The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Google Pixel 5

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Google Pixel 5.

Apple iPhoneGoogle Pixel 5
Owners with an opinion4629145
Positive verdicts58% of 384265% of 125
Positive/negative since 20241115/93530/16
Happy after 3+ years2805
Longest happy owner23 yrs6 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forease of use and softwaresupport and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
As someone who recently switched from a Pixel 5 to an iPhone 15 Pro (bought purely for the camera as I'm travelling around Japan at the moment), I hate it. I'm going straight back to Android when I get back to the UK. I plugged it into my MBP expecting to be able to copy media over, but you can only copy it into the sandboxed filesystem of one app. So choose wisely. Downloading media using Plex etc sucks. As soon as the phone locks or you move to another app, it stops. On Pixel, I could queue up a load of downloads or SMB transfers, lock my phone on the side and expect them to be complete when I come back. As for a terminal or using it like a computer, fuhgeddaboutit. If anything I've said is wrong, please correct me. I want to like this phone, the camera is out of this world.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 5: Doesn’t like it
I was a Nexus/Pixel user for 10+ years. Majority of the phones I owned during that time had some quirks or issues. The worst examples were Nexus 5X and Pixel 5 – both just suddenly froze one day, shut down, and never turned back on again. After that Pixel 5 surprise I grudgingly switched to iPhone 12 mini. I still think Google’s Android UI is the best one out there for me, and I despise a lot in the iPhone UX (such as the keyboard) but I just need a phone that works and I can get repaired or replaced easily if I need to. At least in Finland, Google’s customer service has been abysmal over the years.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 5: Doesn’t like it
I owned a Pixel 2XL, best phone I've ever had. Had a 5 and a 6 Pro, was so fed up with the bugs I ended up jumping ship to an iPhone 14 Pro. It's refreshing to have my phone actually work. I don't need to worry about the battery draining, not having signal because the modem sucks or it getting hot enough to fry an egg because I'm trying to upload photos to the cloud.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
I used to have a Pixel 5 and loved it. Recently switched to an iPhone 14 Pro and... frankly it sucks. iOS UX is pretty bad, IMO, and the photos are subpar. Google's computational photography is much better and faster. Android keyboards are more powerful and lets you easily type punctuation. The notification system is way more customizable. Imessages doesn't filter spam. In fact there isn't even spam filtering built in like there is on the Pixel. You have to buy a separate app. I regret getting an iPhone... My partner has a Samsung and she's fine with it. But having their own photo and calendar apps makes things super confusing when you're trying to share with another Android user using the Google standard apps. If I were getting another Android, which I really wish I did, I wouldn't even consider anything but the Pixels...
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
The Pixels are a standout among the usual Android crapfest. Google has really good computational photography. The images are much better balanced, not oversaturated, much sharper, night mode is awesome, etc. Even with the 48 MP sensor I'm getting subpar results. Apple might have better hardware but their computational photography hasn't quite caught up yet. Here's a sample gallery (not mine) https://imgur.io/a/vG6Yskx I was expecting a major upgrade going from the Pixel 5 to the 14 Pro. It's actually a slight downgrade.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 5: Doesn’t like it
After using Android for 10 years, a similar experience made me switch. I'd just bought a Pixel 5, and I received a call from a pizza delivery driver. I say I received a call because the phone rang. Otherwise I'd never have known. The UI didn't show it at all, even though it was responsive, and the missed call log section never populated. Nothing except the ringer sound. The next day I switched to iPhone and have never regretted it. Like, if my phone can't receive calls or even capture that a call was missed, none of its other features matter.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
I switched to a Google Pixel 5 a year ago, and it's been my favorite phone I've ever owned since the original iPhone. Notification handling, input detection, call screen, the universal back gesture, USB C, and other small elements have made this phone vastly preferable to any iPhone I have ever owned. Android on Pixel is seriously incredible software that makes my phone just work, which is what I want after tinkering on computers all day. And yet I'm going back to iOS when the next iPhone launches due to iMessage. I hate it, and I don't want to. But the simple fact of the matter is, I have become somewhat of a social pariah in my circles with people constantly making remarks about how I break their group chats. People refuse to download a platform agnostic messaging app. Women have made judgements toward me, which does not help as a single man. I genuinely don't think anyone means to behave in such an elitist/condescending way because many of these people are those I know well and who I would consider great people. It's this bizarre tribalistic and subconscious pattern of behavior that the overwhelming majority of people around me in the social circles I engage with all exhibit. It all seems so dumb when everyone could download an app like Signal and be done with this, and it feels extra annoying that I'm supporting Apple by buying their phone that is expensive, and in my opinion, has worse software despite the fact that they have created this issue entirely. Yet it's not a h…
Apple iPhone: NeutralGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
I’m a long-time small phone Android user. But after the Pixel 5, I have not been able to find a suitable small Android replacement. The Pixel 6 is gigantic, and the Pixel 7 looks like it is also destined to be huge. It’s gotten so bad that I’ve resorted to using an iPhone Mini, biding my time and hoping desperately that some Android OEM would step up. But it’s increasingly clear that a small premium phone is not on the roadmap. So I’ve decided to take matters into my own hands. My goal with https://smallandroidphone.com is to rally other fans of small phones together and put pressure on Google/Samsung/Anyone to consider making a small phone. I have a very specific set of skills and industry connections that I have acquired over a long career in the hardware business (my first startup was Pebble). I will put them to use in our shared quest to get the perfect small Android phone. If no one else builds one, and enough people sign up...maybe I will be forced to make it myself. If you want a small premium Android phone, this may be your last chance (ever?) to help bring back the phone category that we love.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
Not sure about iPads, but going from a pixel 3 to a pixel 5 made me feel like my pixel 3 was broken. Xr to 16 pro was similar, but that is because Xr was legit broken.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
for me even pixel 5 was ok (mini is even better but let's say apple is another story). Now we have only zenfone 10, that is a bit taller so again not that nice and s23 that is +- the size of p5 but still something felt off. Iphone 13 mini was super nice to hold, super light. I would have got one if not lightning. All my devices use usb-c, it would be a downgrade to use lightning
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 5: Likes it
I owned the iPhone 12 mini and thought it was a great phone - I was able to one hand it quite easy and the hardware specs were more than sufficient. My partner now uses it but she would prefer a slightly larger screen I think. I moved to a Pixel 5 and think it is currently one of the best smaller phones - For most stuff I can one hand this phone too, and in some ways the ergonomics of the Pixel are better. For instance the back side finger print scanner unlock is the best I've ever used. I used to want to keep my aux port, but the bluetooth audio industry has really stepped up in recent years - I still just use my airpod pros and probably will continue too