The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple Mac vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Apple MacLenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion8032732
Positive verdicts63% of 70375% of 2366
Positive/negative since 2024222/133686/273
Happy after 3+ years37281
Longest happy owner28 yrs25 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forsoftwarebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Isn't that true for anything? Some people will sell 5yo hw in almost mint condition, whole others treat their hw like ass and it's garbage after two years already. The problem with used Macs is that they're still really expensive, and if you want to only run them with Apple software, the support duration is limited (especially true for phones, even more for Android ones). You can pick up used Thinkpads or Dells in great condition for very cheap after a few years.
Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I switched from Linux to Mac around the same age I think, I know Linux works much better now but Mac just works. I remember trying to connect a ThinkPad with an AMD/ATI graphic card I had paid extra to an external monitor on my ex-wife laptop, what a massive PITA and it never worked, it would just work with the Intel builtin GPU. I'm glad I suffered a bit with Linux it taught me vim and resilience and using the command line / shell, but for my day to day I'm happy with Mac. Ironically I just bought a Neo for my home laptop, I'm a bit annoyed by the keyboard because at work I have a 15/16 inches Macbook Pro but I don't do much on it so it's ok.
Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Thinkpads were the only Windows laptop I felt was worth buying. However, IBM selling to Lenovo, and then Lenovo having a couple high profile issues around 2015, with things like SuperFish, made me swear off the brand. Reputations take a long time to build. Lenovo bought their reputation from IBM and then threw it in the trash and set it on fire. I don’t think I’ll ever trust them enough to buy a PC from them. As a result, I end up buying Macs as my primary devices. Looking at the PC market, I can’t see paying a premium for anything being offered. I’ve regretted every attempt I’ve made to buy non-Apple hardware.
Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
> 5W Phone CPUs of today Yeah tbf I would probably consider just using my phone with my mobile usb-c monitor and bluetooth keyboard, if iOS was not so hostile to be used for actual work (and it does not seem simple in android either, though maybe I would be eventually able to make it work there). It would be very useful to have such a light setup on the go, as I do not necessarily need strong multicore performance all the time. > AMD chips with TDP configurable down to ~15W I don't trust the TDP values companies publish because there is no standard way to define what TDP is or how it is measured. At best they are consistent in how they measure them within each brand, so you can at least compare different generations. And in any case, the question is how competitive such a configuration is vs an ARM-based laptop, with much longer tradition in the low-power space. Could be my searching skills, but looking to get a laptop recently I did not find anything in a better spot in the efficiency/performance/price axes than an air. In particular I was unable to find AMD fanless laptops anyway. Just as an example, during light work with my m5 mac (eg editting a text file, or writing this comment while a youtube video plays in the background and a bunch of light stuff run in the background too, screen low lit) I see 3-4W total system consumption reported by the OS, while a wattmeter shows 7-9W consumed. Part of it may be hardware, part of it software, but figuring out idle consumption is…
Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I don't compile Linux or other large C projects on my M5 (why would I). The only thing I have numbers for on both desktop and mobile is your typical JS/TypeScript/webpack shitshow that struggles to keep a Threadripper remotely busy. Might as well do that on the M5. There's a large C++ codebase I need to compile, but it can't compile/run on OSX in the first place, hence the desktop that I use remotely for that. Since it's also kind of a shitshow, that one has really terrible compile times: up to 15 minutes on a high powered Intel ThinkPad I no longer use, ~2 minutes on desktop.
Apple Mac: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I think maybe you don't understand what the needs are of normal people. It's only partially about what software they run. I recommend Mac's to the people in my life because when they have a problem they can take the machine to the Apple Store in the mall. Or if they want to understand iPhoto or Pages better, they can go to the Apple Store and take a class. They like Apple laptops because they look nice, they feel great, sound amazing (for a laptop) and have excellent battery life. Like you, I have a ThinkPad (a P-something) and, frankly, it kind of sucks. It's all plasticy, it flexes, battery life is a joke, the trackpad is meh, and the fans are almost always running. I do like the keyboard though (I'm a fan of backspace).
Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
So what? Most people don't care about battery, so let's just have a crap battery? That argument would work, if Apple released a super light laptop with a tiny battery, specially made for "most people who sit at their desk". No, people do care about battery life. That's where Macs excel. (I'm saying this as a Thinkpad user, where getting 6-8hrs of battery is doable, if you don't do anything on the laptop).
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Resale price does not mean anything if most units have hardware issues which was largely the case for most +5y macs when I looked for them out of curiosity. Granted this is also the case of many brands but I found it was easier to find old thinkpad, fujitsu and dell business laptops in good shape than it was to find Apple ones. Maybe this is biased and it has more to do with professional vs personal use. I guess you are a bit more cautious with a laptop your employer is lending you.
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
HP have a better webcam (Higher res and better colours), Z Book and Framework have the same keyboard basically, the software is no where near as good (far more locked down), considering M series have been out for 5 and many had very speedy failures I doubt 8-10 years especially for the base models on low ram. Multicore scores (so for any form of simulation or parallel computing) work M series are not even in the conversation in comparison with the latest AMD and Intel. Another key issue is due to architecture change, their reusability once they become unusable in their current form means its Asahi or nothing. Repairability is non existant, a battery and some ports is not anything to shout about. I have used Macs since the early 90's when they were repairable, pretty much consistently and I still have to on occassion but they have dropped the ball on every aspect. From the late 90's repairability and innovation have gone downhill. The late 00's to the early 10's brought it back and ever since then bar the odd thing that is pretty but less practical, just look at the touch bar and the removal of ports. I have had Thinkpads, ZBooks, and other laptops such as Lets Note easily as long as a macbook and yes some of the pretty may be missing but that isn't what I focus on in devices.
Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I too have been on Mac for over 20 yrs, but day-jobs are sometimes on Windows. Currently I work in Ubuntu under Windows on a Lenovo X1 Carbon. I feel the same about moving away from Mac. Apple's hardware planned obsolescence/deprecation schedule would have been reasonable during the Moore's Law era, but it feels too fast now, so I'm looking at migrating to Linux on Framework laptops. I don't play games much anymore so don't really need Windows. Linux is fine, it's similar enough to macOS (and Windows, for that matter). For my tastes, all the OSes require some tweaking and compromise. I don't understand the fascination with tiling window mgmt, and disable it everywhere (was surprised it got added to macOS Sequoia). I love having different wallpapers on virtual desktops. Etc etc, there are all sorts of different setup options are available on one platform but not another. It turns out that my stumbling block is the trackpad and keyboard -- I know this issue is highly specific to each individual, so you may not care about this. I haven't tried them on a Framework laptop but they're both horrible IMO on the Thinkpad. (Other people tell me that I'm crazy and they love the keyboard, so YMMV.) The trackpad feels like plastic crap and responsiveness is subpar. Causing a right-click by pressing slightly right of center is annoying. The page up/down keys in the inverted-T pad get in the way. Even on Mac, I didn't like the era of full size left-right arrows, and bought a couple spare ol…
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Macs give me headache because of the screen being too bright/colorful and no option fixes this. Lenovo Thinkpads do not.
Apple Mac: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
As a web dev: Mac. 1000%. It can easily do the Unix-y things that you need to as a dev (Windows can too, it just takes a few more steps because it's not natively Unix-y.) But, importantly, it can also seamlessly use the apps that you need to use with your non-dev teammates, like opening your designers' files (if you need to manipulate a SVG in Illustrator, let's say) or running whatever corporate software they use (Microsoft Office, Zoom/Teams/etc.) There are always workarounds on Linux machines, but why waste time on them when most things don't need workarounds on a Mac or Windows machine. Lastly, the overwhelming majority of other web devs you'll likely meet will also be on Macs, and will only want to troubleshoot issues you might have on a Mac, and your issues on a Mac will get fixed way quicker than whatever obscure Linux flavor of the day might be. I haven't met a web dev not on a Mac for more than a decade now. (Firmware engineers, EEs, etc., sure, but not web devs). It's kinda a feedback loop... web devs love Macs because they're so good now, but then more web devs start to use Macs just because everyone else is too, and soon it's just the de facto standard for this work. The Apple Silicon machines in particular are really, REALLY, REALLY good in terms of performance vs power consumption (meaning long battery life, low heat, low/no noise). And there are no shitty ads like there are everywhere in Windows. When they first came out, there was some compatibility issues bet…
Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
In uni, I ran Ubuntu 7.04 for a summer on a Thinkpad R21. Similar to the author, I was obsessed in customizing in and making it look like OS X but without any direct experience with using a Mac. I even had a ding sound for completed downloads in Transmission-GTK and some form of grass wallpaper (but not the REAL grass wallpaper). I then had the realization that what I really wanted was a Mac. I was fortunate enough for my family to purchase me one which, with an AppleCare exchange for a unibody model, lasted me a whopping 11 years (Tiger to Mojave). I also still have that iPod nano from the back-to-school promo they used to have.
Apple Mac: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
The only non biased answer that you will probably get, as I have used all 3 extensively. I run windows on my desktop, linux on my laptop, and use a Mac for work. Ill group Windows and Linux into one for hardware since you will likely buy a windows laptop and install linux on it. Hardware wise, generally, battery life for use is worse compared to Mac. Generally, you can get ones that last like 10 hours with light use, so its not too much of an issue, but if you are frequently without a place to charge, you will find Macs much longer lasting. Also, depending on the laptop you get, you can get subpar touchpads and displays, but generally at $600 or above, these aren't an issue. Mac wise, the hardware problems are way more present. No way to change out SSD, no way to upgrade ram, no way to replace battery, and you have hardware locks on the software you can run. You also don't get a choice for an actual graphics card, which is a much better choice if you want to do mobile ML, as Apple ANE is pretty much reserved for their own software. Software wise, Windows 11 is pretty good these days, but you have to do some leg work. You need to get the pro version, sign on originally with a microsoft account, then turn on local login, and then disable a bunch of shit. There are github scripts for this, https://github.com/topics/windows-11-debloat is a good start. Its definitely a more resource heavy OS compared to Mac or Linux, but its the only one that can run ALL software, since WSL2 is…
Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I couldn’t fill out your survey as the questions were written with far too much of your own bias against Apple. I think any conclusions you draw will be skewed as a result. I was raised in a house where we were told Apple was an inferior computer and PCs were the only way to go. Not far from your current view. Eventually I grew up and gave them a chance out of boredom and frustration, and I liked them more than Windows or Linux at the time (this was back in 2003). My dad, who raised me to hate Apple, is now using 100% Apple products after he actually saw them and how they work first hand, and got burned several times by PCs. I never thought I’d see the day. Use what you like, let other people use what they like. If you’re curious, learn about it, but do it with an open mind. I don’t feel like you’re doing that currently. For me, during those early years, it was exiting to see Apple go from an extreme underdog position and fight its way back. It seemed like every year there was a big OS release that brought a ton of features that changed the way I used the system (Spotlight, QuickLook, etc), something I never experienced at the same level with Windows or Linux. The way different devices worked together was also something I hadn’t before experienced at that level. The iPod syncing with iTunes. Using iSync to get my contracts on my flip phone. It was all seamless. When the iPhone came out, that’s all went a step further and it has made my life much easier. Playing sys admin for…
Apple Mac: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Dealbreaker? No, but strong negative signal. I have my own preferences and ways-of-working, and having to adjust these on top of all the other new things that come with a new company or team is a significant downside. I've recently switched from daily-driving a mac to daily driving Linux on a Thinkpad, because for my startup I'm working on some Rust code that ends up being too much of a hassle to cross-compile, and the story for using GUI Linux in a VM on [edit: ARM64] macOS is not quite there yet. After 3 months I'm a lot more proficient than when I started, but I still feel so much less productive than I would be on a mac that I'm working on adding better abstractions to be able to mock out the stuff that doesn't build on macOS easily.
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I love this. shame it's kickstarter stage only. There's a real lack of anti-glare displays outside of a few thinkpads. I was even considering purchasing one of those huiwon art tablets to use as my monitor because it's a fully matte display. The Macs are particularly bad reflecting almost like mirrors. I'm not a fan of ultra-hi DPI super glare reflective displays at all.