The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Desktops and mini PCs

Apple Mac Pro vs Apple Mac Studio

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple Mac Studio.

Apple Mac ProApple Mac Studio
Owners with an opinion162221
Positive verdicts67% of 12470% of 174
Positive/negative since 202442/1888/43
Happy after 3+ years182
Longest happy owner17 yrs4 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forvaluevalue
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
I'd love for Apple to bring back the Mac Pro, but Apple hasn't had an affordable Mac Pro tower since the 2012 model. Apple got rid of the tower in 2013 in favor of the "trash can" model. When the trash can languished for years without updates due to limitations with its design, Apple brought back the tower Mac Pro in 2019, but at a dramatically higher entry MSRP, which priced out many users of tower and trash can Mac Pros (I have a "trash can" and was very disappointed by the 2019 Mac Pro's entry MSRP). The introduction of the Mac Studio revealed a large price gap between similarly-specified Mac Studio and Mac Pro models. Given the lack of expandable RAM in Apple Silicon Mac Pro models, and also given the lack of support for NVIDIA GPUs in macOS, there weren't a lot of customers for Apple Silicon Mac Pros when the Mac Studio was available at a lower price, and thus the Mac Pro got discontinued. In many ways, the Mac Studio is the spiritual successor to the trash can Mac Pro. Apple Silicon's architecture solved the thermal problems that limited the trash can Mac Pro.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
Maybe they are just for internal use? I doubt Apple is going back on the server market, and given how little they have invested in the Mac Pro, I doubt they are going to make a new version. There is little advantage compared to the Mac Studio for most users. External GPU support would change that, but it doesn't seem to be what they want.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
The latest Mac Pro really didn't make much use of its size, as there were too few useful things to put into. Especially as the GPU is now part of the package anyway. Also, the Mac Studio is the perfect workstation for the desk. Still, there are a few things which could be improved relative to the current Studio. First, the ability to easily clean the internals from dust. You should be able to just lift the lid and clean the computer. Also, it would be great to have one Mac which you could just plug in a bunch of NVMe disks. On the other side, they might replace the Mac Pro with a rack mountable machine as the demand for ARM servers in the cloud raises.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
I do love the Mac Studio. I had a 2019 Mac Pro, the Intel cheesegrater, but my home office upstairs became unpleasant with it pushing out 300W+. I replaced it with the M2 Ultra Studio for a fraction of the heat output (though I did had to buy an OWC 4xNVMe bay). > I bet there’s gonna be a banger of a Mac Studio announced in June. Apple really stumbled into making the perfect hardware for home inference machines. This I'm not actually as sure about. The current Studio offerings have done away with the 512GB memory option. I understand the RAM situation, but they didn't change pricing they just discontinued it. So I'm curious to see what the next Studio is like. I'd almost love to see a Studio with even one PCI slot, make it a bit taller, have a slide out cover...
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
As someone who came from the SGI O2/Octane era when high-end workstations were compact, distinctive, and sexy, I’ve never really understood the allure of the Mac Pro, with the exception of the 2013 Mac Pro tube, which I owned (small footprint, quiet, and powerful). For me, aesthetics and size are important. That workstation on your desk should justify its presence, not just exist as some hulking box. When Apple released the Mac Studio, it made perfect sense from a form-factor point-of-view. The internal expansion slots in the M2 Mac Pro didn't make any sense. It was like a bag of potato chips - mostly air. And far too big and ugly to be part of my work area! I'm surprised that Apple didn't discontinue it sooner.
Apple Mac Pro: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Neutral
Well, I know exactly what you're saying, but to be fair to Apple, my 68K Mac that's nearly 40 still works. My iMac G4 is fine. PowerMac G3 is fine. First gen Mac Pro is fine. Meanwhile, the only PCs I know of that survive time quite as well (and I collect old crap) were all nearly equivalent to Apple level pricing at the time of their introduction. While Apple does charge nearly criminal markup for RAM and storage, they at least make some products that last (except for the TouchBar MacBooks' keyboards). I just hope my Mac Studio lasts too.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
The Mac Studio hit a sweet spot in 2023 that the trash can Mac Pro couldn't ten years earlier. It's mostly thanks to the high integration of Apple Silicon and improved device availability and speed of Thunderbolt. The 2013 Mac Pro was stuck forever with its original choice of Intel CPU and AMD GPU. And it was unfortunately prone to overheating due to these same components.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
I genuinely forgot the Mac Pro still exists. It’s been so long since I even saw one. And I’ve had every previous Mac tower design since 1999: G4, G5, the excellent dual Xeon, the horrible black trash can… But Apple Silicon delivers so much punch in the Studio form factor, the old school Pro has become very niche. Edit - looks like the new M3 Ultra is only available in Mac Studio anyway? So the existence of the Pro is moot here.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
I've owned every Mac Pro with the exception of the 2019. I bought them because I wanted to be able to easily expand RAM and storage without having to use external enclosures. Apple doesn't seem able or willing to allow this anymore on their systems since everything is either part of the SoC, or hardwired to the system board. The new Mac Pro does allow you to add either NVME chips (at an incredible cost) or NVME cards in the PCI slots. So as soon as the new Mac Pro was announced at WWDC, I did a quick check on the diff between it and the Mac Studio and instantly bought the Studio. I've had it for 2 weeks and it's been fantastic. Although I loved the old flexibility, part of that's gone, and part of it is just not worth the price Apple wants. And Apple has just pushed this price way above the value. Now that the performance is the same, they've limited the market dramatically.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
The TrashCan is 10 years old. It had only Thunderbolt 2 and gigabit ethernet. We've also got USB-C in the meantime, including a lot of USB-C displays. So I think this is a case of "too early". The market looks very different today at how fast external communication is. I'd say that MacStudio is really todays TrashCan. Much better timing, so much better success.
Apple Mac Pro: NeutralApple Mac Studio: Likes it
I own an M1 Ultra Mac Studio that I primarily run Asahi Linux on. Prior to that, I ran a trashcan 2013 Mac Pro 6-core Xeon that I primarily ran Ubuntu Linux on. Thus, I buy Apple primarily for the hardware. After watching today's WWDC product announcements regarding the Mac Studio and Mac Pro updates, I really don't see myself ever buying a Mac Pro in the future. While I can understand how very large studios may value the additional expandability, a massive case with ability for expensive upgrades just isn't something I would need or pay extra money for. It looks like Apple has targeted the Mac Studio for the largest number of professionals, while reserving the Mac Pro for a niche high-end market - and in these regards, the Mac Pro is a continuation of the 2019 Mac Pro, whereas the Mac Studio is a continuation of the trashcan 2013 Mac Pro.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
> the one I played with felt slower than the Mac Studio The Mac Studio is faster than the 2019 Mac Pro. https://www.macrumors.com/guide/mac-studio-vs-mac-pro-buyers... When the Mac Pro came out it was the fastest Mac that existed, but those Intel Chips were already dated and were being roundly beaten by AMD chips of the era. The "killer feature" was the encoding acceleration card, but a faster variant is available inside Apple Silicon. I'm not sure where the cut-off is, but I think the M1 Max (Not ultra) is also faster than the Mac Pro 2019.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Recommends it
I'm not an experienced hackintosh builder, it was in fact the second pc I built myself based on advice on the forums, before that I usually had Mac Pro's until they got ridiculously expensive. I can't remember the specs of my last hackintosh but it was fast :) One of the reasons I switched back was that I no longer wanted to tinker with OpenCore & friends, and make a sacrifice to the gods after every OS update :) The other reasons were that I got tired of the heat, noise and energy consumption, and I started to get weird little issues that I could theoretically solve with reinstalling and/or tinkering with the config. I decided that wasn't for me after all. I love my Mac Studio (Max, 64GB, 2TB). It's actually silent , even when I push it hard. In terms of GPU I took a slight step back, but I only notice that with some games if I run them on extremely high resolution+settings. In terms of CPU I would say it has similar single-core performance but feels a lot faster because of the fast storage. and the reduced energy usage is immediately noticeable. Rendering video is comically fast, which is great. To be honest, it feels like the best Mac I've ever had, and I've had almost all of them in the past.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
The Mac Studio is the obvious Mac Pro replacement. It's hard to do a fixed system and also charge much more than $5k for it, and Apple has failed over and over at any kind of non-fixed Mac Pro. They might just leave it as is. The studio is a very capable machine at the high end, and if given a beefier GPU/CPU and _maybe_ more DRAM it probably replaces the bulk of the professional use cases.
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
No one outside of SF, Tokyo, & NYC cares about saving power or space for desktops which is why people panned the old garbage can pro. This is a slightly better direction, but I’m still waiting for a slightly more affordable bigger box Mac that isn’t an exorbitant Mac Pro. The old refrigerator models were reasonable. I don’t want an improved Mac garbage can model
Apple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
Did Apple just imply that buying a faster processor from them levels the playing field for underrepresented minorities? In the context of a $4000 Mac Studio with something like FinalCut Pro allows them similar creative power that the inaccessible, siloed $10,000 workstations. You're much more likely to see a Mac Studio in a school, library or computer lab where underrepresented people live. I had a gig a few years ago that took place in a public library with a lab of trashcan-style Intel Mac Pros, which were more expensive and far less capable than a Mac Studio.