The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air M1 vs Lenovo ThinkPad

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple MacBook Air M1Lenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion4692732
Positive verdicts82% of 41075% of 2366
Positive/negative since 2024156/35686/273
Happy after 3+ years17281
Longest happy owner6 yrs25 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryreliability and performance
Criticized forreliability and repairabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Sorry, but no: https://asahilinux.org/docs/platform/feature-support/m1/#tab... Can't even drive an external display over the DP. Linux support on Apple hardware is subpar compared to ARM Thinkpads.
Apple MacBook Air M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
> go back to buying Windows laptops and putting Linux on them. But they just aren't as nice. There are native Linux laptops from several manufacturers such as Slimbook, Star Labs, System76, Tuxedo etc. Or if you prefer mainstream OEMs both Lenovo and Dell sell laptops with Linux preloaded (or have official Linux compatibility listed on the spec sheet). And of course, there's also Framework, if you're in the lucky 10% of the world's population where they ship to. Personally I'm a big fan of ThinkPads - I have the Z13 Gen 1 and it's honestly running Linux on it has been one of the best non-MacBook laptop experiences I've ever had. Just picture this: all day battery life, suspend/resume that works 100% of the time, every bit of firmware upgradable from within Linux (fwupd) and literally *zero* errors in the dmesg/boot logs. I've had this machine for over 3 years now (running Bazzite and CachyOS, both on KDE) and have had no major with either the hardware or software. I've also got an M1 MacBook Air, and the only thing it does better is the battery life, but otherwise I vastly prefer my ThinkPad. Happy to answer any questions.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Sometimes, I travel with my nearly-15-year-old Thinkpad T420 in preference to my MacBook Air M1. The Macbook has a horrible keyboard with no travel. The buttonless trackpad is a pain to use; it's very hard to right-click and even with a 3rd party FOSS app to give me 3-finger middle-click, it's almost impossible to do it precisely. I use middle-click hundreds of times a day, but I have no use for trackpad gestures. It has a wretched 2 USB-C ports, one for power. I can't connect a mouse, keyboard, screen and power without carrying a dock. I can't upgrade the RAM. I recently had to remove Asahi Linux because it no longer had enough space to install the latest macOS 15 update -- the SSD can't be upgraded either. It feels like a laptop designed by and for a tablet user. I am not a tablet user. I don't like them much. The Thinkpad is a pleasure to use, and I can work on it all day for weeks without feeling especially cramped or anything. It has 2x the RAM and about 10x the SSD space. I've upgraded RAM, keyboard, main SSD, secondary SSD and battery, and it cost me next to nothing. The only virtues of the Macbook are that it's easy to carry and the battery lasts a long time. It's very unpleasant to actually work on.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
Is it unreasonable to think Framework should be able to make a laptop competitive with the 5 years old MacBook Air M1? I get that Framework focuses on making repairable machines, but does that prevent them from making a fanless, hi dpi, good performing, long battery life machine? I wouldn’t expect parity with an M4 machine, but it doesn’t seem unreasonable to think they should be competitive with the much older M1. I have the same complaint with Lenovo (I usually buy ThinkPads). Where are the fast, fanless, hidpi, long battery life laptops?
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
> i don't think that it holds up well in terms of performance Look, honestly, for a lot of us this does not matter. It's a 4-thread 64-bit computer with 16 gigs of RAM and not one but two arbitrarily large SSDs. Yes, there is modern bloatware -- any desktop app written in Javascript or using Electron, for starters -- that is a bit sluggish, but it's still usable. My X220 runs the latest Ubuntu 25.04 and runs it pretty well. Running Alpine Linux it's extremely snappy, and close to my M1 MacBook Air in performance. There is still a choice of tools. Choose your tools with some care and this is still a perfectly usable computer. Rolls Royce does not state performance figures for its cars; it merely says "adequate". The performance of an X220 is adequate. Computers stopped doubling in performance every 18 months or so nearly 20 years ago now, and since then, they've gained on average about 10% - 15% performance every generation instead. It's still got adequate horsepower for general use. I can run a VM with a whole modern OS in it and write about that OS in a rich text editor at the same time, while running a browser with a dozen tabs for research and fact-checking. I don't need cutting-edge performance all the time. It's nice, but then again, the Thinkpad has a much better keyboard than any modern laptop money can buy and it also has 3 physical mouse buttons so I can middle-click. Between its horrible flat keyboard and no right-click or middle-click, I'd rather work all d…
Apple MacBook Air M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
The best upgrade I've ever done to my T420 was a 65W GaN charger (less than $20) and a USB-C to barrel power cable from AliExpress (~$5). So much more compact and aesthetically pleasing than the stock charger. Another cool upgrade is an HDD bay that you can install in place of the optical drive. Costs less than $5, lets you install both regular SATA SSD (no need to look for mSATA) and an HDD. Edit: total cost of my T420 with all upgrades I've done over the years is around $150. Pretty neat for a daily driver. I'd probably still use it if I could get hands on a good display and a conversion board, but I've switched to an M1 MacBook Air since then. Maybe I'll do a frankenpad build with the M1 motherboard in a ThinkPad case though!
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
Not OP, but I have an older generation Ryzen Thinkpad (Z13 with an AMD 6000 series APU). I also use Nobara Linux, which is based on Fedora, but has all the proprietary codecs etc out-of-the-box. I also use TLP (instead of my DE's power management tools), which is the de-facto recommended power management tool for Thinkpads (and other laptops too). 1. I no longer watch Netflix, but AFAIA, 1080p/4k is still a no go, as that requires proprietary DRM which isn't present in Linux/Linux browsers (Widevine L1 and PlayReady). But you can still watch Netflix in "SD", if you're okay with that. Not sure about fandom services, but if they don't use DRM it should be fine, for instance, YouTube 4K plays without any issues, and so do other sites like Piped/Invidious etc. 2. Sleep/wakeup works fine on AMD, MacBook style. I also use an M1 MBA, so when I say that the resume speeds are identical, I mean it. The default sleep mode btw is suspend-to-idle, which resumes instantly compared to the old method (S3/suspend-to-RAM). 3. By "sane" did you mean S3? If so, at least on AMD laptops and Linux, you can pass `mem_sleep_default=deep` to the kernel and it'll use S3 mode instead of s2idle. However, a couple of things: at least on my setup, s2idle drains very little battery and doesn't cause your backpack to heat up. But if you're still concerned about battery drain over longer periods of time, you could enable the suspend-then-hibernate option, which will cause your laptop to automatically hibernat…
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
Look, I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just saying I get 4 hours of web browsing out of my M1 air with 83% battery health so it must go deeper, like Firefox is deoptimized or something. It's about on par with my ThinkPad E14, and worse than my 2017 i7 MacBook Air, disappointingly.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Use to be 100% linux person. I've gone through many thinkpads. M1 Air is so far beyond them it's not even close. Battery life is (not exaggerating) 5x or more in my experience. It's honest to god, much faster. Completely silent and cool. (one of my thinkpads almost burned me it got so hot, and the fans get so loud) I've never had a single crash, random restart, failure to sleep, failure to charge, driver problem, touchpad randomly not working, wifi failing, all of which I've had with thinkpads.
Apple MacBook Air M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
Just for clarification, the parent I was originally responding to was expressing their negative view about the Nano and how they love their M1 MacBook Pro, so I wanted to provide my experience with the two laptops that I have used extensively. I did briefly have a 2020 M1 Air for 2 years. It was fine for carrying around. It failed for portability primarily in its inability to dock to a 2 monitor workstation. I still vastly prefer my Nano as a portable laptop to travel with (e.g. plane or bus travel outside of my city). The Air indeed weighs very little, but it still weighs 40% more than a Nano! I usually travel with a portable screen that weighs half a pound, so my combo still weighs less than just an Air. It’s hard to describe the experience with an Air, since weight is about physical feel, but that weight saving does make a difference. The Nano is so lightweight that I can quickly pick it up and use it on the sofa as comfortably as an iPad. My Nano even has a 5G SIM card slot that I can pop my cellphone SIM into. However, that only works on the Windows side for now. Finally, the keyboard is much more pleasant to type on with the Nano. It really is a great travel laptop. Add in the ability to natively run Arch Linux, and I’m happier than ever with it.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Yeah, well, Intel laptops are trash subjectively speaking . I'd much rather have an M1 MacBook Air than any current Intel machine. In the past, ThinkPads were my favorite, but they got rid of many ergonomic features and now I can't even use tpmiddle to make the middle trackpoint button function as middle click without using scrolling features. Also, the BIOS on my Ryzen 5000 ThinkPad is always max brightness, regardless of what I had last set it to, so it's extremely uncomfortable to turn on at night or just after waking up, which is basically the only two times I want to use my laptop. Previous ThinkPads lacked all these issues, so they were my favorite overall laptops, but it increasingly seems like Lenovo staff probably don't even use them; I bet they use MacBooks, lol. There is no reason MacBooks have to be the best modern laptops, and yet they are. That's why I think it's a good idea for this much effort to be put into making Linux/Free Desktop useful on them.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
For me I switched from a thinkpad running linux to an m1 macbook air for these reasons: - safari (for testing and debugging, not daily driving) - mobile app dev for iOS - nicer hardware experience than any linux laptop I know of (superior screen with perfect hidpi support, best trackpad, actual all day battery life, top-notch performance) without any major compromises for my needs - full hardware compatibility without any fiddling (my thinkpad required regular fiddling to deal with the fingerprint sensor and runaway power drain) I don’t run into any of the issues you mention, but I use a very trackpad/mouse-oriented way of navigating because my brain refuses to remember lots of shortcuts, and I have an assortment of mac utility apps that fill the gaps (like moom for window tiling).
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I am long time (15+ years) FreeBSD user and sysadmin. My employer used to use RHEL Linux on ThinkPad T14 which worked for me. I configured GNOME with keyboard shortcuts I use daily on my FreeBSD ThinkPad W520 and was quite happy with it - especially with several additional GNOME extensions. Unfortunately my employer decided that it will ditch Linux from admins laptops and forces migration to Windows ... but its also possible to get Apple Macbook. I am sick an tired of being sick and tired by Winblows bullshit so I decided to get Apple Macbook straight away. I got the M1 version of Macbook Air. Its nice light device ... but the keyboard is TERRIBLE to say the least - when you are used to the AWESOME W520 keyboard. But that is just the 'tip of the iceberg' of problems. The keyboards shortcuts are quite limited. You can use some external apps for that. Same for windows tiling. I wrote my own window tiler for X11/openbox. I needed to install Rectangle for that - and it works really well for that. ... but ZERO luck with free apps/solutions for MIDDLE CLICK copy/paste. I have tried free MiddleClick ... but seems it does not support Ventura yet. Generally after two decades with computers I fell like with two left hands at macOS. Both on software and hardware (keyboard) side. The interface is looking nice ... but you are also VERY limited to how small the interface or fonts can be. I prefer to have rather small fonts and/or interface as large fonts/interface takes too much screen spa…
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I use the m1 air for web development and the 16:10 aspect ratio combined with the retina screen and the gestures to easily swipe between full screen applications makes it feel less cramped than the 14 inch 1080p thinkpad it replaced. I never feel the need to hook it up to external displays. Of course, YMMV.
Apple MacBook Air M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I was recently tossing up between a ThinkPad x1 nano and a M1 air. Got them both second hand for a steal and had some time to play with them. If the nano had the battery life of the m1, and didn't sell for 50% more than the m1 was worth, I would have kept it. It just felt like an inviting machine, like a well worn paper notebook. More at home in my actual lap than any desk, no matter what position I was contorted in. And felt fine to toss around and treat rough, with the slightly cramped space only enhancing the experience of a light, portable machine. All making it something I carried around, just in case. Helped that it barely weighed anything at all. The air isn't too bad, but there's something sterile about it, and it doesn't fade in the background, or even a backpack, quite as well.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
Then don't buy an Apple laptop, simple. Buy a Thinkpad that is almost indestructible and you don't have these kind of problems, or as I did a Dell XPS 15 (though I can't talk about how solid it is, since I have it only since 2 months). Surely I would prefer Dell for the support, I have 1 year of premium assistance (if there is a fault a technician will come where I am to make the repair, I don't have to bring it to a store that takes days to do the repair on a computer that I need for my job) and with like 20$ more I got the coverage even for accidental damage. Apple doesn't have correct policy, first it doesn't recognize in warranty faults that should, and secondly repairs outside the warranty period cost more than buying a new computer, and it doesn't sell spare parts to others that are not Apple authorized repair center (that needs to apply the policy of Apple otherwise they will not send the spare parts): something called mafia.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
These numbers are usually lower in real life There are data sheets and then there is real life. People were raving about AMD laptops before. I got a ThinkPad T14 AMD with a 4750U. The stated psref battery life is MobileMark 2014: 14 hr, MobileMark 2018: 11.5 hr. In practice that was more like 7 hours on Windows (with a mild workload) and 3 hours on Linux. The CPU performance was merely ok and I could get the fans blowing quite quickly. Life with the laptop was quite miserable. There were many other paper cuts and despite being Linux-certified, I used Windows with WSL most of the time since basic things like suspend would at least work relatively reliably. I sold the T14 after 7 months (thank deity that there was a chip shortage, so I could recoup quite a lot of the 1400 Euro I paid for the T14), got a MacBook Air M1 and didn't look back. It's a world of difference.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
Am averaging 4-5 years with MacBook Pros though I made an exception and got an M1 MacBook Air when that came out. Have an array of MacMinis still in use dating back to 2012. Debating whether or not to upgrade the sole Windows laptop I have (2017 Thinkpad X1). Most of the programming I do is run on servers, I rarely compile on my systems except for personal use toys.