The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Google Pixel 3a

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple iPhone.

Apple iPhoneGoogle Pixel 3a
Owners with an opinion462982
Positive verdicts58% of 384259% of 56
Positive/negative since 20241115/93515/6
Happy after 3+ years2804
Longest happy owner23 yrs4 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forease of use and softwaresupport and durability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 3a: Neutral
> Why would i want half assed google walled garden when I could get the Apple one? Can’t disagree more. Android has both better phones and better UX. Apple is usually lagging the Asian brands by years. I went from a Pixel 3A to an iPhone 13 and just switched back to a Pixel 10 Pro and gosh the iPhone was a complete wreck. It’s even worse with their new UI. Unless you are somehow stuck in the Apple ecosystem, I don’t understand why people pay more for it. The idea than the Android experience is somehow subpar when all Apple has done for the past five years is merely copying it is crazy to me.
Apple iPhone: NeutralGoogle Pixel 3a: Likes it
I have both and they're surprisingly essentially the same size. Except the iPhone has less bezel and is thicker. I only have the iPhone for dev purposes and I actually prefer the Pixel 3a, but I'm afraid it might die soon... Anyways, are you sure you're talking about the iPhone 16?
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 3a: Neutral
I switched from a Pixel 3a to an iPhone 16 and it really bothers me that it's way too huge for everyday usage. Maybe I have extremely short thumbs but here's the maximum reach I have on the screen when I hold my phone "normally" in my hand: https://i.postimg.cc/Cx97jxLZ/iphone16reach.png - I can't reach the upper part of the screen at all, without doing finger-gymnastics or using my other hand. I'd love to switch to a phone that is 50-60%% of the size of the iPhone 16 but there are essentially no (modern) options for this. It's really a bummer :(
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 3a: Doesn’t like it
I recently switched from android to the iphone ecosystem; I had a 3a and then a 4a, and recently updated to a 7a, but it never really clicked with me -- just too big. Got a 13 mini; I kinda don't like a bunch of aspects of the iphone ecosystem, but the mini form factor is really perfect. Very much too bad that it's now dead.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 3a: Doesn’t like it
> I've owned many of the nexus and pixel phones, never had a problem. I've had 2 Nexus 5x and a Pixel 3a before switching to an iPhone. I can't believe the amount of bullshit I coped up with because I didn't know better. Both Nexus died because of a well known boot loop issue that was never truly acknowledged by Google (support ghosted me twice). The Pixel died because the socket kinda broke and I couldn't charge it anymore. All 3 phones became awfully slow after roughly one year of use. In comparison I switched to an iPhone 2 years ago and it really is good as new: it doesn't feel slower, every single hardware or software feature works great, it's still a first class citizen when it comes to OS updates. As it goes I easily plan to keep it at least 2 to 3 more years. I've never kept an Android phone more than 2 years. To be fair though the Nexus and Pixel were low end devices. Maybe my experience would have been better with higher end Androids.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 3a: Doesn’t like it
You know I totally agree with you on Gnome being superior. Heck, my preferred WM is DWM and I would use it every day if I could. But here I am, on a Mac, just because I just CANNOT deal with another hardware related issue again. I used desktop linux most of my life (ages 12-28). But with a job and a family, I just don't have time for a single second of down time or debugging my computer. Same for android vs iOS. Used Android for 10 years, switched to iOS. Tried to go back with Pixel 3a, and it would freeze up maybe once a month. That's too much for me. My iPhone has frozen up maybe once in 2 years. Before you judge me, I do extensive infra shit at work and fix broken systems all the time. I just cannot deal with it on my personal devices.
Apple iPhone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel 3a: Neutral
I would buy this if it was dual SIM (nano+eSIM) but honestly iPhone 13 mini is still too big for my taste. No wider than iPhone 4 would be ideal for me. Fine if it's thicker to fit a decent battery. I'm currently using a Pixel 3a with multiple cracks in the screen. Willing to drop a lot of money on a phone but there isn't a single phone I want.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 3a: Doesn’t like it
iPhone convert for the small form factor here, too. I had Android since the Galaxy S1, but in 2018 switched to the iPhone 8 as there was just no decent SFF android device. I considered the Pixel 3a, and I am glad that I didn't go for it as it dropped out of support and no longer receives security updates, while I'm today still on my fully supported and updated iPhone 8. Next phone will be one of the iPhone SE series.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 3a: Neutral
Google has a support page that lists the planned obsolescence dates for all Pixep phones: https://support.google.com/pixelphone/answer/4457705 My Pixel 3a is going to stop receiving security updates this May. It’s still a perfectly good phone despite the increasing slowdowns with every system or Play Service update. I’ve learned my lesson and switched to iPhone as my next main phone, and relegated the Pixel to serve as a backup.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 3a: Doesn’t like it
Meanwhile the original iPhone SE from 2016 can boot the latest iOS. And you can get a battery replacement from Apple right at the store, same day for... 49$! It just works. In just 4 months the Pixel 3A is officially getting EoL'd. This phone was released in 2019 (fall), same time as the iPhone 11. It just shows the wide gap between iOS and Android. > Apparently Qualcomm asks for a ridiculous amount of money to support any chip beyond a measly 2-3 years. Apple gets away with it by building their own chips I can believe it. Qualcomm makes money per chip sold, Apple makes money by building an ecosystem. Linux support is a cost center for Qualcomm past the initial launch kernel, and we can only imagine there's a difference in caliber between the engineers writing patches and hacks around the kernel at Qualcomm vs building the OS that powers the iPhone.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 3a: Likes it
I like to get a nice laptop and phone because I spend so much time on them. An iPhone is worth it for me, as I like a predictably good camera. Before I went iPhone, I had a Pixel 3a, and it took perfectly fine pictures. I just like the iPhone cameras more, although I’m starting to get a little jealous of the better zoom capabilities on some Samsung phone cameras I’ve seen recently. Lately I’ve been upgrading every two years, but every three would also be fine.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Pixel 3a: Likes it
It hasn't been relevant for years. It mattered when it doubled the speed but I can use a 6S even today and not care to upgrade. I can use a Pixel 3a and not care to upgrade. Nobody buys the new iPhone because the SOC uses 20mAh less and is 13% faster and 300% faster in some irrelevant benchmark. Camera quality, and bad battery life from old phone seem to be why normal people upgrade, brand and design occasionally too.