The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air M1 vs Apple MacBook Air M2

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook Air M1.

Apple MacBook Air M1Apple MacBook Air M2
Owners with an opinion469234
Positive verdicts82% of 41084% of 199
Positive/negative since 2024156/3588/18
Happy after 3+ years170
Longest happy owner6 yrs1 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryperformance and battery
Criticized forreliability and repairabilitydisplay and portability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air M1: Recommends itApple MacBook Air M2: Likes it
The main thing that held me back from using Asahi on my M2 MacBook air - was missing external display. If I read TFA correctly - that should now work with a custom kernel. If that's true - I'd say MacBook air M2 is probably the new sweetspot - depending on how cheap you could get an M1. My impression is that until now, MacBook air M1 was the sweetspot.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Air M2: Neutral
Mine came yesterday. It's nice enough, and exactly what one would expect from a minor speed bump. Doesn't feel any different than my work M2 Air, though it's faster? It feels a bit snappier than the M1 Air it replaced, and for the same spec it's cheaper these 3+ years later. The subtle blue is nice, it's like a colder sliver look than what it was. I'd still like one in the blue that the series 6 watches came in. I wouldn't have upgraded, except that I'm in need of a hand-me-down for a kid's laptop. Oddly, using Migration assistant -- display and internal/external keyboard settings didn't transfer over, but Apple Intelligence remained off. Chrome reset it's search engine.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Air M2: Likes it
And I have a HP ZBook G3 purchased in 2016 that I still use and have no need of replacing, it came with 32GB RAM, 512GB nvme SSD, 4k display, 3 year on-site warranty and has been upgraded to 64GB RAM 2TB nvme SSD + 4TB nvme SSD. I have mid 2020 Samsung Galaxy FE20, inherited from my wife when she upgraded on a work plan, still getting regular firmware updates and again I seen no need to upgrade this phone for another few years. Oldest computer I use on regular basis is Samsung ATIV Pro 700T from 2013 with upgraded storage (I would have upgraded the RAM if it was possible). At work I have a 2020 i5 macbook air which is almost useless compared to both of those non-Apple machines and 2022 M2 air which works quite nicely for now but since it is not possible to upgrade it will likely be obsolete in a couple of years (like the 2020 macbook) when Apple decides that you now must have 16GB RAM for Mac OS 14 or 15 or whatever. So Apple hardware is neither special nor unique nor worth the premium.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Air M2: Recommends it
8GB is still good enough for office workers and students. Heck, I used an M1 8GB Air for 1 year as a dev. Although I wish I had more RAM, it still served me well. For $899 (on sale sometimes), the M2 Air is absolutely a steal. The screen quality, build quality, SoC, quietness, coolness, metal enclosure, touchpad, and speakers are simply unmatched by anything in the PC world at that price - sometimes any price. Those things cost Apple money. Other PC makers cheap out on them. In order for Apple to earn higher margins, they make the RAM and storage upgrades very expensive. So the base versions actually offer great values. It's the upgraded RAM/storage that decreases the value but still good value overall considering what you're getting. I understand why 8GB is still the base. Everything except the RAM is outstanding and unmatched. Apple makes the money on RAM and storage upgrades. Perhaps Apple will start at 12GB for M4 generation. Perhaps the arrival of local LLMs will make skyrocket RAM upgrade demand such that Apple can start the base at 16GB and still have plenty of people who want to upgrade to 32GB. The problem for Apple will always be how they can increase the base without hurting upgrade profit. On a slightly related note: $/GB for RAM hit a wall starting in 2011. https://assets.ourworldindata.org/grapher/exports/historical...
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Air M2: Doesn’t like it
That's funny, the only two electronics deals I routinely follow are Costco's Macs and Chromebooks. Their $799 M1 Air is still a steal, and the M1 Mac Mini for $299 was unbeatable for the moment it lasted ($499 for the M2 Mini is pretty great, as well). $1200 for an 8GB M2 Air, though... It's a bit steep in comparison, but on it's own, it's really a 13" MBP inside... And if it's practically a Pro, why not just get the 14" for $1600? I think their final lineup of sickly Intel Macs really distorted things with the operations-centric "come get your ports, lol" pricing. Those are awful machines, and setting the expectation that a device's capability should be related to its display size was such a thinly veiled intelligence test. Between barely refreshing their hardware over a decade (the trashcan Pro was X79-based) and Batterygate, it wasn't their brightest era.
Apple MacBook Air M1: NeutralApple MacBook Air M2: Neutral
Almost always you can get the PKGBUILD file from either Arch Linux Gitlab or the AUR gitlab and just add the aarch64 version of the package to it and then install from that. I have an M1 and M2 macbook airs that I use for home/work and I think the only package I've actually hit a hard stop on is discord, everything else can just be built from source if they don't have a bin version..
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Air M2: Likes it
Going to copy/paste from a comment I posted a year or so ago. I have a 12th gen Framework 13", 13" M1 Air, and a 15" M2 Air. I use the Framework laptop for work because I need to use Linux. The Framework laptop is mediocre just like pretty much all PC laptops. The hinges are awful, if you pick up the laptop upright, about 50% of the time the screen falls flat 180 degrees. The trackpad is arse in Linux. If you're lucky you can probably get 5 hours battery life, but on a realistic workload you're looking at 2-3 hours. The keyboard is pretty nice, but I wish ctrl/fn is swapped like Apple and it has the inverted mini-T keyboard arrows (or at least I wish someone would make a swappable keyboard for the Framework). The speakers are bloody awful. Display/Webcam/Mic are fine. I would like more ports over modular ports, but I appreciate the design that went into the modular ports. Speaking of modular ports, sometimes they abruptly stop working and require removing and reseating. All these small nits really add up and it just feels like a mediocre experience. It is my work laptop, but I try my best to avoid using it over my PC with WSL2 or either Air laptop, but I try my best not to mix work and personal. Both the 13" M1 Air and 15" M2 Air are just amazing compared to the Framework, and I suspect PC laptops in general. They have their drawbacks, price (gouging in some ways), less ports, can't drive dual displays, but their trackpad, finish, speakers, etc. are just amazing. I personally…
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Air M2: Likes it
Going to copy/paste from a comment I posted a year or so ago. I have a 12th gen Framework 13", 13" M1 Air, and a 15" M2 Air. I use the Framework laptop for work because I need to use Linux. The Framework laptop is mediocre just like pretty much all PC laptops. The hinges are awful, if you pick up the laptop upright, about 50% of the time the screen falls flat 180 degrees. The trackpad is arse in Linux. If you're lucky you can probably get 5 hours battery life, but on a realistic workload you're looking at 2-3 hours. The keyboard is pretty nice, but I wish ctrl/fn is swapped like Apple and it has the inverted mini-T keyboard arrows (or at least I wish someone would make a swappable keyboard for the Framework). The speakers are bloody awful. Display/Webcam/Mic are fine. I would like more ports over modular ports, but I appreciate the design that went into the modular ports. Speaking of modular ports, sometimes they abruptly stop working and require removing and reseating. All these small nits really add up and it just feels like a mediocre experience. It is my work laptop, but I try my best to avoid using it over my PC with WSL2 or either Air laptop, but I try my best not to mix work and personal. Both the 13" M1 Air and 15" M2 Air are just amazing compared to the Framework, and I suspect PC laptops in general. They have their drawbacks, price (gouging in some ways), less ports, can't drive dual displays, but their trackpad, finish, speakers, etc. are just amazing. I personally…
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Air M2: Likes it
What concerns me the most is the repairability. We make extensive use of Macbook Air M1 and M2 units, and we have a support contract for repairing the devices onsite. We also have a support contract for repair of Surface Pro units, and when these die they get sent away to Microsoft and a replacement eventually arrives. From what I can tell, they have dreadful repairability.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Air M2: Likes it
Going to copy/paste from a comment I posted a year or so ago. I have a 12th gen Framework 13", 13" M1 Air, and a 15" M2 Air. I use the Framework laptop for work because I need to use Linux. The Framework laptop is mediocre just like pretty much all PC laptops. The hinges are awful, if you pick up the laptop upright, about 50% of the time the screen falls flat 180 degrees. The trackpad is arse in Linux. If you're lucky you can probably get 5 hours battery life, but on a realistic workload you're looking at 2-3 hours. The keyboard is pretty nice, but I wish ctrl/fn is swapped like Apple and it has the inverted mini-T keyboard arrows (or at least I wish someone would make a swappable keyboard for the Framework). The speakers are bloody awful. Display/Webcam/Mic are fine. I would like more ports over modular ports, but I appreciate the design that went into the modular ports. Speaking of modular ports, sometimes they abruptly stop working and require removing and reseating. All these small nits really add up and it just feels like a mediocre experience. It is my work laptop, but I try my best to avoid using it over my PC with WSL2 or either Air laptop, but I try my best not to mix work and personal. Both the 13" M1 Air and 15" M2 Air are just amazing compared to the Framework, and I suspect PC laptops in general. They have their drawbacks, price (gouging in some ways), less ports, can't drive dual displays, but their trackpad, finish, speakers, etc. are just amazing. I personally…
Apple MacBook Air M1: Likes itApple MacBook Air M2: Likes it
I did all of that on an M1 MacBook Air and now on a M2 without any problems whatsoever. Only caveat the Airs have is that you can't attach more than one external screen without some workarounds[1]. If you don't rely on that the machine should be more than capable of what you're looking for! 1: https://www.macworld.com/article/675869/how-to-connect-two-o...
Apple MacBook Air M1: NeutralApple MacBook Air M2: Neutral
I sold my M1 MacBook Air to someone and bought an M2 MacBook Air to get more storage. I gave them a discount because of physical damage to the machine, but if I had sold it at market value I would've recouped most of my original expenses. I took the minute to read Apple's instructions before selling so they had no issues, and it's no longer attached to my account.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Air M2: Doesn’t like it
I just got a MBA M2 (16 GB RAM) about a month ago. I picked it up the day before heading out of the country for a few months. I set it up that day, and everything worked fine. The next time I opened it, I was out of the country. The trackpad no longer worked. At all. Nothing worked to fix it. Apple support was only able to apologize and tell me to bring it in for repair the next time I am in the U.S. I managed to use keyboard shortcuts to pair it with a Bluetooth mouse, so at least it’s not a brick. Anyway, I’m just annoyed and wanted to gripe. So far, I’ve gotten Parallels running a Mac OS VM. That seems to run well although the laptop has kernel panicked once already. I’d say you’d be fine with the Air, but only if you upgrade the RAM. If you have the money and plan to keep the machine a few years, the MBP is probably worth it. As CIO of a 70 person company, we found that MBA M1s with 8GB were insufficient. People said they NEEDED the MBPs for performance, but I suspect they just liked the 16” MBPs for the screen real estate. Either way, they were largely unhappy with the stock MBAs and happy with stock MBP 16s.
Apple MacBook Air M1: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Air M2: Doesn’t like it
My (affordable) 2013 11-inch (Intel-based) MacBook Air supports two external (Apple) displays without any issues. In fact, I have two Apple Thunderbolt Displays (A1407) daisy-chained to each other and connected to the thunderbolt port, working flawlessly (with added benefit of integrated ethernet, webcam, and speakers). Since getting added to "Apple Obsolete List", I was hoping to replace the machine with an M1 MacBook Air, but paused bc of lack of multiple monitor support. M2 MacBook Air not supporting it either is a real disappointment, and not sure what to do other than hope Apple re-enables this basic feature on its low-end Mac before my 2013 completely dies.