’ve gotten Parallels running a Mac OS VM. That seems to run well although the laptop has kernel panicked once already. I’d say you’d be fine with the Air, but only if you upgrade the RAM. If you have the money and plan to keep the machine a few years, the MBP is probably worth it. As CIO of a 70 person company, we found that MBA M1s with 8GB were insufficient. People said they NEEDED the MBPs for performance, but I suspect they just liked the 16” MBPs for the screen real estate. Either way, they were largely unhappy with the stock MBAs and happy with stock MBP 16s.
Apple MacBook Air M2: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
The difference between an M2 air (8gb/512gb) versus an M1 pro (16gb/1tb) is much more than I expected. * M1 pro (16gb/1tb) can run the model in around 3 minutes. * M2 air (8gb/512gb) takes ~60 minutes for the same model. I knew there would be some throttling due to the m2 air's fanless model, but I had no idea it would be a 20x difference (albeit, the m1 pro does have double the RAM. I don't have any other macbooks to test this on).