The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Desktops and mini PCs

Apple Mac mini vs Apple Mac Pro

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple Mac mini.

Apple Mac miniApple Mac Pro
Owners with an opinion823162
Positive verdicts74% of 62667% of 124
Positive/negative since 2024267/9442/18
Happy after 3+ years3918
Longest happy owner15 yrs17 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwarevalue
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
I rode a 2009 MacPro5,1 (¡galliently! into the future, with capable GPU upgrades) until Jan23's M2Pro mini debut (which I still use as my main Mac). Apple Silicon is certainly incredible (I also have a base-model M4mini, but it severely lacks RAM/ports so I don't really use it much/eWaste); my only Silicon-purchase-regret was buying a beautiful new 2024 MacBookAir (15") – heavily discounted $850@CostCo – but with only 8GB of RAM (it is functionally worthless, other than for watching it destroy your SSD with page-outs as you casually stream YouTubies...). In 2024, only 8GB of RAM (soldered onto the board because fuck you )!
Apple Mac mini: NeutralApple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like it
I had the following problems. Note my hardware was ageing at the time and was about 5 years old. I know a quality apple specialist that did the work. - Glue'd in batteries on Laptops. I had a Mac Pro with a glue'd in battery. I could have done it myself, however I ended up opting to get someone who knows what they are doing to replace it. Labour and battery replacement cost me about £250. - Official charger made the power lines toast. Another £250 to get it repaired. - iOS Safari browser sometimes stops videos / audio when the screen locks or you switch apps. It is really annoying. Doesn't happen on Graphene OS or Android. - iCloud is kinda required if you use an iPhone even though I don't use it for backups. - Upgrades just aren't possible. Every single on of my laptops I have, I have upgraded ram, disk and even processor on some of the older models I have. I changed an intel Mac Mini drive to an SSD, it was a fiddly to say the least. On other SFF machines it is often a 5 minute job. - MacOS is kinda just weird. While it is a Unix, it does everything it can to hide it. As someone that used both Linux/BSD. MacOS feels like running a weird Linux distro. Brew was kinda weird after coming from Linux world. I would have just preferred to run Linux. - The online account stuff with Apple is somehow worse than Microsoft. These days I buy refurb Business Laptop from Dell or Lenovo. Literally 10% of the price, Linux almost always works and if breaks, I can buy another one cheap for th…
Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
Amateur video and full-stack software dev were the times I really appreciated having 3 monitors, running tons of things at once that all interact with each other. My Mac Pro drove 3 or 4 easily, so it was disappointing when my new M1 mini needed DisplayLink hacks to run more than 2. Nowadays with my big corp SWE job, things outside my control make my workflow a lot slower and I don't benefit from using more than just 1 screen. I work on multiple things at once, but they're totally separate, so I tab between them on my laptop.
Apple Mac mini: NeutralApple Mac Pro: Likes it
There's something fun yet practical about holding onto a solid old computer (or car) that's been upgraded well beyond the original specs. Until this year, my main work machine was a 2009 Mac Pro with dual Xeon x5670s (12 cores total), 24GB RAM, RX580, flashed to 5,1 firmware and OpenCore'd to run the latest macOS. Yes there are beefier versions, but this was good enough. Got an M1 Mac mini and miss a few things. The Mac Pro connectivity is still important. USB-C accessories are never as reliable. Also hate having to use DisplayLink for >2 monitors.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like it
What a weird take. A lot of the changes the "accountants" have made recently are responsive to user request to my eye. So so many more ports on the new products. I absolutely love this. I hated the pure design direction things were going under Ive. Battery life once again going big. I love this. Usability again the key. The trashcan Mac Pro? Too much design. Give folks a square box if you need to crank power up. Self service repair program? Only one out there from what I can tell? I like it. Iphone mini - yes I was one of the few folks who bought this. Sorry to see this go away, I like the small phones. But giving a range of options was great. And this list goes on. My wife keeps her stuff (iphone / macbook) around FOREVER - software updates on phones going back 5+ years? Fantastic. Their run rate is now something like $400B++ per year? With nuts gross margins (maybe getting close to $200B in gross margin?!!) They've done this with almost no acquisitions (relatively speaking). And throwing off $150B in operating cash flow (6 months). I think stock buybacks are lame but what can they spend this on really? A moon launch and base? This is the reward for being trusted (in my view) far FAR more than many other players in the market despite the complaints you see on HN. I know they are considered a "ripoff" but if someone has a monitor / keyboard, dropping $700 for a mac mini, you can basically do all the programming / video editing / photo editing you could want.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like it
It's one of the only sane form factors available if you need off-site compute power running on MacOS. The rack mount Mac Pro helped to fill that niche somewhat, but they're just insanely expensive. Amazon has dedicated Mac hardware in AWS as well and the pricing is also crazy expensive. For large app devs though, the cost is worth it to build their apps in the cloud without bogging down their local machines constantly. If you have rebuild targets for a half dozen OS versions, it can add up! Datacenters are the solution and the Mac Mini just so happened to be the form factor that was available and could be made to work with less hassle than accommodating laptops.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
Not surprising, as the market has broadly moved on from add-in cards in favor of smaller form factors and external devices, absent some notable holdouts in specific verticals. Gonna miss it, though. If they had reduced the add-in card slots to something more reasonable, lowered the entry price, and given us multi-socket options for the CPU (2x M# Ultras? 4x ?), it could have been an interesting HPC or server box - though they’ve long since moved away from that in software land, so that was always but a fantasy. At least the Mac Studio and Minis are cute little boxes.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
Every iMac, Mac Pro, MacBook Air, Mac Mini and MacBook Pro I’ve had (for me and family) has been indestructible. A few months ago Spotify on an ancient Intel Mac mini in the living room started complaining that the new version of Spotify is no longer compatible with that Mac. Then I ran Open Core and updated the MacOS to a much newer version, and Spotify is happy. Now I’ll get even more years out of that machine.
Apple Mac mini: Likes itApple Mac Pro: Likes it
I have a slightly older Power Mac G4, a 350MHz "Yikes!" PCI Power Mac G4 from 1999 ( https://lowendmac.com/1999/power-mac-g4-yikes/ ) that I purchased in 2009 for $40 while I was a senior at Cal Poly. The reason I got it for only $40 was because it had a broken hard drive, but the sellers didn't know that. I was able to replace the hard drive with one that was given away by Cal Poly's computer science department, which sometimes gave away old computer parts. I also replaced the non-working optical drive with a new DVD+RW drive, and I upgraded the RAM; IIRC, it has 640MB RAM. Even though the computer was already obsolete in 2009 (I used a 2006 Core Duo MacBook as my daily driver, which ran circles around the old Power Mac G4), it was a capable machine that could run Mac OS X Leopard and could handle the Web of that era, even YouTube videos. Eventually, sometime around 2013 the Web became too much for my Power Mac G4, but it remains a very nice machine for Mac OS 9 and early Mac OS X retrocomputing. I now have faster PowerPC Macs in my collection (a 1GHz PowerBook G4 and a 1.25GHz Mac Mini G4), but my Power Mac G4 is the fastest machine in my collection that could run the classic Mac OS without any modifications, and it is also the fastest Mac in my collection that has expansion slots. I'm keeping an eye on 2019 Mac Pro prices (I own a 2013 Mac Pro, which I purchased refurbished in 2017 and used as my daily driver until 2022, when I switched to a Ryzen 3900 build). I love…
Apple Mac mini: Doesn’t like itApple Mac Pro: Doesn’t like it
I don't know. On one hand, lag is real. I rebooted my M1 Mac mini yesterday running Ventura, and while it only took a few seconds to boot to the desktop, it took, like, two minutes for it to stop beach-balling and finish initializing. (It was most likely waiting on network I/O to finish, but still.) On the other hand, machines are faster than ever before while doing more than ever before, and apps are more flexible and change more quickly (largely in part to super approachable cross-platform frameworks like Electron). A few milliseconds of UI latency will bother almost no-one. On the other _other_ hand, Julio's demo of using Windows 2000 on an time-appropriate machine is best case. I definitely remember waiting what felt like eons for lots of useful apps to load, like Office and Internet Explorer. (Remember when browsers had startup screens?) He's definitely right about how far hardware has come since 1999. The shift to Apple Silicon was even more transformational than the transition to SSD, IMO. Julio's right in that the shift to SSD was night-and-day, but going from an Intel Mac to an Apple Silicon Mac sped up literally everything you used to an insane degree AND you got 12+ hour battery life to boot. This used to be an either-or kind of trade-off, and for Windows devices, it still is. To wit: I used an Intel Mac Pro (the trash can) last week for some audio work, and that super expensive almost-server-class machine was _slower_ than my base model M1 Mac mini at home, while…