The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Motorola Razr

Hacker News owners lean toward the Motorola Razr.

Apple iPhoneMotorola Razr
Owners with an opinion462928
Positive verdicts58% of 384283% of 24
Positive/negative since 20241115/93514/2
Happy after 3+ years2800
Longest happy owner23 yrs–
Praised forreliability and performanceease of use and design
Criticized forease of use and softwaredisplay and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itMotorola Razr: Recommends it
> Alas it seems we won't see any such phone that fits in a pant's pocket and that can be operated single-handedly Check out the Motorola Razr! I switched from an iPhone 13 Mini to the Razr last year and I'm a big fan. The outer display is 4"! It runs all applications and it's extremely usable one-handed. Some apps and websites are clearly not designed for a screen that small, but the vast majority work just fine. And it unfolds into a phablet for when you want/need an enormous screen. And it's Android so you can use Firefox. I'm much happier with it than I was with the iPhone.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itMotorola Razr: Recommends it
They do make one with a 4" display! I'm a small phone liker. After spending years on an iPhone 13 Mini and wishing it was a little smaller, I got a Motorola Razr Ultra last year and I've been very happy with it. It has a fully functional 4" external display, and unfolds into a full-size smartphone display for when you need it. I use the little external display probably 80% of the time, but it's handy to unfold when you need it for Maps or something. I know it sounds wacky to have a foldable phone, I was nervous about it too, but give it a look. It's actually really cool.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itMotorola Razr: Likes it
In earlier smartphones fractured screens were indeed very rare, because the glass did not reach so close to the edges of the phone, i.e. to the impact zones. My "Razr i" took a hell of a beating. The iPhone 3 was also quite robust. Galaxy S4, iPhone 4 were probably the turning point in terms of robustness vs aesthetics.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itMotorola Razr: Likes it
Perhaps, but I was comparing Apple ear buds with the 3.5mm jack vs lightning ones. Presumably the drivers and whatnot would be similar. In general I don't think audio quality has ever been particularly important to Apple. The iPhone (and all smartphones really) is a jack of all trades gizmo not a device for high quality audio playback. I remember when I had a first gen iPhone and the call quality was atrocious with AT&T compared to my RAZR on Verizon. You get used to it over time but back to back it was pretty dramatic.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itMotorola Razr: Likes it
Im still on an iphone SE (same shell as 5s) and waiting for another iphone this small. The mini is still too big! I mean, I was a big fan of the nokia 8210, the iphone nano (the long one) and the razr when it first came out. I dont watch tv/films on my phone because Im not insane, give me a smaller one!
Switched from the Motorola Razr to the Apple iPhoneApple iPhone: Likes it
I had an iPhone on launch day. Compared to phones of today it wasn’t great, but compared to some of the phones it was replacing, it was fantastic. I was coming from a Moto Razr, so it was pretty much better in every way. For the smart phones of the day, there were a lot of things they could technically do on paper, but no one did, because they were too clunky to use. The iPhone solved this. The features it did have were a joy to use and easy to figure out and discover. There were also some pretty easy jailbreaks after not too long, which allowed for 3rd party apps before Apple had an official store. I think the only things holding back the original iPhone were the price and production volume. As I remember, it sold out quickly. And everywhere I went people were every interested in it. The guys selling cell phones at the mall were trying to stop me to see it, a girl at the bar said having that was better than a puppy. Pulling it out to use it was like being a celebrity, everyone started paying attention and trying to get close to it; it was a very strange time. I don’t recall anyone saying they didn’t want it due to a lack of features, other than people online looking for clicks or who had a history of Apple criticism.
Apple iPhone: Likes itMotorola Razr: Likes it
I got the iPhone 13 mini as a work phone for the sole reason of it being the smallest iPhone at the time. I too dislike the phone landscape nowadays with their ridiculous and ever increasing sizes. My personal device is a Motorola Razr 50 Ultra, which I got because while it's huge when flipped, it's portable enough when it's closed. I can have it in my pocket without it falling out.. without it being annoying while i put on shoes etc... I use its cover screen a fair amount too, to avoid having to flip it open, which is also why I got the ultra rather than the slightly smaller version.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itMotorola Razr: Doesn’t like it
The first few iPhones also had terrible browsers. When my dad got one in ~2008, Safari would consistently crash 5 seconds after loading apple.com as soon as an animation was triggered. Still a hell of an improvement over my Razr flip phone’s browser.
Apple iPhone: NeutralMotorola Razr: Neutral
All too common. I've had several devices (iPad, iPhone, iPod Touch) killed because Apple stopped providing any sort of software support until practically everything I used them for bitrotted away. The only old Apple device I have that still works fine is my iPod Nano, since it's too dumb to have this problem. I also have had to replace two otherwise pristine phones as 2G (Motorola Razr) and 3G (iPhone 5) services were discontinued, so there's that too.