The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Samsung Galaxy Note

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple iPhoneSamsung Galaxy Note
Owners with an opinion462988
Positive verdicts58% of 384272% of 75
Positive/negative since 20241115/93514/9
Happy after 3+ years2809
Longest happy owner23 yrs10 yrs
Praised forreliability and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forease of use and softwarereliability and support
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: NeutralSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
The Samsung Galaxy Note (the first one) had a screen size of 5.3 inches. The Samsung Galaxy Note 2 had a screen size of 5.5 inches. I had one and regularly had strangers ask me if that was really a phone. I had friends say, "Give me a call on your tablet" as a joke. I loved it. Now my 6.1 inch iPhone feels on the small side.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
Beyond the Hz, the depth of the modulation matters. I am sensitive to poor PWM implementation, but Hue bulbs luckily don't bother me. On an old iPhone with basic slow-mo recording capabilities, typical Hue bulbs don't "blink" when the video plays back, but the PWM-dimmed iPhone in the same video recording was blinking/flashing like crazy. ~~ Another example of the PWM details mattering: I can't use any iPhone with OLED (anything from the X to current), but I am able to use a Note9 which has OLED with DC-style PWM.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy Note: Neutral
Curious how you're finding it so far? I mowed my Note20 Ultra in June of last year and replaced it with a 14 Pro Max then just last month went and swapped back to an S24 Ultra. I found Apple to be too restrictive. The OS level stuff was one thing but the app store lacking things like emulators or vape apps because "Apple said so" rubbed me the wrong way, whether I need them or not. Plus I like writing python on my phone.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
> Rich people? Everyone wants iPhones, they are by far the best smartphones. Why do people think this? I've been using a Samsung Note with the Wacom stylus for over a decade. Every now and then I try an iPhone and the experience is good, but not great. The UI noticeably lags on any iPhone over a year old. The keyboard is annoying and lacks features I use, and third party keyboards don't integrate properly. No consistent back button behaviour, it's up to apps to implement and each does it differently. There is no way to sync the calendar or contacts with Webdav, not even with third party apps. So far as I know, there is no ADB equivalent. Other than the phenomenal camera, which I think the newer Samsung S-series phones with the stylus match, I fail to see the appeal of the iPhone. Well, it is an appealing device, but not the "best" device for many workflows.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like it
I really tried to ride that train, had a Nexus 6, which got stuck in an unrecoverable boot loop after a year, after that a Nexus 6P which bricked itself similarly, and then a flagship Samsung Note something, which couldn't be charged because of "moisture in the port" after a year, despite it being completely dry, after which the battery inflated so much it blew open the whole case. Then I bought an iPhone 11 Pro and it "just works" to this day, with no replacement needed in sight. After years of being that guy who explains the "dangers" of walled garden ecosystems to my boomer iPhone parents, I joined their gang and have been living carefree since.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Neutral
It was AirPods for me, I was fully android and chrome os (pixelbook), windows on my work machine. Then AirPods came out and they worked with my Samsung note, but I got an iPhone at upgrade time. 5 years later and I’ve just got my second iPhone and my house is fully in the Apple ecosystem. The “how do we?” Or “can you setup this” have effectively stopped from my wife and kids.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like it
I think that Android has burned too many users in weird ways. For example, I recently convinced my father to switch to iPhone after 4 years of Android. Why? The first phone he got was a Galaxy S7 (Snapdragon). After just a year it was extremely slow, crashing all the time, overheating... which turned out to actually be a very, very common problem with the processor (Snapdragon 820). It was Qualcomm's first stab at a 64-bit processor and it showed. Well... try, try again. Galaxy Note 9. After a year, super slow at everything, even though all he does is browse internet and check emails. Even the Microsoft Outlook app would crash loading Inbox 25% of the time with no other apps open. Battery replacement and factory reset didn't help at all. A few months after that, it started dropping Verizon phone calls at random. Turns out that was another flaw widely reported on their forums, specifically on Verizon, with a botched software update installation for the modem, that if you were unfortunate enough to install, could not be removed or repaired or factory reset. And, of course, Samsung wasn't pushing any updates to fix it. Kind of a really big deal when you are a small business owner. So iPhone 13 he went. A year and a half later and it doesn't drop calls.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
Went from a Note 8 to iPhone. Lack of stylus bugs me all the time. One of my favourite features was being able to hover over foreign language words and it would translate them, even if the word was in image or a button on an application. On iOS if you wanted to translate the text on a button you have to take a screen capture, then translate the screen capture. This was possible partly because of the stylus hover feature, but also because the Android permission model allowed for applications (translation service) to 'see' the screen of other applications. Something I don't think iOS allows. If you enjoy using foreign apps, learning languages or living in an area with a different language the Samsung Note series was fantastic.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like it
Apple does a much better job. My Note 10, released in 2019, is officially close to its EOL (last year of life support, i.e. security fixes) - and it was a big step forward for Samsung to ever even give such guarantees. The iPhone X, released in 2017, still gets new versions of iOS. Even phones that have long been dropped from new iOS releases still get security fixes for a long, long time. I hate Apple for some things and even they could probably do better, but they're incredibly far ahead here (now if only the devices were more repairable).
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
It was perfect for the time. It's definitely lacking in features today, which is by definition true of any phone from that era. I still have them both with me and in active use - mostly as remote controls, kids games, etc. Perhaps more pertinently, my daily driver is a Galaxy Note 8, which also has a 3.5mm jack and MicroSD card. There's really nothing that my 4-generations newer, work-mandated iPhone has, in terms of functionality and definitely battery life, that Note 8 does not. iPhones are about sexy impracticality, and that's clearly where market has gone (Unlike S2 & S5, Note 8 also cannot be held without a case) - I'm just a old grouch who misses the olden days :).
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like it
This is a decent example of what folks are talking about in terms of supported lifespan. Your Note 8 was EOL'd in October 2021. It came out in September of 2017. That's four years of support. My iPhone came out around the same time and Apple is planning to support devices several generations older than mine with iOS 16...
Apple iPhone: NeutralSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
That’s fair. Maybe I tend forget a lot of the issues older Android versions had. I always had Samsungs, never remember any issues with them getting hot, maybe that was an HTC problem? I think my first android was a Samsung Galaxy S3. Now that I think about it, I do remember a lot of weird bugs and restarts to fix some issue. After that I had a Note 4 & 5, and I really have high opinions of those. I kept the 5 for over 3 years I think it roped out at Android v8.x and it was pretty good, but still not as reliable a iOS at the time I’m sure. I recently got one of those cheap Samsung tablets & I must say I’m impressed with Android v10. I switched to iPhone a couple years ago out of curiosity mostly. It’s fine. Doesn’t blow me away, but you’re right. Super reliable. There are things I miss about my Note, and things it did better, but also things about the iPhone I would miss if I went back. Mostly the seamless and sync between my MacBook Pro/ iMac, and effortless wireless file sharing with airdrop are amazing. As a dev, I do like to use a Linux box for daily use so I’m with you there :)
Switched from the Apple iPhone to the Samsung Galaxy NoteSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
There seems to be little comment about actual "choice". A lot of comments on this site and the original news site seem to be either "I hate SD cards because..." or "I love SD cards because...". The question to ask is: What about the consumer in general? Does this decision limit choice? The answer is: Yes, it does, and that's a bad thing. I now cannot use an app that I paid for to copy MY files to an arbitrary folder on MY device and use a different program I also paid for to view/manipulate them. This is one of the key reasons I prefer my Galaxy Note 2 over my previous 3 iPhones. Anyone here who loves working with iTunes? Crickets... Making specious arguments about the coding difficulty involved with SD cards suddenly being removed is just inane. Are these people going to be arguing for PCs that prevent you working with external hard drives? No? I thought not. Are these people not bothered with having to pay an "Apple-like tax" on internal storage at 2-3x markup? People have been using memory cards in their cameras, mp3 players etc and there's been no backlash about hard that is to manage. It's a non-issue. Google, don't eff this up. Prefer choice over restrictions.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like it
Looks great except for the eMMC. That's the part that died on both of my previous phones (Galaxy NoteⅡ and Galaxy NoteⅣ; currently still using an iPhone 7 that's on its third battery and literally falling apart) so I am very wary of getting another phone with that type of non-replaceable storage. I know that people have replaced them but it takes some awfully fiddly soldering just to end up with another part that Will Die At Some Point.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
Another anecdotal example here: Nexus 4, Pixel 2 XL, Pixel 4 XL, Pixel 6 Pro – never had any issues whatsoever, all phones still alive and kicking at my grandparents' places. Yes, most of them tied to the wall now... but hey, they're fine for showing some photos and displaying current time or setting alarms. Interestingly, I also used Samsung's Note 9 and 10+, iPhone 12, iPhone 14 Pro Max – daily, also with no issues... other than disliking Samsung's software. (I was/am doing a lot of mobile work so I test a lot of phones) After years of doing this kind of testing, it's hard for me to believe that the entire batches of phones are so fundamentally broken... I'd rather bet on software issues, but who knows.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
I used the original Moto X as long as I could. I can't even remember what I got after. I'm now sporting a iPhone mini. Obviously the market just isn't there for smaller phones, but I actually think the iPhone 3GS had the best form factor of any phone I've used, and it's smaller screen encouraged information density, which I like. I say I use an iPhone mini now, and it's true, but only because Apple requires you to use an iPhone with their Watch. I've given up on the phone form factor, and use an Apple Watch with an ear bud and cellular, and keep the phone in drawer most of the time. Actually is was the Moto lineup that got me onto that: they had that short-lived earbud that was marketed as requiring zero screen in order to do all your mobile computing (I never got one though). You might wonder why one wouldn't just use an Android watch that could do all of it without the bullshit Apple tax across multiple devices. It's for similar reasons for why I didn't end up liking the Galaxy Note, even though it still, to this day, feels like a miracle that they could cram so many features AND so much quality into that device, and that it could legitimately perform in all those categories. The iPhone mini still feels too big, but at least it's mostly usable with one hand, even if it's not comfortable to do something like pull down the control panel shade on the top right corner with your left hand. I know I'm just a weirdo though. I thought the Windows Phone UI was brilliant, especially…
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
This started with my LG g3. That was a flagship when I got it. My HTC M8 also died. I had a galaxy s3, s4, s6, and a note. The note 8 was the only one that survived longer than a year. Meanwhile, my iPhone 7+ was in service for 6 years. I owned it until I upgraded to an XS, and a family member used it up until last year. I used the XS until I got a free upgrade to the 13.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
On an iPhone 13 pro right now but miss a few things about Samsung/Note series phones: Stylus. Better web browser options. Dex. 360 support. knox/secure secondary area. ability to install multiple versions of same app (eg for two diff whatsapp numbers). fingerprint sensor. custom launchers with better widgets. better youtube clients. chromecast receiving. windows and side-by-side displays. And I actually really liked the ability to remap the bixby button on older devices as a dedicated back button. I fully suspect future iPhones will have more hardware (ish) buttons on the sides of phones. or dedicated touch points on the phone rim for certain functions/programability. Especially since 'Shortcuts' are a thing in ios. iphone wins hands down for battery life, processor speed (especially video/processing), and arguably for some aspects of camera.
Apple iPhone: Likes itSamsung Galaxy Note: Likes it
Interesting - I still have my good old note 3 as daily driver, although my use case has changed (It is the need for better modem/antenna tech) that makes me upgrade. I am testing the IPhone 13 now. It is quite a jump in UX, hardware capability (5G, camera, storage space not so much). Also, your flashlight app does not spy on you. The Note 3 was truly a masterpiece when it came into the market. Also, the the exchangeable battery was very practical. And 8+ years in use: what a economical and ecological device. If I find some time, I will have a look at lineageOS. Any hints?