The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple Mac vs Apple MacBook Pro

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple Mac.

Apple MacApple MacBook Pro
Owners with an opinion8033902
Positive verdicts63% of 70362% of 3276
Positive/negative since 2024222/133945/592
Happy after 3+ years37355
Longest happy owner28 yrs16 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwarebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
I switched from Linux to Mac around the same age I think, I know Linux works much better now but Mac just works. I remember trying to connect a ThinkPad with an AMD/ATI graphic card I had paid extra to an external monitor on my ex-wife laptop, what a massive PITA and it never worked, it would just work with the Intel builtin GPU. I'm glad I suffered a bit with Linux it taught me vim and resilience and using the command line / shell, but for my day to day I'm happy with Mac. Ironically I just bought a Neo for my home laptop, I'm a bit annoyed by the keyboard because at work I have a 15/16 inches Macbook Pro but I don't do much on it so it's ok.
Apple Mac: NeutralApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I had an 11” 2011 air. An incredible machine, one of the best I’ve ever owned. I stupidly replaced it with the 2016 retina touchbar MacBook Pro - which is hands down the worst Mac I’ve ever owned bar none. My modern M1 is fine. But that little air was somehow more fun.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
Anecdotally, my path was 2010 macbook pro -> 2015 macbook pro -> 2021 M1, with each device lasting about 10 years, and keeping 2 in flight at once. The 2015 one is showing it's age, and is likely to be replaced this year or next. Running linux on it isn't an option due to all the nonsense involved in suspend/sleep and the effect it has on battery life. I also have a 2007 Intel mac with firewire that I use for some audio stuff that's still going strong with just an SSD swap.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
In some cases yes, but having used Macs for decades and also working in companies with Macs for all the developers one thing is clear; these things don't easily break. Built extremely well. (One exception being the GPU issues a few years back though on Intel MBP's)
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
> Apple was a great option before they moved to ARM. Now they can't run much of anything (and it sucks). I used to love my 2013 MBP. ARM Macs run pretty much everything I need, and some things better than Windows (such as Lightroom and PS which don't run at all on Linux). But what kills it for me is the absolutely bonkers window management, and the fisher-price interface filling up half the screen with empty space around huge widgets.
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
The worst Apple era for me was the butterfly keyboard / touchbar era of Macs. They went too far in the pursuit of thin and light - removing ports, going with a keyboard design that felt bad to type on and was prone malfunction, and the touchbar, which I actually thought sounded cool at first, ended up being much less useful than a row of function keys. I didn't feel betrayed by Apple, I just decided not to buy a new MacBook until they fixed their keyboard issues. I switched to Linux for a couple of years, and switched back once they released the M1 MacBook Pro. I'm perfectly happy with my Macs (I have 3) now. I actually really like the current era of Apple where their motto seems to be give people what they want. MacBook Pros with HDMI ports and SD card readers. iPads finally getting viable multi-tasking support and a real mouse cursor (although iPadOS still sucks IMO). The iPhone 17 Pro is slightly thicker than the 16 Pro to allow for a bigger battery. Their storage and memory upgrade prices are still ridiculous, but at least Macs come with a usable 16 GB memory minimum now, and iPhones start with an honestly better-than-I-expected 256 GB storage. It's not all perfect - especially on the software side. The settings menu on iOS is kind of a cluster. Apple Music has a terrible UX, as does the recent update to Photos. And I haven't tried Tahoe and Liquid Glass yet - but I'm definitely a little concerned.
Apple Mac: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Yes. Just get (a Apple Silicon Mac) one in general. It just works. > However, lately I've become interested in this AI revolution, specifically LLMs. I'm interested in the prospect of running these inference models locally at some point. It runs even better on a Apple Silicon MacBook Pro. There is no question about it.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
It all depends what your use case is. Also, rant on how Apple was once my favorite, and now I hate them as much as 90s Microsoft. (M$ is no angel either with all their telemetry...) I manage macs at scale, and I notice they are getting worse and worse. After managing 150 Macs as MDM admin, I want Mac to get off the train they're on and start being predictable again. Intel macs run like crap now, while the M1s chug along nicely. I'm convinced Apple bakes engineering obsolesce into their old products to keep you on that 3 year device renewal period. They got sued for it more than once for the "Battery throttling" on the iPhone, and likely one of the only times they will ever get caught doing it. And they had an excelent PR push of "Battery health = performance, not my fault" We've had to straight-up replace fully-decked-out 2019 i7s with 32GB ram because they run so badly with modern software. Our graphic designer has a $3000+ laptop that is useless for their job. Massive fuckery is going on, because these are powerful machines. Why suspect malice when you can suspect incompetence? Apple has a track record of lying about their throttling, so I assume there's a culture of it and it pads their bottom line. The T480 is looking great, other than the bad keyboard they adopted after they killed-off the last genuine thinkpad keyboards. An optional video card would have been great for the T line, but you'd have to go with W or P for that I think. I don't trust big companies in General,…
Apple Mac: NeutralApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
Two big issues with my workflow caused by M1: -occasional Postgres failures (i/o errors, especially with parallelization) -kernel panics when connecting an external Sandisk ssd (known issue according to Apple forums) It’s a shame because the machine is so much faster and energy efficient than my 16” intel MacBook Pro
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
When I overloaded my Intel Mac it did the same thing. MacOS is just not that great under pressure. Bluetooth regularly dropped out even with just one build running, when I started 2 at the same time (iOS+Android) there was always a chance for a reboot. (64GB ram+i9 cpu) Had an M1 Mac Mini with 8GB ram for Lightroom+Chrome use, it did not cut it. 16" MBPro with 16GB ram is heaps better, but no developer experience on that machine. I think buying as much memory as you can afford is a good advice for Mac buyers. 8GB is enough for Chrome + a few native apps, but would go for 16GB for anything more and now you can get 24GB with the M2, that is nice (like a 20GB machine + a 4GB GPU).
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Neutral
A large number of Macbook Pros from around 2013-2015 have had failed SSDs. Mine failed 4 years ago. Because I was able to put in a new SSD - one twice the size and about twice the speed, I might add - I was able to keep using the system, and still am. I had to use an adapter, because Apple tried to discourage SSD replacement by using a proprietary pinout on the NVMe connector. If the soldered-on SSD in an M1 mac fails, you can't even boot the system . You can't send the system off to have someone do a board-level replacement, because apparently they do some bullshit to "pair" the flash chips with the flash controller. Apple has gone out of their way to take systems that used to be incredibly durable and long-lasting, and give them a very finite lifespan.
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
If you have a 5K2K monitor, as I do, then you are unable to enjoy decent 1.25 scaling. Everything looks pixelated because Apple don’t allow a ‘proper’ HiDPI mode with M1s. The same monitor is absolutely fine on a 2019 Macbook Pro. If you use BetterDummy, it creates a ‘fake’ display to mirror to. The result is beautifully clear display on the 5K2K. This is the crux of the issue. M1 macs can absolutely do nice 1.25 scaling on a 5120*2160 display to give crisp text in the 140dpi range but they disable it. That is the issue IMHO.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
The most mind-blowing thing about the M1 is that I've never seen the beachball cursor for the entire system ever since I got mine. Used to be a daily occurrence on my 2012 macbook pro and drove me nuts at times. This one is ridiculously responsive. On and I've only managed to get the fans to audibly spin after several minutes of compiling an Android app with a huge native library on an x86 NDK for 4 architectures.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
This is music to my ears. Thank you for your efforts. When I first started using my M1 Mac, it was like a computer from another planet. It was so freaking fast it took me back to the 90s/early 2000s when every upgrade was a night and day improvement. I could never believe a computer could be so snappy in everyday usage. It just brings joy every time I use it. Meanwhile I have this 2019 Core i9 Macbook pro at work and it is a slug compared to the M1.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like it
I definitely concur on Apple not going back to Intel. Like you said, beyond performance, the problem with Intel is that they don't make the chips that Apple really wants. Apple is able to put an M1 into an iPad Pro because they were able to design the thermal and power requirements of the chip to what they wanted. At the same time, it's a very good laptop chip (even in the non-Pro/Max version) and lets them ship a fan-less MacBook Air with the same chip. Because they control the whole hardware, they can go with an efficient unified memory architecture that doesn't require copying. Intel is pushing benchmarks on a 45 watt processor and trying to compare it to M1s using half the power or less. As a Mac user with an M1 Pro, I don't ever want to go back to a laptop that requires the fans to spin up all the time like my 2020 Intel MacBook Pro. Apple has shown that it can continue to churn out processors that are better than Qualcomm's (or anyone else) on the mobile side. It seems likely that they'll be able to maintain their pace with the M-series processors and it gives them the chance to build the best part for their needs. I don't think it's strange for Intel to say that. They want to put the impression in your head that their future chips are going to be so great that the richest company in the world will come back and say, "we're sorry for leaving, could we get some of your amazing chips?" If they say, "we've written off Apple," they're saying that they won't ever make chips…