The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs Google Nexus 5X

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple iPhone.

Apple iPhoneGoogle Nexus 5X
Owners with an opinion462923
Positive verdicts58% of 384230% of 23
Positive/negative since 20241115/9352/3
Happy after 3+ years2800
Longest happy owner23 yrs–
Praised forreliability and performancedisplay and value
Criticized forease of use and softwarereliability and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like it
I was a Nexus/Pixel user for 10+ years. Majority of the phones I owned during that time had some quirks or issues. The worst examples were Nexus 5X and Pixel 5 – both just suddenly froze one day, shut down, and never turned back on again. After that Pixel 5 surprise I grudgingly switched to iPhone 12 mini. I still think Google’s Android UI is the best one out there for me, and I despise a lot in the iPhone UX (such as the keyboard) but I just need a phone that works and I can get repaired or replaced easily if I need to. At least in Finland, Google’s customer service has been abysmal over the years.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like it
Yes wow, because it’s not the norm. Before I switched to an iPhone, I needed to change my Android phone every 2 years or so (sometimes less) because they became completely unusable, from hardware issues (broken connectors) to software issues (I had 2 Nexus 5x that died because of a bootloop issue, unacknowledged by Google). Android also becomes extremely slow pretty quickly for some reason. For comparison I’ve had my iPhone 12 for 3,5 years and it shows no sign of slowness or battery issues or whatever, and I intend to keep it for at least 1 or 2 more years. When OP say it stays functional for several years, they mean it stays as functional as the first day for several years, with no degradation.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like it
iPhone 6s (released September 2015) - ~ 8 years and going Nexus 5X & Nexus 6P (released September 2015) - last update January 2019 [1] ~ 2.25 years Pixel & Pixel XL (released October 2016) - 2019 (can't find a good reference) ~ 3 years Pixel 2 (released October 2017) - December 2020 [2] ~ 3.3 years [1]: https://9to5google.com/2018/11/07/nexus-6p-and-5x-final-guar... [2]: https://www.androidpolice.com/2020/10/05/pixel-2-and-2-xl-re... My conclusion: an iPhone outlives (at least) 2+/3+ android phones
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like it
> I've owned many of the nexus and pixel phones, never had a problem. I've had 2 Nexus 5x and a Pixel 3a before switching to an iPhone. I can't believe the amount of bullshit I coped up with because I didn't know better. Both Nexus died because of a well known boot loop issue that was never truly acknowledged by Google (support ghosted me twice). The Pixel died because the socket kinda broke and I couldn't charge it anymore. All 3 phones became awfully slow after roughly one year of use. In comparison I switched to an iPhone 2 years ago and it really is good as new: it doesn't feel slower, every single hardware or software feature works great, it's still a first class citizen when it comes to OS updates. As it goes I easily plan to keep it at least 2 to 3 more years. I've never kept an Android phone more than 2 years. To be fair though the Nexus and Pixel were low end devices. Maybe my experience would have been better with higher end Androids.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like it
Very similar to me, I went nexus 5 > 5x > pixel > pixel 2 after the 5/5x/p1 broke in different ways, but the Pixel 2 I used until it ran out of support and I was annoyed at having to replace a phone so quickly because it was fine for me, so I switched to a second hand iphone XS and it still works fine even though it's only 1 year older. I doubt I'll ever buy an iPhone brand new (I go out of my way not to support the CCP) but until Pinephone and linux becomes a usable mobile OS I'll stick with the XS until it either dies or Apple stop supporting it in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_iOS_and_iPadOS_devices 4 years or so? The iphone 6s was released in 2015 and it's still getting support, that's incredible.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like it
My 5X died in my pocket before a year of usage. Just died and wouldn't turn on. I called support and they said to ship it out, and I would have a new one in about a week. Never mind 1) phones shouldn't just randomly die, and 2) a week without a phone??? Switched to iPhone and never looked back.
Apple iPhone: Likes itGoogle Nexus 5X: Doesn’t like it
I get this, but honestly it's more important for me to have a phone that works... I can deal with inexplicable software changes, I make some of my own. At one point I had the same iPhone for 4 years. When I tried Android I couldn't get the same device to stick around for more than a year. After my 5X bootloop fiasco I tried another manufacturer and found out I couldn't even upgrade my software to patch a security issue because I had to wait on the vendor to add their crapware before releasing the update. I waited 6 months after Google released their update and then gave up... I don't know how Android users deal with the update nonsense.