The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Desktops and mini PCs

Apple Mac mini vs Intel NUC

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple Mac miniIntel NUC
Owners with an opinion823293
Positive verdicts74% of 62678% of 237
Positive/negative since 2024267/9474/25
Happy after 3+ years3914
Longest happy owner15 yrs15 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwarenoise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itIntel NUC: Neutral
I’m impressed with that. I had a Nuc 9 extreme with a 10gb SFP card in it. It averaged 69w. The Mac Mini I replaced it with uses just under 5w. A Mini is possible the worst bang for buck. Also, the horror that that is Desktop Docker can’t be over emphasised. I know there are better ways of using Docker on a Mac, but having got something working I can’t face rebuilding it.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itIntel NUC: Doesn’t like it
I’m running the mini on 7w (averaged over a month). It’s networked at 10gb, which is hard to do on mini pc/nuc without using a lot more power. My other Nucs use 70ish (nuc 9 extreme) or 35 (nuc 10 with thunderbolt dongle). The mini is also much more powerful. The is was a bit of a nightmare to tame but I’ve got it sorted now.
Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itIntel NUC: Likes it
The new Intel NUCs are only like a hundred something dollars for an N150 CPU and come with 16 gigs of RAM and a SSD. Why pay so much more to fight an uphill battle? Unless you desperately need the hot garbage that is Xcode there isn't much reason to deal with Mac Minis running MacOS as a server. One update and it will suspend and be unwakeable without physical interaction.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itIntel NUC: Neutral
So much this. I’ve migrated a home server to a Mac mini. It was awful to achieve. Trying to get a machine to boot, connect network shares and start containers was a week long effort. I can do it in Ubuntu in about 10 minutes from a clean install. So much is disgusting UI options hidden deep some in the (awful) settings app. But the result is a server that is fast, powerful and using 6-7W per hour, compared to the old Nuc 9 it replaced that used 70W. It’s just so good. The OS lets it down.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itIntel NUC: Doesn’t like it
I just replaced a nuc 9 ghost canyon with a Mac mini. The difference in power consumption is insane. Nuc was 67 watts. The mini is 4-10. I don’t have enough data for a long term average on the mini yet, but it’s ludicrously efficient.
Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itIntel NUC: Neutral
Nah the biggest problem (for intel macmini) is there is no easy t2 applesmc support in the Linux kernel so you have zero fan control without patching and building a new kernal and I never figured out how to do it I have my old Mac mini and a 10th gen nuc in a proxmox cluster and they are basically the same. except I had to upgrade the nuc to give it nvme and 10g where as the macmini already had that. And then because I lack fan control on the mini slap a giant heat sink on top and point some fans at it
Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itIntel NUC: Neutral
What do you mean "what computer"? You think I have only one?? :) Desktops: Daily driver: Skylake NUC with 16GB RAM, FreeBSD with KDE Gaming: Ryzen 5 5600X, RTX 3080 Ti, 64GB, Windows 10 Work: Mac Mini M1 with 8GB (meh, 8GB is not enough but my work only buys off-the-shelf SKUs and these are not upgradable :( ) - The above 3 are all connected to the same 4k 24" screen (200% scaling) :) Laptops: Work 2: Thinkpad T490s 16GB RAM, Windows 11 On the go: Ultra-cheap "Chuwi" Atom laptop with an old Ubuntu version (been meaning to change it as I hate Ubuntu). I rately do laptopey stuff anyway. That's about it in terms of workstations :P Servers is another story (mostly a Linux and ESXi one)
Apple Mac mini: Likes itIntel NUC: Doesn’t like it
> I mean a beautiful screen, reasonable dimensions & weight, a really good touchpad, great battery life, etc. The competition on the other side is on specs. It's hard to stick hardware with bigger numbers in a thin case. Look at Intel's NUCs vs the Mac Mini... they come with a power brick larger than the computer to win in specs, while Apple has an elegant built in PSU. And... a working touchpad that can actually replace a mouse for 95% of use cases? How are you going to market that? You want the largest numbers, you have to go with the others. If you can stomach windows. You want a less annoying experience, Apple unfortunately has about zero competition there. Which is bad even for Apple users because then you get masterpieces like the butterfly keyboard...
Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itIntel NUC: Likes it
I think this is a topic about which people can reasonably disagree :-) I'll just add that my complaint about inability to upgrade does not just apply to laptops. It's the whole product line (other than the Pro) including the Mini and the iMac. If I have an iMac and I need more RAM, I have to throw out a perfectly good SSD, processor, and display . There is just no excuse for that. I have a NUC that is essentially a hardware equivalent of a (pre-M1) Mini. The NUC is both smaller than a Mini and upgradable so I know it's possible.
Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itIntel NUC: Likes it
I find it really good. It's super stable, I have it running 24/7 for a month at a time and FreeBSD has some really nice things that Linux is only now catching up on. Like ZFS on root (snapshotting your desktop is so cool). It's never crashed on me. Unlike my Mac. Hardware issues are present yes. Your hardware may vary of course. In my case I had to turn off bluetooth on my NUC (NUC5i5RYK). Because it hangs on boot with some cryptic messages. I probably could have troubleshooted it more but because all my peripherals are wired I didn't really care :) Also, I don't think sleep works (I don't care, I want it to be ready for me all the time) and I didn't even try WiFi (I have wired ethernet) In fact the sleep thing is one thing I hated about my Mac Mini. Apple always forces some kind of sleep.. Every morning when I logged in my apps would have this state of "oh wait, just catching up" despite me having switched off all the sleep states with "pmset" and in the GUI, and using an app ("Jiggler") to fake mouse inputs every few minutes. Yet the apps still go to some kind of sleep somehow. Which meant it would take a couple of minutes to be responsive again. I looked it up and this is some "app nap" thing or something. Cool but let me turn it off. My desktop takes 5-10W idle so this is really not something I care about. And during the night I schedule stuff like backups. Another thing where FreeBSD shines are the jails. I've used them for 15 years and you can even jail GUI apps now. Li
Apple Mac mini: Recommends itIntel NUC: Doesn’t like it
NUCs aren’t fanless, the newer versions tend to be 25W and have very loud and whiny fans, and in fanless cases they tend to throttle, sadly. I replaced one with an M1 mac mini and the mac mini is faster and near silent - I have literally never heard the fan over the room’s background noise, and I’ve thrashed the thing.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itIntel NUC: Neutral
I have a NUC6i5SYK (Skylake) running Ubuntu 16.04 server, and I too had some serious problems initially. Installing to the SSD worked without issues, but then I got machine check panics during most boots. After a lot of troubleshooting I was finally able to make the system stable by adding these parameters to the kernel command line: intel_idle.max_cstate=1 i915.enable_rc6=0 After that it has been running without a glitch. I hope it will be as stable as the Mac Mini it replaced. That too had some initial problems however: the first one I bought in 2008 was DOA. Apple replaced it, and the replacement lasted four months before a thunderstorm zapped it. My insurance company replaced that one, and that Mac Mini then ran like a clockwork 24/7 for eight years.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itIntel NUC: Neutral
I had the same experience as the OP. My Mac Mini was getting old, and the fan was making a worrisome noise. I wasn't going to buy the "latest" Mini, since it is very stale, hard to upgrade and expensive for what it is. Funnily enough I was already running Windows on that Mini anyway, so my next computer didn't have to be a Mac. But I did enjoy the small footprint, and I have to say that the Mac is probably the easiest hardware to run Windows on. The drivers have been tested and everything just works. I ended up with the latest "Skull Canyon" NUC as well. Even though it is thinner than my old Mini, its footprint on my desk is about the same, it's just less square. I'm not a fan of the color or the design; it seems marketed at teenage gamerzzz, not at the boring middle aged guy who prefers a minimalist Scandinavian style. But that's not very important. I did have to buy the SSD and the RAM separately, I had to install Windows myself (so that's no better than buying a Mini to run Windows on), and I did have to hunt for a couple of drivers. I don't know why they don't sell a fully configured machine. Its fan is not as quiet as the Mini, and it has some weird transient behavior when it wakes up from hibernation. It didn't come cheap (I maxed pretty much every spec though). It is very fast, it does the job competently, but I don't Love it like I Loved the Mini. Sad that Apple has abandoned this cute nifty little machine.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itIntel NUC: Likes it
That all makes sense and lines up with my experience. Schools have a hard time keeping IT staff, as soon as you manage a school district for a year or two you can double or triple your salary elsewhere. So the near adminless part of chomebooks is quite valuable, doubly so when every IT lead seems to want to go in a different direction. I do question the utility of laptops vs desktops. Assuming students aren't on the laptop during every class. If you assume say 1-2 hour a day of laptop time and access to a web browser at home you could save much of the waste of throwing away a laptop every 4 years. LCD panels can easily last 10 years, and batteries are often the first thing to die on laptops. I've built diskless linux desktops for educational settings, with a bit of tweaking was pretty much seamless for users. Literally had a browser, matlab, mathematic, maple, and print icons on the desktop and didn't do any training for incoming students. We'd buy 100 at a time or so and they would last 6-8 years, and each one met the needs of 4-10 students. Cost (and environmental impact) is quite a bit less for a mac mini/Intel NUC and similar SFFS than a laptop.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itIntel NUC: Likes it
I don’t buy Apple products for philosophical reasons, but the Mac Mini, and now Mac Studio, are everything I wish Intel NUCs were. I have an Intel Skull Canyon system from 2016 as my gaming PC and it fits in my wife’s purse. Since then, the gaming NUC variants have gotten larger and larger so that they’re nearly mini-ATX form factor again.