The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple iPhoneSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra
Owners with an opinion462915
Positive verdicts58% of 384269% of 13
Positive/negative since 20241115/9352/1
Happy after 3+ years2801
Longest happy owner23 yrs3.5 yrs
Praised forreliability and performanceperformance and display
Criticized forease of use and softwarebattery and ergonomics
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Doesn’t like it
My experience, sadly, has been the opposite. I had an iPhone 13 Pro Max with 120hz, and switched to a S22 Ultra, and although I can see the animations at 120hz, most of the time they feel stuttery. I always was an Android user until that iPhone, I had it for about a year, and switched back to Android again because I thought I was missing some stuff, but I was wrong, I don't miss a thing of current Android, I think current iOS is simply smoother and more fun to use, and stutter free 95% of the time.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Likes it
Can't agree on this. Also on Samsung, S22 ultra, I can't be bothered with any deep app settings because why would I do that? Device runs flawlessly, doesn't bother me with anything, has great battery life (and photos). On the other hand, my wife bought iphone 13 mini after being whole life on android and its a proper shitfest form her point of view - basic settings simply NOT possible by OS because Apple decided they know better than users what users want and users have no say in this apart form losing warranty via jailbreak, basic convenient features missing. The whole device can be summarized as 'basic for very premium price' - it looks very cheap, works cheap, not a single fancy or cool thing on it. Was about to give a chance to Apple myself but quickly rolled back after what I've seen. Plus all the scandals that show Apple is just another amoral non-privacy corporation just like the rest of bunch, despite their hard efforts at marketing. My wife will be probably rolling back to Android soon since its pretty bad experience overall. So completely opposite experience.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Likes it
One problem that Apple actually considers a hard won feature is color inaccuracy. They like to do default images look very instagram-ish, which may be what many folks like to see but they are pretty far from reality, more than most. Skin smoothing is another topic on its own. Maybe I am very biased by almost a decade of full frame shooting basically everything, but I like photo representing what I actually see with my own eyes at that moment. When talking about Pixels, when I saw some non-ideal light samples from latest one, it was pretty clear neither Apple nor ie Samsung (which I own and love, S22 ultra) are in same league in many aspects of photography. But Pixel 6 had some pretty annoying issues from user reports. On the other side it costed (and v7 still does) significantly less from day 1.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Likes it
I went from an iPhone 12 mini to S22 Ultra. The battery difference is obviously huge but from my experience iPhones seems to deteriate very fast. They are fine the first year but after that it never even completes a complete day without a charge. I haven't had the same issues with android brands like Samsung even if of course the battery gets worse over time, it is nothing like iPhone.
Apple iPhone: NeutralSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Likes it
> It was also very frustrating when trying to share photos to put together a slideshow for a funeral. And on that subject, it's her primary camera now and the quality leaves a lot to be desired on that front. This is actually one of the main reasons why my other family members prefer to stay on Android. While the average Android handset may not have a camera better than an iPhone, the best phone cameras are generally on Android handsets. This is partly just because Android runs on handsets from many different manufacturers and everyone competes on camera / picture quality for their flagship phones, and there is iterative improvements in technology over time. While the recent DXOMark report disagrees, in our testing ourselves, the S22 Ultra outperforms the iPhone 14 Pro, although both capture very good photos.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Doesn’t like it
> I can browse on my samsung S22 ultra random internet without being swarmed with ads and tracking (firefox and ublock origin, something Apple phones will clearly never have). If you are ok with using Safari instead of Firefox, that’s something that has been possible since 2015 on iOS [1]. > instead of ridiculously shitty faceid which doesn't work with masks It does since iOS 15.4 (March 2022 [2]); I use it every day. > It often doesn't work even without masks, ie non-ideal light conditions like right now (evening and dimmer lights) Light has nothing to do with this because FaceID works with infrared: I’m able to unlock my iPhone in the dark with no issue at all. You’re probably holding it wrong [3]. > But quality is just not there, the devices are worse, bigger in size with smaller screen, […] heavier I fail to find an iPhone 13 that’s bigger than your Samsung S22 Ultra. The Pro Max is 0.2mm wider but 2.1mm less tall and 1.2mm thiner (163.3 x 77.9 x 8.9 mm [4] vs. 160.8 x 78.1 x 7.7 mm [5]). It does have a smaller screen-to-size ratio (87.4% vs. 90.2%) and is slightly heavier (240g vs. 228g -- not sure how noticeable this is). > the devices are worse, […], uglier, […], software is meh That part is highly subjective. I personally find the S22 Ultra very ugly but that’s an opinion, not a fact. [1]: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-34173732 [2]: https://www.businessinsider.com/guides/tech/face-id-with-mas... [3]: https://www.macrumors.com/2017/09/13/how-iphone-x-face-id…
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Likes it
I recommended recently to my wife to buy Apple mini 13 as her next phone, after both of us being forever on Android. What a disappointment, she likes actually 1 feature - photos, and the rest is subpar experience compared to her old galaxy S10 (almost 4 year old phone). But then she likes my android photos similarly, since I have 10x zoom which is great for kids always running around or for hiking. Its not even first weeks of her use of Apple, she has it few months. I can browse on my samsung S22 ultra random internet without being swarmed with ads and tracking (firefox and ublock origin, something Apple phones will clearly never have). And all the rest. It has fingerprint sensor for unlocking, instead of ridiculously shitty faceid which doesn't work with masks (she is a doctor so does wear them often). It often doesn't work even without masks, ie non-ideal light conditions like right now (evening and dimmer lights). Comparable S22 is much nicer phone to look at, to hold, to carry, to charge, and to work with. I regret recommending it to her at this point, I too was convinced by Apple's effective PR. But quality is just not there, the devices are worse, bigger in size with smaller screen, uglier, heavier, software is meh, raw CPU power is useless on its own when device is so limited. I don't believe a zilch of Apple's PR about privacy, as I didn't for the ads and various other PR talk, actions are the only thing that matter. And after reading this topic, its clear I will co…
Apple iPhone: Recommends itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Likes it
I can say, after 6+ months with samsung s22 ultra i am very happy with it. Camera delivers more than any apple device can right now (since 10x zoom is surprisingly useful for me in normal light), battery is fine, screen is amazing and I think still best on the market today. People bash androids for privacy like all are from china, but Korea (and Japan and US) makes some fine devices too and as european I prefer them to US (and obviously China). I even have european exynos crap version, which is slower but some claim exynos models on previous models were much more stable/reliable after few months compared to snapdragons. Can't say, what I want works, there is absolute 0 broken/annoying things for me, no bloatware, no ads etc. That being said, when wife was looking for smaller phone few weeks back, I went through reviews and opinions and suggested iphone 13 mini. She always loved iphone photos of other folks and I think she will enjoy phone UI smoothness and long term reliability/security. It will be an interesting experiment.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Likes it
Its a horrible thing to have to manage USB for everything and yet another cable just for apple devices. I have met actually 0 people who appreciate this on Apple, everybody hates it with passion and during usual office day there is always somebody hunting for iphone cable to charge his phone. For me, this was the reason which swayed me for Samsung galaxy S22 Ultra instead of iphone 13 pro max. Plus that fugly-as-hell notch, I mean phones look like cheap chinese phones from 2015 with it. Literally everybody on the market has figured a better way to do this.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Doesn’t like it
It's worth noting that even a cheap, used 3-year-old iPhone 11 [0] is faster in benchmarks than a new flagship Samsung S22 Ultra [1], and the disparity is much larger when comparing flagships of the same generation head-to-head. This is no excuse for slow software, but it does go some way towards explaining the speed of the iOS app. [0]: https://browser.geekbench.com/ios_devices/iphone-11 [1]: https://browser.geekbench.com/android_devices/samsung-sm-s90...
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Likes it
> their incentive is to lock users All good apart from this. Apple does this magnificently, ie closed hardware protocols. For example there are significantly better earphones than airpads pro (and some cost +-same), but good luck getting same level of integration over apple's proprietary protocols. While rest of whole universe at least tries to adhere to open things so we users have freedom in how we design & evolve our electronic setup, they have basic support for stuff like bluetooth and superb for their proprietary protocol. If some random chinese company can make seamless aptx hd integration with their buds, so can apple. But it won't. Thunderbolt vs USB. Again whole world vs Apple. It required... who else than our sluggish EU to come up with way to end this cable madness that would otherwise continue forever. Seen enough 40 euro frayed cables for one lifetime. For me this was a one of few breaking points between Iphone 13 pro max and Samsung S22 ultra. I am currently very happy user of the latter. That's hardware lock-in like hell.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S22 Ultra: Likes it
I did, and went with S22 ultra at the end. Long term nikon full frame shooter. I must say both iphone 13 pro max and this are very formidable devices, each has their strengths and weaknesses, took quite a bit of time to decide. I like how S22 feels like a real computer where I can plug my variometer for paragliding via OTG cable, side load apps of my own choice, use normal charging cables like rest of the universe, upload/download files straight from filesystyem without any installed apps and so on. I am getting into whole S pen experience, its pretty nice for sketching or precise mouse-like work ie when editing photos in phone. Apple notch making it look like some basic 2015 chinese phone is just a cherry on the top. As for cameras, 10x physical zoom is not something to neglect, Apple doesn't have anything to offer there. In past 2 weeks I have it, I've shot quite a lot of otherwise impossible kids, family, nature, animals etc. pics with this zoom. That was my main motivation for new phone - a camera for pictures I always have with me, unlike dedicated camera (2.5kg being just a detail, I didn't mind carrying it but I didn't have it a lot of casual times where great situation happened). Another reason that swayed me - with this upgrade I wanted to improve headphones, priority being quality of sounds and battery life to play my collection of flacs. Airpods Pro were just not cutting it, went with Sennheiser momentum 2. You can't connect iphone and Senns via some above-defaul…