The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Palm Treo

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple iPhonePalm Treo
Owners with an opinion462939
Positive verdicts58% of 384279% of 34
Positive/negative since 20241115/93515/5
Happy after 3+ years2802
Longest happy owner23 yrs20 yrs
Praised forreliability and performanceease of use and design
Criticized forease of use and softwareperformance and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Likes itPalm Treo: Doesn’t like it
I went from a Palm Treo to the iPhone in 2007, these devices were not in the same league. Years apart in all aspects. I had an external box for tomtom gps on the treo and a janky mp3 player and some crappy apps on a resistive touch screen that looked like it had a permanent hazy film over it as all resistive ones do. The apps part was rectified pretty quickly but even the kind of halfway decent web apps available after iPhone launch beat treo apps.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itPalm Treo: Likes it
What's funny is I actually use to have a Palm Treo and I feel like I stopped being able to text even remotely efficiently ever since I switched from that to my first iPhone. Probably just a me problem, but I feel like I've never been able to get any good at typing on a screen keyboard no matter how long I do it. That said, I may consider this just for the fact that I won't have to retype/correct every other word in a text lol.
Apple iPhone: NeutralPalm Treo: Doesn’t like it
Of phones I owned 10+ years ago: iPhone 6S: 138.3/67.1/7.1 = 65.9 cc the mini is just barely smaller. iPhone 4S: 115.2/58.6/9.3 = 62.8 cc smaller than the mini. Treo 650: 113/59/23 = 153 cc which is about the same volume as a Galaxy Z Fold 3... the displacement was so uncomfortable, people often used hip holsters for the former.
Apple iPhone: Likes itPalm Treo: Doesn’t like it
>, we had plenty touch screen smartphones in Europe, between Nokia, Siemens-Ericson and PocketPC/Windows CE. Those were older TFT resistive touchscreens and not the newer capacitive touchscreens that could detect multi-finger gestures like swipes and pinch-to-zoom. TFT touchscreens requiring finger pressure instead of finger swipes is not as intuitive a UI. That's why the audience at Macworld 2007 gasped in astonishment when Steve Jobs demonstrated gentle finger scrolling on a capacitive screen. Deep link to that demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQKMoT-6XSg&t=16m05s Keep in mind that MacWorld tradeshow attendees are technology geeks who are aware of the latest gadgets and phones . Many of those in the audience would already have the latest 2006 Palm Treo 680 in their pocket that had a TFT touchscreen. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treo_680 ) The iPhone's touchscreen capabilities made that Palm phone's TFT touchscreen technology obsolete. You can check the Europe news archives back in 2007 to see both the telecoms and customers there were also eagerly awaiting the iPhone. If Europe already had equivalent touchscreen smartphones with Nokia, Siemens-Ericsson etc, the iPhone would have been a non-event and flopped in sales. Nokia/Blackberry/WindowsCE/Android/etc switched to capacitive touchscreens to compete with the iPhone. Why didn't European devs collectively just ignore the Apple iPhone and instead, focus on Nokia Symbian OS? Devs did ignore pla…
Apple iPhone: Likes itPalm Treo: Doesn’t like it
I don’t think we can even reasonably talk about Palm circa 2007 and iPhone 2007 in the same sentence. PalmOS was an aging clusterfuck that was a PDA with cellular glommed onto it (and the good Treo’s of the era ran Windows Mobile, which was better in some ways but a ridiculous mess for its own reasons) and the iPhone, even without apps or 3G was such a revelation and improvement that it single-handedly reshaped not just mobile, but personal computing, nearly overnight. The software the iPhone did have was truly impressive — at least for the core feature that really set it apart: the web browser. The capacitive touch screen and the on-screen keyboard made mince meat out of every other mobile operating system in existence or even in development; Google completely changed Android from being a Palm/BlackBerry clone to being an iPhone clone as soon as they saw it. People were willing to jailbreak and reverse engineer their iPhones to run apps on it. Palm, like most everyone else, was caught completely flat-footed. They weren’t working on webOS in 2007; their next-gen version of Palm OS (the name escapes me) was not going to set the world on fire and Windows Mobile (who they increasingly had offloaded software duties to) was also not doing super well. It took new investors (and management changes that included ousting Colligan, who by all accounts is a pretty great guy and who did lead Palm and Handspring well in different environments) and a brand new engineering team for Palm t…
Apple iPhone: Likes itPalm Treo: Doesn’t like it
So I had one of these and loved it so much, but then I switched to an, early-ish, iPhone, perhaps the 3G one, after playing with a couple early-ish androids. The iPhone was just so much better, generally, even if I lost the parts of the Treo that appealed to the more "nerdy" or tinkerer parts of me. I think this was a lesson for me on how important UI is to mass-market devices. The Treo had so much going on for it, but most of the things you describe, most people would describe as awkward to use. Worse, the hardware keyboard meant the screen would always be smaller than an iPhone. I think the earliest Androids were marketed as "still has a keyboard" and that didn't really last. No one cared other than die-hards. Downloading apps from random websites wasn't fun either. The app stores make a lot of sense in general, but moreso in mobile. I also learned most times I'm forced to be a "tinkerer" by the industry, when most times I just want stuff to "just work" so I can choose what to tinker with. Oh, my win10 wont update to win11 because I need to redo the boot type and install a TPM chip on my old motherboard? That's not fun tinkering, that's annoying. The same way all the little things about the Treo or other less polished tech were like that. The game or novel I'm writing? That's fun tinkering. It was also a lesson for me on how if you want to sell a mass-market product, the geeky, super-efficient, nerd-culture wisdom, etc stuff is a liability, not an asset. A lot of Apple win…
Apple iPhone: Likes itPalm Treo: Doesn’t like it
> Balckberry, Treo, AIM, XMPP, and Windows Mobile 2 of those aren't phones, did you mean something else? On the other three, that's kind of like saying that the IBM Selectric blazed the trail for the PC — not wrong, but minimizing how much room there was still to go. If you used a Blackberry, it was good at message, tolerable for email, and bad at everything else. The Treos had some nice ideas but were agonizing slow, PalmOS was unstable, the software selection was limited, and the UI was … uninspired. Windows Mobile was at least stable but held back by mediocre hardware, and it had the lowest-common denominator problem that developers had to deal with the same OS running on a wide range of hardware and thus apps weren't usually tailored to work with the hardware. The major trailblazing things added by the iPhone were the first touchscreen UI which was often better than a desktop UI — the Palm-style touchscreens with a stylus were much clumsier – and a desktop-grade web browser. Yes, other devices had mobile browsers earlier but they had significant compatibility issues and the UIs were uniformly clumsy — I briefly had a work Blackberry which was one of the last non-Android devices they made and despite coming out later, it was worse that an iPhone 1 in every way except messaging, and that's only if you excluded the App Store because that wasn't in the first release. One of the big things which people underestimated was how much bigger the iPhone screen felt: when you were us…
Apple iPhone: Likes itPalm Treo: Doesn’t like it
Nice article, but I have one thing to say: your list of priorities for features is probably what you think you want. Before I got the iPhone, I never browsed the internet on my Treo because the experience was just absolutely terrible (the experience on blackberry is also terrible). Now I browse the web on my iPhone more than I use it as a phone. While investigating how to make the best UI, I've found that people's priorities come from their habits and not necessarily from their needs. At first this seemed kind of illogical to me. But if you think about it, before the iPhone, no normal people really could imagine a mobile browser as good as mobile Safari, so no one really put "a desktop experience web browser" at the top of their requirements lists for phones (obviously tech people did, but average people did not). I wonder what would happen if you bought an iPhone.
Switched from the Palm Treo to the Apple iPhoneApple iPhone: Likes it
You're completely discounting quality of execution, which in this case is everything. It's the whole ballgame. I had friends who were Palm Treo die-hards, and they dropped them unceremoniously in 2008 when they used an iPhone for the first time. They were already used to carrying around a phone that could do email and access the internet. But the qualitative jump to the iPhone was so big that it upended the industry and became quite literally the most successful consumer product of all time. If you can't see how that's different from Palm, I don't know what to tell you.
Switched from the Palm Treo to the Apple iPhoneApple iPhone: Likes it
Not really. I had a fairly recent Treo at the time. I certainly didn't buy an iPhone when it first came out. Come the 3GS I was definitely ready to go with Apple but it wasn't an instant switch. Of course, I was also not an Apple customer at the time except for an iPod sometime around that time.
Switched from the Palm Treo to the Apple iPhoneApple iPhone: Likes it
The call quality on the iPhone seems much better than on previous smartphones I've used (almost exclusively Treos), and callers complain about my voice quality far less then they used to. I can't compare to Blackberries since I haven't owned any. I'm willing to believe that Palm's handset design was poor, although I did own every Sprint model that came out for several years (300, 600, 650, 700) and you'd think they'd have fixed it if call quality was that bad. My understanding is that 3G (UMTS/HSDPA) and EDGE/GSM are two different networks running in parallel. If the 3G network is overloaded with iPhones, then older/cheaper phones that only use 2.5G should (in my understanding) work better. This theory could be tested if iPhone owners tried disabling 3G, but I don't know if that's a widely-tested theory. I don't know if the overloaded 3G network is the entire problem with the iPhone - maybe it's combined with a poor ability to handle an overcrowded network. I can say that I live in Western NY (Rochester) and do not see any of the problems people/articles report. I drop calls maybe once every two weeks, I've only missed calls due to reception problems and have never had problems with missing/failed text messages. (I have had some occasional Visual Voicemail issues, however.) I have, however, had all those problems when going to conferences in much larger cities, and those conferences have had very high proportions of iPhone users. It's a tricky problem, because Apple chooses
Apple iPhone: Likes itPalm Treo: Likes it
I carried a Palm Treo 700p until about five years ago. Only as a PDA, no phone or internet access. I used to swear I’d be buried with a Palm in my pocket. But now I am feeling the same way about my iPhone. You can have my iPhone when you take it from my cold, dead…
Apple iPhone: NeutralPalm Treo: Neutral
I had a Treo and didn't switch to an iPhone until the 3GS. A lot of people remember the iPhone (and iPod) as these overnight successes--and they really weren't although they sold well enough. It was around the third or fourth generation that both really hit their stride. (As I recall iTunes didn't even run on Windows at first and Macs were systems used mostly by media professionals.)
Apple iPhone: NeutralPalm Treo: Neutral
The app ecosystem on the iPhone (and then Android) certainly became much more significant over time. But the 2007 iPhone announcement didn't upend things over night. I had a Treo at the time and didn't get around to switching over to an iPhone until the 3GS in 2010 or thereabouts--which was probably the model when the iPhone really started taking off. (The iPod was similar. A lot of people viewed the initial models as just another and not very compelling MP3 player.) And you're right that the iPhone also hit the market at a time when data plans were becoming more affordable for people not expensing them. My Treo's plan was fairly reasonable as a recall but then you couldn't really use a huge amount of data anyway.
Apple iPhone: Likes itPalm Treo: Likes it
I started using Graffiti on my Newtons; under NewtOS 1.x, having it was the difference between usable pen input and not. Under 2.x, the native HWR was so much better than I really only ended up using Graffiti when I was editing an existing block of text -- but it was still very useful. And then, like almost everyone, I shifted to Palm. I had forgotten about the lawsuit. The issue for me was that, by the time that was muddying the water, I had moved on to a keyboard-based Treo 650 that I used off and on with sidelines in BlackBerry (about which UGH) and WinMo (UGH UGH UGH) -- until I got my first iPhone. The Treo keyboard was good enough I didn't miss stylus input, but on the WinMo device I absolutely did. BB was its own thing, but didn't really work for me on any level. I'm probably faster on my iPhone than I was with Graffiti, but both input mechanisms enabled fast-enough input that I was rarely frustrated at the input rate.