The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Pine64 PinePhone

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple iPhone.

Apple iPhonePine64 PinePhone
Owners with an opinion4629137
Positive verdicts58% of 384225% of 112
Positive/negative since 20241115/93511/49
Happy after 3+ years2801
Longest happy owner23 yrs4 yrs
Praised forreliability and performanceease of use and repairability
Criticized forease of use and softwareperformance and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
I have thought about buying one of the Pinephone things, because I want to actually own the computer in my pocket, but I have always hesitated because the hardware is always kind of ancient for these things. The Pinephone doesn’t even have 5G, so I am not even sure that my phone service will let me activate it now. What I would like is to take my existing iPhone 13 Pro and install a real Linux on it so I could guarantee decent hardware. You know, like we could do with pretty much any computer before smartphones.
Apple iPhone: NeutralPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
It is kind of extreme. I personally daily drove the OG Pinephone for about a year-and-a-half, back in 2020. I bought in during the postmarketOS edition. I'm still dealing with the fallout from the choices I made in order to conform with that phone. And at the end of the day... I got nothing out of it. Nothing but issues, problems and inconveniences. The modem eventually stopped working for some reason, and I moved to an iPhone 7 that had been abandoned for quite some time. It felt like I had let out a breath I had been holding in for years.
Apple iPhone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
If someone physically steals my phone, they can’t install a keylogger that loads before the login screen. The sandboxing actually works pretty well and serves a useful feature, the PinePhone doesn’t have sandboxing at all (and even Flatpak sandboxing often has massive holes punched through). The iPhone has dozens, if not hundreds, of research organizations working on it to find bugs. Even Apple’s competitors like Google contribute. I have no assurance the PinePhone’s login screen doesn’t have an obvious buffer overflow. If my iPhone does somehow get a virus, no virus has been found that can persist between reboots since iOS 9. Linux, persistence is the default. If an iPhone app gains my PIN code, it’s bad but mostly meaningless to system integrity, which is forbidden at a kernel level from being tampered with by anything. If a Linux app gets your root password, or a privilege escalation bug is found in the many userspace utilities, daemons, or processes, you’re SOL. The iPhone has hardware level features called “mailboxes” in the Secure Enclave, which enforce the limits for how often a PIN can be guessed; making a software bypass impossible and even a 4-digit code relatively safe. PinePhone doesn’t even have secure boot, so loading a tool that runs unlimited guesses could not be easier. Do I need to go on?
Apple iPhone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
When I spoke of inferior experiences, I was referring to the Pine Phone, not the Pixel 2. I'm sorry that wasn't clear! That said, the iPhone 8 is still supported by Apple (probably for the last year), while the Pixel 2, like the Pixels 3, 4, and 5, are no longer supported by Google. This likely doesn't matter to someone not running standard Google-supplied AndroidOS, though! My use of the closed-source iPhone is not solely based on feature quality, and I've got no illusions that every feature is the best in class. P.S. Just before clicking the reply button, I decided to do the search myself, curious. The iPhone 8 was a weird model; that was the year they released both the iPhone 8 and the iPhone X, because (IMO) they lacked the courage to switch things up in their flagship product so much in one year. (Okay, and maybe also supply issues?) Still, when I DDG'd "pixel 2 iphone 8", I got results[0] that seem to not be the same as yours. The first doesn't really make any determination, the second is mealy-mouthed but seems to give an edge to Pixel 2 based primarily on price ("the Pixel 2 is a better value, starting out at about $50 and £70 cheaper than the iPhone 8" vs "you'll actually get more bang for your buck with the iPhone 8"), and the third, well, it's right in the title: "iPhone 8 vs. Pixel 2: Why Apple Beats Google." So I don't know, I bought an iPhone X that year rather than an iPhone 8, and just replaced that with an iPhone 14 Pro this year after five years of faithful…
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itPine64 PinePhone: Likes it
Different priorities don't make OP disingenuous. If you want to run a mostly free software stack and Emacs, LineageOS is definitely way worse than PinePhone [1]. Alarms do work, OP just missed the apps that make it possible: https://linuxphoneapps.org/categories/alarm-clock/ Regarding connectivity: This really seems to depend on the hardware revision (OP's braveheart edition was the first available to the general public), the proprietary bits of the modem firmware, your carrier and maybe a bit luck: I am having less connectivity issues on my PinePhone than on my iPhone 13 mini. Seriously. [1]: See https://mainline.space and contrast it with https://not.mainline.space
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itPine64 PinePhone: Likes it
No, it's about making the phones themselves more repairable so that it makes financial sense to have them repaired versus buying new ones all the time. It would also be great if they were more robust in general. Even with the correct tools, and decent skills, repairing a lot of common issues on modern phones is really expensive and complex. After a couple years of value depreciation, it is often questionable whether it's even worth it. The problem is that today, the incentives are all fucked up. Everyone's just trying to make phones with increasingly greater sex appeal every year so that they can convince consumers to throw out their perfectly working phones. Granted, there was obviously rapid progress for quite a while, but it has slowed down a considerable amount; it's hard to argue that this year's phone line ups offers something significantly game changing versus last year's. People have been saying this for a while, but it just gets truer every year. At best, real meaningful differences occur around every three years or so now. I really don't think corporations will magically decide to all agree to stop this completely unsustainable and pointless madness. It seems like the perfect place for regulation, because it puts everyone on a level playing field. I also think people are imagining that the result will be phones that all look and feel like the PinePhone (which, BTW, feels pretty nice in my opinion) but honestly, I seriously doubt that's the case. The degree of corner…
Apple iPhone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
You are concluding things from a false premise. Just because mobile phones are not zero trust devices (note that there is no such thing anywhere!) doesn’t mean they are not secure against malware. While iphones have a really good security and privacy story, I may get that with sufficient tinfoil hat-layers one might choose not to trust apple (though the only target vector would be a deliberate malware created and pushed by apple itself) But there is also the Graphene project which runs on the Pixel phones, where you have complete control over the software. But the hardware will always be somewhat proprietary so you can’t have complete trust in that either. (And no, pinephone and alia just put closed firmware into the hardware not even allowing updating it, which is strictly worse than having it patchable) Nonetheless, both of these options are orders of magnitudes safer than desktop OSs, as per my original statement.
Switched from the Apple iPhone to the Pine64 PinePhonePine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
I like mine after installing mobian rather than the disaster it shipped with. Just needed something as good as my old iPhone 6s… but not quite there yet. :-/ Also assumed there’d be new hardware by now. Skipped the Pro, when does a new one come out? Been four years I think, which is worse than shipping a phone ten years out of date at launch.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itPine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like it
My ideal mobile computer would be something like the GPD MicroPC, but with mobile broadband, a camera, and a bit bigger battery. Hell, if it had the ability to do proper phone things, it could legitimately make a decent mobile phone replacement: it doesn't really need to be spectacular. The keyboard is small, but in situations where a laptop dock is a possible answer, it's pretty damn good. In other situations, having a dedicated laptop would be ideal, of course... But I've been experimenting with ditching smartphones and alternative phone options, and I gotta say, the MicroPC really feels like it's as close to the ideal general purpose mobile computer as I've ever gotten, so the desire to have something like it that really could just replace any other mobile device is strong. Unfortunately though, as of today, we're really no closer. For some insane reason, most computers that can do mobile broadband cannot do calling or SMS, at least not in any obvious way. The PinePhone Pro offers a potential story, giving you effectively Linux but on a touchscreen, but many of the OS options for it do not handle suspend well enough; and the RK3399S is not exactly about to blow anybody's mind with its performance. And of course, with no keyboard, you'll need to dock it to do any kind of "productivity" work. With how fast flagship phones are, dockable smartphones that can just provide a full desktop OS experience when plugged in should be commonplace, but they're not. Some vendors have sh…
Apple iPhone: Likes itPine64 PinePhone: Likes it
Please keep in mind that my comments come from someone who bought a Framework laptop precisely because of their right to repair stand. I've also experimented with alternate phones like the Pine Phone, looking for something that could be more open. However, like many criticisms of Apple's phone, this one is also largely bogus. This person wants a phone that's less than 8mm thick, with a high resolution screen, high quality camera, holes for speakers, a hole for a charger, smooth and tight tolerances all the way around, etc., that can mostly be taken under-water. (I regularly forget I have my iPhone in my pocket when I get in the pool and never once put it in a bed of rice.). Then it's surprising that it has to be fixed or disassembled with machinery to ensure that it correctly seals, doesn't break, bend, or warp during disassembly or assembly? Or that maybe it requires some degree of training to develop the confidence to use correctly? Could Apple design a phone that can be repaired at home with a hair dryer, plastic spudger, gasket kit, and a set of jeweler's screw drivers? Could Apple design a phone with an easily replaceable battery? Could it work with any PoS battery you order off Ali express because the Chinese knock-offs on Amazon are too expensive? Absolutely. It just wouldn't be 7mm this, largely water tight, non-exploding, etc. etc. And wouldn't be supported by the manufacturer for 5+ years. You would have something like my Pine phone. I can do anything I wa…