The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple Mac vs Apple MacBook

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple Mac.

Apple MacApple MacBook
Owners with an opinion8032608
Positive verdicts63% of 70361% of 2254
Positive/negative since 2024222/133718/459
Happy after 3+ years37161
Longest happy owner28 yrs18 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwareease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Mac: NeutralApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
> It wasn't that long ago they had terrible keyboard lifespans which... Yes, their butterfly switch keyboards were really bad . I skipped that generation. I own machines from 2006, 2014 and 2020. > and overheating CPUs which limited performance way behind spec... Apple unfortunately does this sometimes, but interestingly just before changing CPU architectures (Power to Intel, Intel to ARM). I sometimes think whether it was semi-intentional. I don't blindly support them, however. > that is the basic usability of the system and window manager (sway), which is something Apple will never match until we meaningfully switch interaction paradigms. I'm way faster in my Debian + KDE system as well, but portables are always secondary machines for me, so Mac doesn't bother me much. Also, I like running different operating systems and paradigms at the same time, so I can learn from all of them while developing some stuff for myself and others. However, as I said multiple times over the years, macOS is the "alternative" OS for me, not the primary one. Linux has that part for the last 20+ years.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
I switched from Linux to Mac around the same age I think, I know Linux works much better now but Mac just works. I remember trying to connect a ThinkPad with an AMD/ATI graphic card I had paid extra to an external monitor on my ex-wife laptop, what a massive PITA and it never worked, it would just work with the Intel builtin GPU. I'm glad I suffered a bit with Linux it taught me vim and resilience and using the command line / shell, but for my day to day I'm happy with Mac. Ironically I just bought a Neo for my home laptop, I'm a bit annoyed by the keyboard because at work I have a 15/16 inches Macbook Pro but I don't do much on it so it's ok.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Recommends it
> The market for people who want to install Linux on a Mac laptop is very tiny. I suspect there would be an element of induced demand here. IMO the MacBook range are the only laptops on the market worth buying - but not having support for gaming (or at least, hilariously bad support for a limited range of games) is compelling enough reason to install Linux for a large portion of users (filling the void left behind by the widely adopted Bootcamp). > but the information needed to support an entire platform like this is not as simple as sharing a PDF. Yeah, GPU ISA, controllers, power management, NPU, and who knows what else. I still believe that companies should be compelled by regulators to offer documentation and support necessary to write drivers as I believe it is part of the "right to repair" (M1 will lose support in 2 years, it's still a great platform). > They chose to leave it open. I _really_ wonder on this point. It's so uncharacteristic of Apple. Were they concerned about potential anti-competitive lawsuits and maliciously did the bare minimum to avoid them? "It's technically open hardware, but good luck figuring out how it works"
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
Intel MacBooks were overpriced, under powered, overheating junk. They ran outdated processors at launch day and charged a premium because they had the best screens and track pads money could buy. Apple Silicon Macs are a 180. Fantastically fast and efficient hardware stuck with an increasingly locked down OS, zero upgrade path and still a premium price. If you’re holding on to the memory of Intel Macs I can certainly agree, they were not great.
Apple Mac: NeutralApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
> Why were you mucking with Grub configs? Because something went wrong. Because I needed to enable a driver, actually, and something on the Arch forums or AskUbuntu said that I could enable it in a boot parameter in my grub config. I cannot remember the specific driver, but it was absolutely not to fix any boot partition issues. Also, I explicitly stated that I didn't know what I was doing in the comment you're replying to. Please don't get me wrong; I really don't have any rose-tinted glasses in regards to Linux. I'm basically a Mac person now; my work computer is a Mac M3, my home computer is a MacBook i9. I do have NixOS dual-booted on my personal computer, and it's been a nightmare to get all the drivers working. Just kidding, they still don't work, because the Linux drivers for the T2 MacBooks are garbage. There's a good chance that I will be nuking the Linux partitions this weekend in all honesty. The only thing that runs Linux full time in my house is my server, which runs a NixOS install on a tmpfs root. It's not like I have a ton of love for Linux, if I did I would probably still be using it for my daily driver, but I just haven't had the dual-boot-partition issues that people complain about. Maybe it's because I so rarely actually went to Windows, but grub more or less did the job. I will acknowledge that getting Linux installed in a secureboot environment continues to be a pain, however.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
Apple made a bad computer by using components that were known to break down. Nvidia GPUs on mobile still break that way, and have broken in gaming laptops all the time. It took years for them to admit fault, by that time the computer was worthless. My friends Intel MacBook was good at first and it got worst and worst, he was glad he got applecare. His m1 Mac is doing great, but I'd call the quality closer to the consumer electronic I mentioned earlier. I've had other used MacBooks and laptops since, but apples customer service had gotten worst and there's long waits. If he didn't have apple care for the Intel one he would have hated his Mac too. Framework is probably not going to be around in less than 10 years. I'm happy some products but not the Apple company. Waiting for hours to be sent away at the apple store is never a luxury and a dreadful experience.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
Yeah there was a "crap zone" of Apple stuff around the butterfly keyboard disaster. The new M1 kit is completely 100% different grade of hardware. I have no issues with macOS UI as such. It takes about 6-9 months to get used to it though coming from anything else. When you get there it actually makes sense. I've seen a lot of Windows converts expect everything to be windows-like but it's more NextSTEP than windows.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
I upgraded to 16GB RAM and put a 1TB SATA3 SSD in it too. Never had an issue with the SATA flex cables myself, so I must have been lucky. The trackpad took some tinkering on Linux but I got it to behave like a Mac with three-finger drag. Didn't need rotate or any other gestures but I had got used to three-finger drag and 2 finger right-click. It's my daily driver. Amazing to think it started out running Snow Leopard. Great piece of hardware. Even the CD drive on it has been useful for ripping my entire 1000 CDs of yesteryear and then using sacad and kid3 to apply artwork to the MP3s, then host on Navidrome on a Pi4 at home with Wireguard VPN access so I can stream all my music on my phone using Subsonic whilst out and about. Really happy with the setup and the machine. Meanwhile my work 2016 Macbook's keyboard is playing up again after it was replaced (£900 worth, replaced free by Apple thanks).... Replacement includes the entire top panel and touchbar (which was defective too) and also a new battery...
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
>Mac laptop hardware is still better than Linux laptop hardware. As someone who's considering my first Linux laptop, I need to balance the inconveniences of Linux hardware now with the likely fact I can probably use that laptop significantly longer than current Mac. Somebody has to pay for all those convenient Mac support folks. The funny thing about that is that it's only with the Apple Silicon Macs that's true. The 2016-2020 Intel MacBooks were a garbage fire.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Likes it
My less-than-one-year-old Core Ultra 9 275HX was supposed to be much more power-efficient than previous generations, but I’m not impressed with it at all. Yes, it’s a gaming laptop, but why does it need 70 watts just to idle? And when playing Factorio with a CPU-heavy save, the PC uses 170 watts, while my M5 uses 50 watts on the exact same save. I don’t know how much the CPU alone is to blame for this, but I’m tired of x86 and Intel. My Linux laptop/server with Ubuntu and an AMD CPU is somewhat better (Also a gaming laptop), though. It’s only drawing 25 watts while idle while hosting six web services. So, if I were to go by just my anecdotal experience, having used about 10 different laptops over the last five years, Macs are just in another league when it comes to efficiency. However, the AMD/Linux combination is getting somewhat better at a slow pace, while Windows/Intel is stuck with terrible efficiency.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Likes it
Anecdotally, my path was 2010 macbook pro -> 2015 macbook pro -> 2021 M1, with each device lasting about 10 years, and keeping 2 in flight at once. The 2015 one is showing it's age, and is likely to be replaced this year or next. Running linux on it isn't an option due to all the nonsense involved in suspend/sleep and the effect it has on battery life. I also have a 2007 Intel mac with firewire that I use for some audio stuff that's still going strong with just an SSD swap.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Likes it
I’m still using my M1 MacBook from 6 years ago. My company keeps emailing me to upgrade to the newest one but everything works perfectly fine and the performance is more than adequate for dev work. Compared to pre-Apple silicon I was getting company exemptions to upgrade before I was technically allowed. M series Macs are just amazing devices.
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Likes it
> I've never personally understood the point of macOS for power users I am not sure how much I qualify, but here is my use case: it can run Photoshop and MS Office, it has Keynote, it can compile just about any software I use or I develop for my job (mostly Physics and computational Chemistry stuff). It just works for more than simple tasks. The alternatives are Windows (which I also use for other tasks), which is a nightmare to deal with and requires tons of faffing about to compile codes, and Linux (which is actually what I use most), which does not have a working Office and is very janky. That is not even considering the fact that MacBooks are the best laptops by a mile (my Mac is a desktop). > which makes it worth sacrificing the ability to run your machine the way you want? I do run my Linux box like I want. I spent hours upon ours ricing it up and fine tuning everything I cared about. Stuff still occasionally breaks after a minor update and I regularly have to roll back because of a misbehaving NVIDIA driver (at least once a year). On my Mac, I don't need to tweak every aspect of KDE because the default is fine. I don't need to be able to change pid1 because launchd is fine (but nowadays so is systemd). I don't need to install drivers because everything that does not work out of the box can be tweaked with SteerMouse and Karabiner (honestly, I would kill to have something that works that well on Linux). The couple of utilities I use are much, much better than the Linux…
Apple Mac: Likes itApple MacBook: Likes it
Personally, I feel passionately about being held back from innovating due to legal and corporate anti-competitive barriers. I feel that these artificial barriers contribute to a less competitive environment and increases the problem of e-waste. # The barriers put in place by companies to prevent their hardware from being tinkered with Locked bootloaders and the absence of hardware documentation to base the development of drivers on is an example of this. This prevents the community from taking over when a device reaches end of life or expanding a device to be more useful/open than the company originally intended. Examples of this are: - Apple's M-series Macs/MacBooks. While the hardware is remarkable, Apple's anti-competitive practices manifest in MacOS holding the devices back from their potential. Asahi Linux is an indicator of demand and its success is remarkable given what they are up against. If Apple was compelled to provide reference documentation of their hardware sufficient for driver development then the resulting alternative operating systems introduces competition to an otherwise stagnant market. - Microsoft's Surface laptops and broadly the new X-Elite hardware lineup shares the same criticism as Apple's platform - Mobile phones. Imagine an iPhone running Android. Imagine a Galaxy, Pixel, etc running Linux where Android apps are executed within Waydroid containers? Not going to happen because we are either blocked by bootloaders or blocked by a lack of drivers (d…
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
Don't buy a Mac with the intent of gaming on it. It's just not there. Apple is not really effective as improving gaming, despite what their marketing department wants you to believe. I bought an M3 Max with the intent of blowing cash, having good LLM performance, and maybe gaming. I certainly blew cash and it has good LLM performance, but the gaming is very meh. I even tried the Steam Link thing from my gaming PC and that was of dubious quality (graphics artifacting and latency). IIRC, Steam Link was running over Rosetta, because an Apple Silicon build wasn't available. There's a couple games, like Baldur's Gate 3 or whatever, but the Mac support forums for those games are full of bug complaints. I ended up building a ~$672 gaming PC (i3-13100 + RX 6600 on sales) last month and it's been great and I don't think about gaming on my Mac anymore. I supposed I should try Steam Link play as the i3 is surprisingly performant -- hopefully it's not the Mac's fault entirely.
Apple Mac: Doesn’t like itApple MacBook: Doesn’t like it
Weirdly I have both of these as well and feel total opposite. Give me the Thinkpad keyboard any day of the week. The mac keyboard feels down right anemic. I wish mac would stop making the track pad so damn big though, the amount of palm activations I have on that thing drive me bonkers.