The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air M1 vs Apple MacBook Pro

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Air M1.

Apple MacBook Air M1Apple MacBook Pro
Owners with an opinion4693902
Positive verdicts82% of 41062% of 3276
Positive/negative since 2024156/35945/592
Happy after 3+ years17355
Longest happy owner6 yrs16 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryperformance and reliability
Criticized forreliability and repairabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air M1: NeutralApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
They get pretty expensive when you bump the ram and storage... I mean, it's less noticeable in today's market, but it was pretty rough... IIRC my M1 Air cost close to $3k with the extra memory, storage and 3 years of apple care, vs something like $1300 base price iirc. Similar for prior Macbook Pros I've had. If you can get by with a base model, they've been an okay deal.. and as mentioned a lot of the build features, display, touchpad, etc. are top of the line, best in class. But before the Neo, I'd still often pick a Lenovo Ideapad or similar for ~$500 or so first, and still might for more ram/storage. Mac is really good and the ram performance is generally better than slotted ram, so that helps a lot. It doesn't help, however if you want to run a VM/Docker or things that allocate/isolate memory usage away from native apps. I haven't even had a system with less than 16gb ram since before 2009... I've used as much as 70gb of memory with certain workloads on my desktop (though usually not nearly that much), but it's nice to have if/when you do need it without thrashing the storage drive.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
When you open up Activity Monitor, to the immediate left of the "Memory Used" and "Cached Files" that you see, you'll see the Memory Pressure graph that the guy above is talking about. On my 64 GB M1 Macbook Pro right now, I have 53.41 GB of Memory Used and 10.72 GB of Cached Files and 6.08 GB of swap, but Memory Pressure is green and extremely low. On my 8 GB M1 Macbook Air I just bought for OpenClaw, I'm at 6.94 GB Memory Used and 1.01 GB of Cached Files with 2.05 GB of Swap Used, and Memory Pressure is medium high at yellow, probably somewhere around 60-70%. You can open up the Terminal and run the command memory_pressure to get much more detailed data on what goes into calculating memory pressure - more than just the amount of swap used, it tracks swap I/O and a bunch of page and compressor data to get a more holistic sense of what's going on and how memory starved you're going to feel in practice. In any case - I've been absolutely mindblown at how fast my 3 8GB M1 Macbook Airs I just bought for ~$350 brand new have been - even with tons of Chrome tabs open, multiple terminal windows open, running OpenClaw and Claude Code and VS Code and doing a ton of development and testing, never once have they ever felt slow. Oftentimes they actually feel faster than my 64 GB M1 Macbook Pro, which kind of blows my mind and makes me wonder wtf is going on on my monster machine. Moreover, my M1 Macbook Pro drains battery like crazy and uses a ton of charge, whereas the Macbook Airs sta…
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
Something I've heard from someone that owns an iPhone 16 Pro is that animations are (were?) laggy sometimes. I was also looking at some pictures on an iPhone the other day (unsure about the model, maybe 14?) and it felt like it was dropping some frames while switching apps. So while it may not be fundamentally broken, it's the type of stuff that would annoy me a lot if I used an iPhone. I never expect to go from smooth experience to a low-end Android phone experience after a software update. MacOS... I've avoided upgrading my M4 Max MBP so far after upgrading the M1 Air we have at home. It's just not as smooth as before, even with reduced transparency.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
Yeah when I got the first gen base model M1 Air, I put it to the test against my maxed out i9 MacBook Pro (basically the last Intel model they released, so it was the “best of the best” they had to offer on the Intel side). I tried out using Handbrake to CPU encode the same video on both devices. Amazingly the M1 Air was slightly faster than the i9, while comparatively sipping power, and staying relatively cool without even having a fan. The i9 on the other hand drained its battery super fast, sounded like a jet plane taking off, and was too hot to sit on my lap. That’s when I knew it was really a massive leap forward.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
> A [macbook] battery replacement involves carefully prying out a glued component. Can't speak to every model, but it's not always like this. I just swapped the battery on my 2020 M1 Macbook Air, and it's much easier now. The battery is glued to a metal tray that unscrews and lifts out of the laptop. It is discarded with the old battery. The tray is also held down with pull-tab adhesive strips, but they are trivial to remove - similar to what "command hooks" have. https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/MacBook+Air+13-Inch+Late+2020+B... I've also done a battery swap on a 2015 Macbook Pro 15" - much harder. Each individual battery cell is glued directly to the chassis, and removing each one involves a lot of prying and praying it doesn't puncture or decide to detonate. Back to the macbook air, I've also replaced the screen and USB-C ports. It's not that bad.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
When I owned an M1 Air the keys felt "thin" and "hollow" when bottoming out, versus the Pros which have always felt slightly softer without losing responsiveness. You can hear the difference between the keyboards at full speed typing. The M1 Air sounded cheaper to me. Can't speak to M4 Air.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I play Football Manager on my M1 Air and I've never felt heat. This is a game that used to turn my Intel MacBook Pro into a testicle roaster with 2 hour battery life.
Apple MacBook Air M1: NeutralApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
The 2011 Intel macbook air I used when visiting home throughout college was downright _dangerous_ on a lap, but performed so much better than my Atom-based Aspire One that I felt compelled to learn to tolerate OSX, as a longtime Linux nerd. I eventually got the M1 Air for serious ocaml and rust development and found it would get quite toasty (tho never concerning) during big compile/test cycles, but generally only over several dozen seconds of full load. I upgraded to a 14” pro with an M2 Max and am reasonably happy with it and think it was an important upgrade for my productivity. In daily use, fans kick in rarely but when needed for a speciality job like TLA model checking, they can reject a lot of heat (= performance margin). Of course it would be nice if it weighed less (mine is 1.8kg after including a case), but as a side benefit the machine can play games (even emulated x86 ones inside Parallels!) so it’s hard to say I’m worse off than my previous status quo of VSCode remoting into my big Linux desktop :)
Apple MacBook Air M1: NeutralApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
This solidifies my satisfaction with my choice of a mid-spec’d M4 Pro to replace my M1 Air. I wanted more RAM, so I went with the middle option with 24 GB. Similarly, I mostly care about single-core performance, so the Max didn’t seem like a huge deal. I’m still getting used to the weight of a 14” Pro vs. a 13” Air, but the additional screen size is terrific. The only thing I’m unsure about is the matte screen option. I saw screenshots that seemed as though contrast gets blown out, so I kept the glossy. I’ve seen others say at normal laptop viewing angles, this is not the case.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
My 2019 i9 flagship MBP is just so, so terrible, and my wife's M1 MacBook Air is so, so great. I can't get over how much better her computer is than mine.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
Same. In comparison, my last job I joined right when the last of the Intel Macs were going away, so my work machine was a fully loaded 16” i9 MBP. Aside from being enormous, and having the battery life of a gaming laptop, it would get absurdly hot unless I disabled Turbo. While the heat wasn’t a physical problem when docked, it would spin the fans up, and sometimes I don’t want headphones on. I don’t know who thought shoving an i9 into a laptop designed to be sleek and quiet was a good idea, but they were mistaken. Oh, also, my base (8 GB RAM, 256 GB SSD) M1 Air destroyed the i9 in actual workloads.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
I have been using an iPhone 14 Pro. It's thick, I think I got used to it? Recently someone handed me an old Samsung Galaxy S7 to use for testing. It was a revelation: I wanted and dearly missed having a phone that thin. I really hope someone pushes for thinness again. I miss the iPhone 6 (Edit: a big part of this might be down to the weight, the squared off edges, and the enormous camera bump) Same thing with laptops. I updated from a MacBook Air M1 to a MacBook Pro 14". The 14" is fast enough to justify its bulk — but barely. Every time I pick up the Air it feels effortlessly portable, when I grab the MacBook Pro it just does not feel thin and light enough
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
I replaced a 16GB Intel MacBook Pro with an 8GB refurb M1 Air and regretted it within weeks. (Due to the initial claims about M1 using less memory and that the M1 destroyed my Intel's Javascript performance.) Turns out that my 8GB machine would slow down significantly when hitting the RAM limit. This was expecially noticeable when running Final Cut Pro (almost unusable) or Photo Mechanic + Photoshop (I'd have to quit one to run the other). I tolerated this situation until the M2 Airs came out and I maxed it to 24GB RAM, and have been beyond happy with it since then! My partner now has my 8GB M1 and it works perfectly for her.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
My 2018 15" MacBook Pro has been used daily (since 2018) and still works great. I have never had a single issue with it. My M1 MacBook air has had a logic board replacement, and is currently getting a screen replacement because it shattered from the light pressure of my finger while adjusting the angle of the screen. Both of these issues seem to be very common across the internet. Before someone chimes in saying that I closed the lid on something and cracked the screen. No, It cracked while the lid was open, when my finger touched the display. Also it is the inner actual LCD that cracked. The outer glass sheet has no damage at all.