The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone vs BlackBerry Bold

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple iPhoneBlackBerry Bold
Owners with an opinion462921
Positive verdicts58% of 384295% of 20
Positive/negative since 20241115/9357/1
Happy after 3+ years2801
Longest happy owner23 yrs15 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancedesign and ergonomics
Criticized forease of use and softwareease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone: Likes itBlackBerry Bold: Neutral
The Blackberry Bold 9000 is the greatest handheld cellular device of all time. It's perfect. The Bold 2 was the last Blackberry device I owned and used as a actual phone before they started leaning into the black bar monolith. At that point the 'your holding it wrong' iPhone 4 was just better in that area. The perfect form factor however is the Blackberry Passport which I now own as a little Cyberdeck device (managed to get a version running Android). The combination of touchscreen, keyboard swipe mouse cursor and physical keyboard is what every phone should be.
Apple iPhone: Likes itBlackBerry Bold: Doesn’t like it
Back in 2010 I had an iPhone 3GS and a Blackberry Bold. I really wanted to justify using the Bold because of the professional image I associated with it. In repeated typing speed tests, I found my WPM to be essentially the same between the two. Every other aspect of the iPhone user experience was vastly better. I kept the iPhone and never looked back to phones with keyboards.
Apple iPhone: Likes itBlackBerry Bold: Doesn’t like it
And that phone came out around the same time as the iPhone 4S which was almost the same size, well over double the resolution, and ~30g heavier. By that point form factor didn’t really matter. Capabilities did and that screen sucked, web browsing on BB sucked compared to iPhone, and apps were way better (in some cases no equivalent existed on BB) on iPhone. I was specifically talking about devices that came before the iPhone and how the iPhone was marked improvement over them. However comparing phones that launched at the same time as the 9790 still show the iPhone being far superior unless you weight the physical keyboard much higher than other features.
Apple iPhone: Likes itBlackBerry Bold: Likes it
I have a lot of Blackberry nostalgia; I was 23 in NYC, 2007ish, and my work-issued BB Curve (later a Bold) plus my personal original iPhone were a combination that I was so happy with. The Blackberry could tether to my early MacBook pro in the remotest of locations, and I could easily SSH into the (real) servers I ran. Never used BBM but played Bricks for hours and hours. I wasn’t nearly as satisfied with an iPhone-only solution until 2017 or so.