The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Google Pixel 8

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple iPhone.

Apple iPhoneGoogle Pixel 8
Owners with an opinion4629122
Positive verdicts58% of 384246% of 101
Positive/negative since 20241115/93544/50
Happy after 3+ years2800
Longest happy owner23 yrs–
Praised forreliability and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forease of use and softwarereliability and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: NeutralGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
I had the exact same problem because I had a strong addiction to smartphone apps. I looked into the Light Phone and The Mudita Kompakt, but I ended up buying a refurbished Pixel 8 and putting Graphene OS on it, then I installed only essential apps I need. I keep my old iPhone 12 in a drawer at home and use it for anytime I Need any apps that don't work on a custom ROM, which includes my bank app (plus, imo, it's safer not carry around a phone that has my baking data on it in case it gets lost or stolen). The light phones are a really cool concept but the Light Phone 3 is quite expensive (more expensive than a new Pixel 10) and the Mudita Kompakt seems to have a huge amount of grievances from users on their forum, so that put me off.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
My iPhone 8 just stopped working 2 months back (phone works but the microphone used in phone calls no longer works) so by chance my good friend gave me his pixel 8 that was only a couple few months old. It got a pink line down the screen that comes and goes which if you press in one spot can usually make it go away but he is a business owner and he can't risk the screen going from line to not working for a day as a missed communication could cost him thousands. So he said here take it and he got a new one. Seems like this pink line is common and a defect in some screens. Anyways I wanted to say I also have a pixel 8 but with stock OS and my battery typically lasts a full day with average usage. My iPhone 8 previously even with a replacement battery was lucky if it lasted more then 5 hours. I had to charge that thing multiple times a day.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
I have a Pixel 8 running GrapheneOS and it does most of the above: - slightly lesser build quality than my iPhone 15 Pro but comparable - doesn't funnel data to Google unless you explicitly let it, you can circumvent a lot of the Google Play stuff by restricting permissions and using Aurora Store - is backed by, well, Google and the Graphene team porting over security updated. They have a fairly good track record by now. - can use any of the N backup services that already exist unlike the iPhone's silly restriction on background apps - don't notice performance differences between it and my iPhone 15 Pro in day to day use. If anything, biometrics are way faster on the Pixel since iOS 26 made FaceID slow as molasses for me - the default camera is pretty good (uses all the Pixel fancy processing hardware) but if it's not good enough you can just install the stock Google camera which works fine. You can turn off network access if you don't want it snooping. Photos are neck and neck with the iPhone but the iPhone is way better at videos, no Android phone has cracked that yet IMO. - Yeah, but no other brand can give you an AppleCare experience. Best option is phone insurance and just getting a new Pixel if that happens. Graphene can do full device backups via Seedvault and it's not that much more of a pain to restore compared to an iPhone backup. Granted, it's jankier but it's not impossible. The other issue is that Pixels are not a thing in a lot of countries, Apple really…
Apple iPhone: NeutralGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
I had a two phone lifestyle as well for different reasons: I needed car play but don't like iOS, and also needed to know Android and iOS quite well for my job. One iPhone that was wifi only, had my entire music library local, used for car play and a few exclusive apps. One android with a sim that had my communication apps, social media, and some custom tinkering stuff that doesn't exist on iOS. I did this for about two years. The main takeaways: -I 100% could have just had the iPhone with a sim for communication apps and been fine. The social media was just annoying enough to swap to that I never felt that draw and barely used it on 2phones. -even though I despise how little customization iOS lets you do, without social media or game apps, the only actual pain point with it was the nightmare of managing notifications/alert/vibration/screen wake settings* -god it made me miss small phones so much. The android was a pixel 4a, the last real phone with real hardware that released at the actual ideal size for my hands(that has an unlocked bootloader, I really can't do the Samsung hellOS experience again). Now Im on a pixel 8 only, with Glider for this site and no other social media or games. It's fine. Phones too big, car doesn't have AAuto, and Google is trying to rot the foundation of android, but for now it's fine and better than the two phone experience because it's less juggling.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
I'm still salty about my Pixel 8 dying out because of the "green screen" bug (basically, screen just progressively turns greener until it stops working). Very common according to reddit, and the ubreakitifixit guy acknowledged it's a common problem as well. My Pixel 5a also had some shenanigans and my dad's pixel 6 as well No idea why they don't do proper Q&A. Looks like a good phone but yet fails in ways my work iphone never has.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
And they have been rather uncompetitive lately. Nowadays, the only thing they do better than others is their own silicon but since it's not that relevant for phones anymore they need to do better. The worst is that because of greed they find a way to purposefully limit the phone usefulness to artificially force higher price poing (RAM/storage). Just as an example, you gotta be really into the ecosystem to choose an iPhone 15 over a Pixel 8. But I think most stick with Apple because it is complicated to switch and all the software "investment" is lost. Previously as an Apple "believer" I was against cross-platform apps but now I feel like a transferable licence is almost a requirement. It is very worth the small performance cost.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 8: Likes it
Boo. I was delighted by its introduction in pixel 8. I thought this was a resurgence of the old Google, actually giving a f about software, security and the end user. iPhone 17 has it now. maybe Google's work here is done https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/1ndcrug/iphone_17_in...
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 8: Doesn’t like it
That was my experience with a back fingerprint reader. I reach my hand into my pocket, my finger naturally lands on the sensor, and my phone is unlocked before it's out! I rarely saw my lockscreen But when I switched to the pixel 8 with a front reader I always saw it Now on my iPhone I see it frequently and it doesn't land when wearing a mask, when I'm talking, when I'm not looking (I could blind navigate my phone), or when it's just dark. So it just feels painfully slow in comparison... Nothing has beaten the magical experience of a back fingerprint reader and I think this is why so many of us miss it. But I'm sure it's one of those things you'd have had to use to really feel the magic It doesn't have to be for everyone but there's enough phones that the option should be available...
Apple iPhone: NeutralGoogle Pixel 8: Neutral
It works with my iPhone 15 Pro. I do not see any visible light emitting from the remote. This is in a pitch dark room. Edit: proof, taken in a semi-lit room for clarity: https://imgur.com/a/63FbXjQ Edit 2: Tested on iPhone 15 Pro selfie camera. It detects IR at the same intensity. Edit 3: Same as above with a Pixel 8. Edit 4: I now have my office involved, this is fun. Same with a Samsung S24. Final Edit: OK, I just went through about 20 colleague's phones, which are various mixes of iPhone and Android, new and old. Testing the front and back camera, every camera on every phone saw the IR light. If a smartphone camera does not see IR light, this appears to be the exception, not the rule. OK, back to work! These are all US devices, in case that matters. We don't seem to have an agency that regulates light emissions from cell phones.