The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Desktops and mini PCs

Apple Mac mini vs Microsoft Windows Dev Kit

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple Mac mini.

Apple Mac miniMicrosoft Windows Dev Kit
Owners with an opinion8235
Positive verdicts74% of 62640% of 5
Positive/negative since 2024267/941/0
Happy after 3+ years390
Longest happy owner15 yrs–
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and ease of use
Criticized forsoftwarereliability and support
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Mac mini: Likes itMicrosoft Windows Dev Kit: Doesn’t like it
The difference here is that the M1 in the M1 mac mini is faster than Apple's phone SoC (the A16). The Qualcomm 8cx gen 3 (what a terrible name) in this machine is NOT faster than even Qualcomm's phone SoC (the 8 gen 1), let alone Apple's phone SoC. It's absurd to be selling a desktop PC that's weaker than a phone.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itMicrosoft Windows Dev Kit: Doesn’t like it
Sure - if you need all 32GB for development work, it is a great deal. But, with a processor slower than a midrange modern Intel laptop, good luck using it to its full extent without feeling quite slow. So slow you might almost prefer a 16GB M1 Mac mini with swap for the rest despite the VM. Plus, if you read Microsoft documentation on Windows on ARM so far, Microsoft doesn't actually expect you to use an IDE on these machines - but rather run your code remotely on them. You'll be a lot happier with your IDE running on a more powerful machine. Of course, if you do that, the lack of a GPU on the M1 for a Windows on ARM VM becomes not really an issue.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itMicrosoft Windows Dev Kit: Likes it
There's a lot more use-cases though, of both systems. If you want a "good" small computer and you already have a screen (or want to buy cheap ones) then these systems are fantastic. Performance is completely fine for moderate-to-heavy workloads (assuming the heavy workloads are bursty) for the Mac mini, and hopefully this. Both systems are what you would get if you didn't need a display or keyboard already, they're desktop replacements with a small footprint, and fantastic for the majority of computer workloads including a lot of development ones.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itMicrosoft Windows Dev Kit: Likes it
This is Microsoft's second go at a developer-focused ARM kit. You may recall the first was called the Snapdragon Developer Kit [1] and was a miserable machine. It appears Microsoft has already pulled it from the Microsoft Store [2]. There is no other supported desktop/CI/etc. solution for Windows on ARM. (Mac mini with Parallels/VMware is a popular unsupported alternative. It may still be your fastest.) Seems like a truly decent machine (ordered one) but I'm not sure if there's remaining appetite for Windows target-specific development. After years and years of development platform missteps and PC usage pattern changes, I fear web (electron, etc.) has become good enough for Windows users. [1] https://developer.qualcomm.com/hardware/windows-on-snapdrago... [2] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/d/ecs-liva-mini-box-qc710-de...