The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs OnePlus

Hacker News owners lean toward the OnePlus.

Apple iPhoneOnePlus
Owners with an opinion4629301
Positive verdicts58% of 384273% of 255
Positive/negative since 20241115/935104/32
Happy after 3+ years28025
Longest happy owner23 yrs11 yrs
Praised forreliability and performanceperformance and reliability
Criticized forease of use and softwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
Having both would be even better. My current Android phone (Pixel 7) has both Face Unlock and an on-screen fingerprint scanner. My previous phone (a OnePlus) had Face Unlock along with a rear-mounted fingerprint reader, which was even better. Unlocking a phone has never felt as effortless on my iPhones; after all these years, it continues to be a nuisance. Face ID is fine, but you have to hold the phone right in front of your face (and its angle sensitivity is far less forgiving than on my Android phones, where it recognizes you even at an angle--unlike the iPhone, where you practically have to hold it parallel to your face). Plus, there are countless situations where you cannot or do not want to pick up your phone from a table just to align it with your face. In those cases, I am forced to type in my passcode, whereas an on-screen fingerprint scanner would be a billion times more convenient. I am mostly baffled that such a "solved," trivial problem in the Android ecosystem continues to be a topic or a matter of "choice" on iPhones.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
I'm carrying my 13 Pro without a case, to see it's Alpine Green glory and feel the matte finish on the back. It's been perfectly fine for the last almost 4 years, some minor scratches on the steel edges I fixed with a sandpaper, there is one recent scratch on the screen and that's all. Otherwise it looks good, just a bit used. Has fallen multiple times from pocket when sitting, and a dozen times from tables, few times onto pavement (that's what needed sanding). Almost every single one "case" for iPhone is a waste. Waste of material, waste of space, waste of your money, waste of user experience. You've already paid for a perfectly good phone, and then slapped some $[1]0.99 case on it to gain nothing but pain and vanity. I only had one case on a phone, that made it better - original wooden case for 1+3T. Been looking for same experience on iPhone, but it's not possible due to shape -- they are all bulky. The closest thing is carbon-fiber cases, and I had one, which saved this iPhone when I dropped it onto slanted pavement, where it slid for a few meters screen down, ruining the case, but saving the screen. Would I drop it if I wasn't using a case, that has parts sticking out, making the phone more cumbersome to use and carry? Unlikely, because it happened in the first year owning it, and I've been going caseless since then and nothing similar happened.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
There's always a "later" or equivalent button in all of these setups, sometimes it does have a few prompts. I personally have iPhone, Google Pixel, OnePlus, Motorola and Samsung devices, without any accounts on them. The iPhones are very limited without an account, obviously, but I never feel that way on Android. All that I did to set them up, is click on the screen a few times, no extra tools or anything. Then just go into the browser, and follow the instructions for F-Droid installation; which can be done entirely on the phone, without a computer or any other phone, or any username/password.
Apple iPhone: Likes itOnePlus: Neutral
I think the renting analogy is a decent one and I’m on the other side of this, so let me give you my perspective. When you own a home, you are 100% liable and responsible. If anything breaks, it’s an unexpected demand on my time and/or an unexpected expense. When you rent, you just call the landlord and say “shit’s broke” and it’s no longer your responsibility. I don’t have the mental bandwidth these days for the unexpected demands the house places on me. This is _exactly_ the experience I had with Android versus iPhone. I bought the original Android Dev Phone 1. Still have it somewhere. Moved to a Galaxy Nexus, Nexus 4, couple of OnePlus phones, etc. Used the stock Android, Cyanogenmod, LineageOS, and others. Did all sorts of fun stuff. Then my life got busier and busier and busier and I found myself sitting up late one night dicking with fixing something on my phone again and just was like nope, this is not how I need or want to be spending my time. My life has only gotten busier since. I don’t have time for suddenly finding out one day that the last update that I installed broke the microphone on my phone and I can no longer use it as a phone. Using the iPhone is having a landlord. If it breaks, it’s just broken. Not only do I not need to feel responsible for fixing it, I couldn’t if I wanted to. It takes up no space in my head. So the fact that Apple (1) generally doesn’t release terribly broken software; (2) supports their devices with updates for a long time; and (3) is…
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
I made the switch at the end of 2021 after only having an android phone since the very first one. I wouldn't say I regret the change but I would say I'm not impressed. The way so many of my friends mocked me for having an android phone and talked up their iphones made me think I _must_ be missing something. Alas, I don't feel that I was. Every once in a while I boot up my old android phone (oneplus 6) and use it and it's snappier than I remember and feels way better in my hand than my iphone does. I kinda want to go back but we'll see.
Apple iPhone: Likes itOnePlus: Doesn’t like it
Agreed. My business depends on my phone. If I can’t call clients or pull google maps up, I’m screwed. I have both an iPhone and an Android. I’ve never had an iPhone die for no good reason. Every single android phone I’ve owned prior to my OP 8T has died in under a year. I got hit with the LG bootloop bug on my first android phone and it just went from there. And that’s just hardware. The other day I realized my 8T had bricked itself. I hadn’t used it in a few days, and an OTA update broke something. Wouldn’t flash back the normal way either, I had to go and dig up specialized software and a copy of the ROM from XDA. I’ve never had an iPhone have a bug that a simple reboot wouldn’t fix. The same thing extends to computers too. I think macOS is an abomination, but the hardware they put out it leaps and bounds ahead of pretty much every other manufacturer. In comparison, my surface book 2 has been a steaming pile of shit from day 1. I built my desktop, but my laptop is a MBP. I’d get 3-4 hours of battery on the SB2 with brightness all the way down. The MBP will literally last all day unless I’m running Thinkorswim. Whoever thought that its performance was acceptable should be shot. Even on my desktop it will routinely use 5gb+ RAM alone.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
> The amortized cost for me is much less than any alternative Android. I think that with the trade-in program, I've spent a similar amount between 2016 and now upgrading to flagship OnePlus phones every year. The software updates have been good. For example, OnePlus 8 series were the first non-Google smartphones to receive Android 13. The bathtub curve of reliability applies to smartphones as it does to most electronics. The "infant mortality" failures can be covered by manufacturer warranty pretty well. But the "wear out" failures go up a lot in electronics after the first few years in my experience (with both Apple and other brands). In case of Apple, battery degradation and a bunch of build quality "-gates" come to mind. So there is value in upgrading your smartphone every year or two, ecology aside. I could do that with OnePlus phones but it might have been much too expensive for me to do it with iPhones.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
I used almost all Apple products from 2004 to 2018 when i decided to get off the bandwagon. I started with getting off the iPhone cause I wanted a fingerprint sensor and no notch. (OnePlus 7 Pro had what I wanted.) I hated the touch bar and wanted real F keys because I use those extensively in my IDEs. I also hated fixing my laptop once or twice a year cause keys broke. From an OS perspective, iOS upgrades permanently broke apps for me several times, which were not updated by their providers. For macOS, 10.8 was great and I eventually got to 10.12, but I had devices that work just fine but were 32-bit only. Then Homebrew even stopped supporting old versions, whichnwas the last straw. All in all, Apple just became more and more hostile to me and I am done with them. I keep an iPad solely for Foreflight, but I am sampling Garmin Pilot too. (Does not appear to be in the same league.)
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
With the SE (and regular 13 & 14) having not-that-great 60 Hrz displays, I could never switch from my 13 Pro to anything else but a 14 Pro (that's why my second phone is a Pixel 6 Pro [or sometimes a OnePlus 10 Pro], as 120 Hrz & 1440p are requirements for a phone to be in my pocket). I used to have a SE (2nd Gen), prior to ever experiencing a better display, and now I can never go back, However , if the came out with an SE that did have 120&1440p, I would definitely buy.
Apple iPhone: Likes itOnePlus: Neutral
Switched from Android to iPhone a few months ago. Hard to believe the difference. Android is really bad at many things, and I had a good brand (One Plus 6). Taking a picture on Android is an awful experience. The Camera app takes about 3 seconds to open, and freezes for a second when taking a picture. The Camera app on iPhone opens instantly and takes photos instantly. The quality of the pictures taken on the iPhone are also much much better. I don't like the closed model of the iPhone, but the quality is currently unbeatable.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
I really don't understand the hype for the iphone. I own a oneplus 8t on Android 12, I particularly like the 120Hz display and the very fast charging (65w). When my battery is almost dead I can get to 30% in just a few minutes. Android 12 has been a big improvement, it is really snappy and good looking (Android 11 was already good). I bought the phone 550Euros, and during the last black friday it was sold for 350Euros. The camera is ok makes decent enough photos. I tried last week-end my mum's iphone 13 and was really disappointed. She was not aware of faceid so I set it up with her, and the forced swipe up after unlocking the phone is annoying. On my phone, the fingerprint scanner is almost instantaneous and I get directly to the last opened application. Also I saw that the phone gets constant ads for Apple products (we disabled notifications): Apple pay, Apple watch, Apple TV, etc. really annoying. For me the main selling points for the iphone are the good camera and apple ecosystem integration. But the latter means that you are stuck with Apple hefty prices.
Apple iPhone: Likes itOnePlus: Doesn’t like it
I've been with Android since the beginning (though Apple everything else). But I'm just tired of needing a new phone every year just to get ok performance. A few weeks back I got a free iPhone 6, and was amazed at its performance. When I compared it to my OnePlus 2 phone from a year later, it's night and day performance wise. My next phone will be an iPhone, no question.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Likes it
When I was about to upgrade phones from an iPhone 8 Plus to an iPhone 12, I decided to back up my pictures from my old phone onto my Linux computer. I assumed it'd be as easy as an Android phone and act as a simple external drive when plugged in over USB; I assumed incorrectly. Plugging the phone into USB exposes almost nothing to the Linux OS, and pictures / videos are not present. Once I read a tutorial similar to this one, I was able to get my pictures off using libimobiledevice. BUT, none of the filenames were preserved. Even worse none of the file _extensions_ were preserved. Instead I was left with a jumbled mess of files named after a SHA checksum. I had to run `file` against them all with a script and rename accordingly. This was not going to cut it. I tried the alternate route of using iCloud / Photos app to get everything back. First I had to pay to get enough cloud storage to hold my 10,000 photos and 1,000 videos. Then I had to wait till they synchronized with the cloud over wifi since my phone obviously didn't have Ethernet. This took a night's sleep to finish. I had to jump through even more hoops which I don't remember, but this way barely worked too What's funny is that I had already bought the new iPhone 12. However, I was so annoyed by the locked-down Apple platforms that I returned the unopened iPhone for a full refund and got a OnePlus 9 Pro. Best decision ever. Now I have an unlocked bootloader and the ability to take phone backups, install LineageOS, roo…
Apple iPhone: NeutralOnePlus: Neutral
I guess I'm in an extreme minority here but... it's not broken if autocorrect is off. I raw dog my typing everywhere. Zero autocorrect. The last time I did use typing assistance was on BB10 with the 'flick to complete' because it was out of my way enough that I could ignore it was there or use it to save a small amount of time. Otherwise I too have the fond memory of Windows Phone's keyboard (I ran it on the HTC HD2), I couldn't tell you why it was good other than it felt good to use, again without autocorrect. However, I'm CERTAIN there's an ergonomics thing at play, the 'brain calibration' time for me to type accurately on a big screen takes longer. I ran the original iPhone SE's as long as I could and always carried a second android device that was huge by comparison. Today I have the 15 Pro and a OnePlus 11. If I spend a lot of time using the iPhone it takes a little time maybe 20 minutes or so to stop making easy errors on the OnePlus 11. However, going back to the smaller iPhone after being on the OnePlus for awhile, there's not really an adjustment, I can hit all the letters accurately. I have large hands, I still want the smaller device. There is extra work to need to move your hand and eyes across a larger device. More space to misclick on. Swipe to type is enabled on android/ios for me. I use it sometimes, if you are hesitant at all on iOS or have a tendency to drag fingers at all don't enable it or it will mess up your typing. It's of course enabled by default like…
Apple iPhone: Likes itOnePlus: Likes it
By the way, inferior goods are not necessarily poor-quality products, though there is a meaningful correlation, and I based my original comment on it. Still, a OnePlus Android phone is considered an inferior good; an iPhone (or a Samsung Galaxy Android phone) is considered superior. Both are of excellent quality and better than one another in key areas. It's more about how wealth, brand perception, and overall market sentiment affect their demand. OnePlus phones will be in more demand during recessions, and demand for iPhones and Samsung Galaxys will decrease. No objection to your use/non-use of the Market for Lemons label. Just wanted to clarify a possible misconception. P.S. Apologies for editing this comment late. I thought the original version wasn't very concise.
Apple iPhone: Likes itOnePlus: Likes it
any insider info on the current state of affairs? is los just barely making by or is there still some enthusiasm. used it for a few years on two oneplus devices and loved it. but - the usual shortcomings and issues requiring workarounds or other adaptions finally led me to the iphone ... i hate ios ... but they just work and especially when traveling i didn't feel like taking any risks with google api integrations for maps and messengers (also camera is just better).
Apple iPhone: Likes itOnePlus: Likes it
I consider that state of the art and brand new. I just inherited an iPhone XS and the battery is at 91%. I figure I can go at least another 3 years. For reference I was using a Oneplus 3T which is still going strong.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itOnePlus: Doesn’t like it
I had a pixel 7 pro, that after a half a year developed a battery problem. I got my money back and could get another pixel but was afraid of battery problems again, and picked a one plus 10 pro. I regret it. Pixel has the best Android expirence on the market. I'm not buying iPhones probably ever. I tried iphone 14 pro max a little bit and it's not worth 400 EUR over the Pixel for me. I also had Samsungs, they are ok, but pixel is better.