The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Nokia N-series

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Nokia N-series.

Apple iPhoneNokia N-series
Owners with an opinion462923
Positive verdicts58% of 384278% of 23
Positive/negative since 20241115/93510/2
Happy after 3+ years2800
Longest happy owner23 yrs–
Praised forreliability and performanceease of use and design
Criticized forease of use and softwareperformance and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Likes itNokia N-series: Doesn’t like it
I had an N95 when it first came out. It wasn't the screen so much that lured me to an iPhone but the web browsing experience. Trying to use the browser on the N95 was difficult it was slow to load pages and the reformatting was barely usable most of the time. Everything was high latency even on wifi. With the iPhone it didn't really reformat websites so much as allow you to render it normally and then zoom and centre on to the bit you wanted to read. This was pre-responsive web design so everything stayed roughly the same as a desktop screen layout. That and the multi-touch screen were the bits that made it superior enough for me to swap by the time the iPhone 3G came out.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itNokia N-series: Likes it
I've had the competition's ruggedized android phone with a flir camera for a couple of years now? [1] [1] https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4001227941445.html I don't love it like I did the nokia n900 but it is decent. It's an android that goes underwater, can take photos there and you can drop without being worried about breaking it including the screen - all phones should be like that. The flir camera pics look just like that, haven't really found a use for it yet but I guess I might one day. The endoscope is also a cool idea that hasn't really worked out so well when I've wanted to use it. It works it just an endoscope frequently isn't as useful as you'd hope it could be. Like every single android phone vendor they really need to get out of the business of providing the OS and set it up as a community project so it works the way you want and has upgrades if you want. Not that Apple, controlling everything, are better at this iphone6 now junk etc.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itNokia N-series: Likes it
I'm all over the place with pocket computing devices and remain confused. I once has an iphone. Beautifully crafted, both inside and out, but so frustratingly locked down that I was desperate to leave it behind. They have progressively opened up the platform, but it always lags behind (I remember I couldn't access the cloud storage from anything other than a mac). My favourite devices have been more alternative. E90 running symbian, which was fairly 'open' for its time - I could install any software, proper multitasking. The N900 also, full linux system, great phone. But then the apps I find useful, are often not available for that platform. At the moment I'm on Pixel, which has been a good balance between being well supported, while still fairly open. I can sideload apps, run a linux distro in the form of termux. As a bonus the camera is great. I have to remind myself that while it might not quite compare to iphones in terms of refinement and hardware, I do at least have more freedom on the platform, and it's easy to take that for granted until you lose it.
Apple iPhone: Likes itNokia N-series: Doesn’t like it
> instead of making better phone than Nokia he would make something that no one at Nokia or anywhere else even dreamed of. This oversells what Apple did and undersells just how much Nokia dropped the ball. Nokia wasn’t blindsided by the iPhone or touch screen interfaces. They knew about touchscreen interfaces and actively chose not to persue it. “Because people want tactile keyboards” essentially they Listened to much to their own engineers who were in love with blackberries. While Apple mindlessly perused a vision that notably had already failed them once in the Newton, and which every business major would say was a suicide mission “because the iPhone will canibalice the iPod market”. The reason Nokia failed was because management was just horribly bad. Not only did they have 500 different models of phones with every team competing internally, the were proud of it. Apple went out with “we have one phone and one phone only” at that time. And Nokia engineers laughed them off saying “how the hell will they ever complete with us, they have just one phone!?”, and of cause they also laughed at the price point, saying that trying to sell expensive phones in North America was concept that was dead at birth. No, to them true market dominance was to sell cheap phones in India and China. On the engineering side, that point in time was also when Nokia had extremely shitty software, again this wasn’t a mistake, they were proud of it. The N95 had like 4 different menu systems to reach the…
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itNokia N-series: Likes it
With refined product image. Their products have less features for the higher price and it is only the Apple image that sets them apart. Sure, later on they refine the product and most of the time it is their competitors that stumble or degrade their products in order to imitate or differentiate and due to that Apple stands out. Example - iphone - it was an amazing and revolutionary marketing of a sub-par imitation of other available touch screen phones. It wasn't until 3rd or 4th hardware release that iphone gained parity with other devices (tried copy+paste before then?, how about multitasking?) and other companies jumped on the bandwagon of locked down slow phones with short batter life. I had n900 and it was a great device with good batter life and all the software anyone could want but maybe a bit low on RAM. Still light years ahead of iphone at the time...and it died due to MS trying too hard to differentiate from iphone and android.
Apple iPhone: Likes itNokia N-series: Likes it
I had an Nokia N95 which was basically a smartphone and came out a year before the iPhone. And Wikipedia says >it became a huge sales success for Nokia ... It managed to outsell rivals such as LG Viewty and iPhone. However the iPhone got better.
Apple iPhone: Likes itNokia N-series: Likes it
Illbe switching to the iphone se 2022 from android after ~10 years for this exact reason. I'm fed up with not being able to hold my phone in my hand. I miss my nokia n73.