The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Desktops and mini PCs

Apple Mac mini vs Apple Mac Studio

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple Mac miniApple Mac Studio
Owners with an opinion823221
Positive verdicts74% of 62670% of 174
Positive/negative since 2024267/9488/43
Happy after 3+ years392
Longest happy owner15 yrs4 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwarevalue
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Doesn’t like it
>They just want to see “Running Model X with quantization Y I get Z tokens per second”. Influencers on Youtube will give them that [1] but its meaningless. If a benchmark is not part of an in-depth comparison than it doesn't mean anything and can't inform you on what hardware will run this software best. These shallow benchmarks influencers post on youtube and twitter are not just meaningless but also take days to browse through. And they are influencers, they are meant to influence you and are therefore not honest or reliable. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GBR6pHZ68Ho >but I don’t understand how you’re concluding that a Mac is the “second best option” to your $30K machine I conclude that if you can't afford to develop custom chips than in certain cases a cluster of M4 Mac Mini's will be the fastest cheapest option. Cerebras Wafers or NVDIA GPUs have always been too expensive compared to custom chips or Mac Mini clusters, independent of the specific software workload. I also meant to say that a cluster of $599 Mac Minis will outperform a $6500 M2 Ultra Mac Studio with 192GB and be half the price for higher performance and DRAM but only if you utilize the M4 Mac Mini aggregated 100 Gbps networking.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Doesn’t like it
In 1986 we wrote a parallel Mandelbrot program in assembly instructions in the 2K or 4K on-chip SRAM of 17 x T414 Transputer chips linked together with 4 x 10 Mbps links each into a cheap supercomputer [1]. It drew the 512 x 342 pictures on a Mac 128K as terminal at around 10 seconds per picture. I later wrote the quadruple-precision floating-point calculations in microcode [2] to speed it up by a factor of 10 and combined 52 x T414 with 20 x T800 Transputers with floating point hardware into a larger supercomputer costing around $50K. With this cheap 72 core supercomputer it still would have taken years to produce the deep zoom of the Mandelbrot set [4] that took them 6 months with 12 CPU cores running 24/7 in 2010 [3]. In 2024 we can buy a $499 M4 Mac mini (20-36 'cores') and calculate it a a few days. If I link a few M4s together with 3x32 Gbps Thunderbolt links into a cheap supercomputer and write the assembly code for all the 36 cores (CPU+GPU+Neural Engine) I can render the deep zoom Mandelbrot almost in realtime (30 frames per second). That is Moore's law in practice. The T414 had 900,000 transistors, the M4 has 28 billion transistors at 3nm (31.111 times larger at 50% of the price). The M2 Ultra with 134 billion transistors and M4 Max (estimate 100 billion transistors) are larger chips than a M4 but they are relatively more expensive then the M4 so it is cheaper and faster to link together 13 x M4 than buy 1 x M2 Ultra or 6 x M4 instead of 1 x M4 Max. Cerebras or NVid…
Apple Mac mini: NeutralApple Mac Studio: Likes it
You can, but honestly, if you can afford 24GB, go for it. Remember that unlike in the Intel days, the GPU uses main memory for its RAM. (Well, I guess integrated Intel GPUs did some of that, too.) That can be painful when you've got a few clips in the timeline and some plug-in wants to have multiple copies of each frame for doing its processing. (Like it applies a blur, then mixes that with the original, or whatever.) I have a 16GB MacMini I sometimes edit video on, and it works, but there are times when things get choppy/slow. I also have a Studio with 64GB, and it's smooth as butter. (I mean it's possible to load it up so it slows down, but it takes a lot more to do so.)
Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
Once you start adding memory and ssd, it makes more sense to just get a mac studio. You basically get less for more with the mac mini. Once you max out the memory and CPU, the entry level mac studio is cheaper and comes with the M1 Max instead of the M2 Pro. A bit of a toss up which is faster but for 230 euro extra you jump to 32 GPU cores, which is not an option with the mini.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Doesn’t like it
Without having a teardown available, and more importantly, without having actually manually manipulated it, I am ready to say the Studio is poor design. I could be completely wrong, but it appears from the images of the back that the design is simply this: a Mac Mini on the bottom with storage, I/O & PSU, below a processor layer with a massive heatsink, which is likely the only thing taking up any space behind the top grill. The problem with the design is that the M1 Ultra version weighs 8lbs., and most that weight is going to be in the bottom, making Studio unwieldy, and I expect placement of this little bottom-heavy box that weighs nearly as much as a gallon of water is going to be the source of a number of wrist injuries, and I think it is safe to say also, there will naturally be some blunt force injuries to a number of hands and fingers, some with ugly lacerations. Most of this could have been avoided with some new cutting edge technology colloquially known as putting a doggone handle on the top that was solidly loaded into the more massive layer on the bottom. I think the design ethic here is similar to strapping a 350 to a gocart. Putting a handle on something that weighs 8lbs. is so ordinary and necessary and obvious, and because Studio lacks it, I honestly do not care what's inside it. Even if manipulation is only going to occur once or a small handful of times, physically it is going to function like junk, and that just bugs me too much. I have too much junk as…
Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
Perfect. Recently went to a 40" ultrawide display to share between work laptop (during work hours) and personal desktop (after hours) to simplify my desk, and felt the Mini was probably just a little too limiting/low-end. Finally, the replacement to my 2015 iMac 5k.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Doesn’t like it
Boy is that an ugly box… the proportions seem all wrong to me - looks like they just stacked a bunch on Mac Mini’s (which has pretty nice proportions)
Switched from the Apple Mac mini to the Apple Mac StudioApple Mac Studio: Likes it
You’re bang on with this comment. The Mac studio is surprisingly quiet and well cooled. I haven’t had to install a fan control utility as of yet. I thought I’d be trying one of these out and sell it if my setup didn’t work, but it’s the first desktop I’m starting to consider especially if I want to leave a workload running on it instead of a decade of carrying a lot of horsepower around with me. Instant on for 3 monitors, no need for docking station or USB hubs, everything is plugged in and works, I can run a virtual cam obs setup easily. The studio is a great upgrade on Mac mini, which might cannibalize the Mac pro sales and why it might not get toasted or refreshed. I’ll F the max studio was a way to put a dent in hackkntoshes, it makes sense. The M2 mini looks super decent but quickly goes up in price when ram and ssd is setup to match a studio. For my purposes the ultra wasn’t that much faster than the M1 max on because the software has to be optimized to benefit from it. Maybe some of this ML stuff will be shortly.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
The Mac Mini’s and Mac Studio’s are very popular fast, quick, and easy to move around. With very good resale value private party or back to Apple.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
I’ve felt the same way since way back then ever since reading about this guy’s setup[0], so I paired a 11” MBA with the quad core Mac Mini 2012. I’ve kept that philosophy over the years, the MBA was replaced by the 2017 12” retina MacBook and then again with the 13” M2 MBA. The Mini gave way to the 2018 Mini, then a M1 Max Studio. I even attempted replacing the MacBook with an iPad though that didn’t really workout. It’s the best of both worlds really, enough power to do everything when on the go and even more power back at the office. 0: https://elliotjaystocks.com/blog/a-note-about-my-new-mac-set...
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
It's the utility value I can't see. It makes sense for as much as you can put "into a laptop" and is the same zone as AMD Strix/Gorgon Halo. I'd much rather have the high compute in my server in the basement that I have remote use of rather than burning my battery with limited thermals. And the Apple Max/Ultra does it better. The Mac Mini/Studio form factor makes way more sense. These laptops look like conspicuous consumption brand marketing devices. CUDA is worthless--AIs can port kernels.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
I happily booted and ran an Intel Mac mini using a 4TB drive in a Thunderbolt 3 enclosure, and I do the same for an M4 Max Mac Studio using an 8TB drive in a USB4v2 enclosure (OWC Express 1M2 80G). You'll just have to be careful to match the enclosure to the ports on the system. The base-model M6 Mac mini still uses Thunderbolt 4, so a USB4v2 enclosure would be wasted.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
I use both the base M4 Mac mini and an M4 MacBook Air for Final Cut Pro, Photoshop, and Fusion, and while they're not as almost-always-perfectly-smooth as my Mac Studio, they're about 100x better than the experience I used to have on my old Intel MacBook Pros in the 2010s. I edit 4K ProRes and H.265 footage, sometimes with multicam (up to 4 streams) and color adjustments, titles, etc. It's only after stacking 3-5 effects before things can stutter, really. Or if you try doing something CPU-intense in the background _while_ running some heavy creative software. I just don't do that.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
The solution to your noise and electricity costs are the ARM-based Macs. Not only are they whisper-quiet, they also sip the electricity. I just had an unplanned power outage two days ago, and my Dell Precision 7920 (44c/88t, 256Gb RAM) had about 20 minutes of UPS power vs the 148 minutes of my much more powerful Mac Studio M4 Max (16c, 128Gb RAM). Both were idling at the time. Even the first-gen ARM Mac Mini’s are something like ⅓ the power draw of the 2018 versions (the last of the Intel CPUs), and under load it can be as little as ¼ the power draw.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
Mac mini has first-class access to iCloud, photos, iMessage etc. So if you are deep in the Apple ecosystem you might prefer it for that reason. I have a windows gaming desktop that I could use as a server for openclaw/cowork but I realized I simply don’t trust that system enough to give it access to all the personal stuff I’m giving to the AI. I trust Anthropic and Apple. I don’t trust whatever junk is running on my gaming desktop. If you want to run local models, another advantage is Apple’s unified memory architecture. The biggest Mac mini has 64gb ram and Mac Studio has up to 512gb. Compare this little box to what monster Nvidia gpu system you would have to buy to get the same memory there. That doesn’t account for the shortage of basic $600 Mac minis though.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Studio: Likes it
Not surprising, as the market has broadly moved on from add-in cards in favor of smaller form factors and external devices, absent some notable holdouts in specific verticals. Gonna miss it, though. If they had reduced the add-in card slots to something more reasonable, lowered the entry price, and given us multi-socket options for the CPU (2x M# Ultras? 4x ?), it could have been an interesting HPC or server box - though they’ve long since moved away from that in software land, so that was always but a fantasy. At least the Mac Studio and Minis are cute little boxes.