The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple Mac vs Lenovo ThinkPad X1

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Lenovo ThinkPad X1.

Apple MacLenovo ThinkPad X1
Owners with an opinion803376
Positive verdicts63% of 70371% of 335
Positive/negative since 2024222/13398/57
Happy after 3+ years3728
Longest happy owner28 yrs11 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forsoftwarebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Neutral
I could easily see someone preferring macOS to Windows, with how ad-ridden and pushy 10 and 11 have become. To me it would’ve been more understandable if someone preferred Windows back in the days of 7, which I liked even as someone who’s long been disinclined from Windows. For macOS vs. Linux it’s more fuzzy, but there are still some ways the macOS experience is a bit smoother once everything is up and running, like dodging the tinkeriness of X11 and awkwardness of the transition from X11 to Wayland… for example, you’ll never see blurry XWayland windows because someone forgot to update Electron. That said I haven’t hackintoshed in several years. It stopped feeling as necessary after M1 came out, with my reasons for doing so being lack of power and bad cooling endemic to late 2020s Intel Macs. These days I use real Macs alongside a custom built gaming tower running Windows and ThinkPad X1 Nano running Fedora.
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I finally dumped Mac completely for Ubuntu LTS on a Lenovo X1 Carbon about 12 months ago. My experience is that I'm now tinkering with things less on Linux than I used to on macOS/OS X. I have an external Thundebolt dock that actually works. I'm not on the Xcode treadmill forcing me to update an OS because Apple dropped support. Updates are on my schedule instead of Apple's. I can use an actual standard 3D API (Vulkan) rather than the undocumented pile of crap that is Metal. My Bluetooth speakers are more reliable than they were on macOS. I can set my monitor resolutions without buying a dumbass Mac App. My printing system never gets confused forcing me to reinstall all my printers. I can go on and on. Is it flawless? No. About once a week, my cursor response goes to absolute shit for about 90 seconds for no obvious reason. Occasionally, I hit one of the Wayland corner cases. Lots of software still doesn't run on Linux--so I have to keep a Windows box floating around, but I had to do that even with macOS. I've had 2 hangs over the last 12 months. But, overall, while I can list grievances about my Macs endlessly , I have to actually think hard about what has genuinely pissed me off about Ubuntu. I'm not going to deny anyone's experiences because when that's done to me I just get pissed off. In addition, I made a point to buy somewhat more expensive hardware that was a decent match to Ubuntu (better quality laptop, i5 for better thermal performance, max RAM and S…
Apple Mac: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
Love my M1 Mac now that I'm a front end dev. The node ecosystem is mostly compatible with it now, except some really old modules. Back when I was backend, though, Docker and LEMP virtualization was nightmarish to use (late 2020). Maybe things have gotten better. In general, if you need legacy support, I'd stay far away from the M1. Otherwise go for it, best laptop I've ever had by far! (the only machine that comes close is the ThinkPad x1 Carbon)
Switched from the Apple Mac to the Lenovo ThinkPad X1Lenovo ThinkPad X1: Neutral
> how am I suppose to make it "more constructive"? Obviously by shutting the hell up, you ungrateful serf. The beatings will continue until morale improves. Seriously, though, if you want this to stop, people like you are going to have to start voting with their wallets. I finally pulled the plug on macOS a couple years ago for Linux, and I haven't been unhappy about it. However, I did make a point of buying a laptop that was well supported on Linux (a Lenovo X1 Carbon that was in the same price class as an equivalent Mac).
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
People have differently sized hands too: with my fingers on the home row, 13" and 14" Macs have the heels of my hands resting exactly on the sharp bottom edge. Glare from the screen can affect you more if you have problems with halos in general (many vision problems can cause them, and fatigue won't help either), causing reflections to disproportionately affect legibility of the screen for you. Finally, the keyboards are simply bad in comparison to best keyboards (in terms of typing feedback) on small portable laptops like Thinkpad X1 Carbons (though those have gotten significantly worse with Gen 7 onwards too). Additional gripe I'd have is that they are very heavy in this day and age when we are getting laptops under 1kg (2.2lbs) in 14" size that perform and hold battery adequately well. This only hurts if you travel a lot and carry more than one laptop with you (business and personal, for instance). But really, ergonomics is hard because everyone is different, and as long as you are outside the 2 SDs from average (and you can be so only on one of those measures, like your hand size or torso height or head size), your ergonomic position might be impossible.