The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone SE vs Samsung Galaxy S

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple iPhone SESamsung Galaxy S
Owners with an opinion355449
Positive verdicts74% of 29563% of 368
Positive/negative since 2024129/49107/71
Happy after 3+ years2242
Longest happy owner9 yrs12 yrs
Praised forperformance and ease of useperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitysoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone SE: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Neutral
Earlier this year I downgraded my S24 ultra to an iphone 13 mini and then to the first gen iphone SE. I replaced the battery myself on the SE and couldn't be happier. Less screen time and more IRL time. People should just use less of their phones and for battery longevity they should not let their phones go daily below 20%. No one on this planet should use their phone more than 2 hours per day. Period. More is just plain stupid.
Apple iPhone SE: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
> but iPhone’s really aren’t more expensive than androids, per year. > The 5g SE (2022) is $429 iPhone absolutely are more expensive than any other phone if you care about things other than the CPU/GPU performance. The 5g SE has a tiny screen with archaic bezel design and still uses LCDs in an era where not giving you an OLED would be seen as a ripoff on the android market. It starts at 64gb of storage for this $429 (in France, it's actually 529 euros), my S20FE from a couple years ago which I bought at 400 euros on deals had 128gb. It has a very big, 120hz OLED screen and the finger print sensor works from underneath the screen. For me, and many others, the phone is primarily a content consumption device. If the CPU is good enough that I don't see stutters all the time then it's good enough. I don't need my smartphone to be a laptop in the pocket. I do need a screen that I enjoy looking at and big enough that I can use it to read ebooks. This in turns is heavily reflected in how many Apple users will splurge the big bucks to get the iPhone models that are comfortable to use despite their insane prices. Right now, the cheapest phone Apple produces with a large screen is the iPhone 14 Plus at 969 euros. There's a reason why the iPhone SE is the least popular of all Apple phones despite having far-more-than-good-enough hardware performance and longevity while being accessibly priced: it lacks what people actually wants out of their phone, Apple knows that and they keep the SE
Apple iPhone SE: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
I 100% agree about the hardware but I have to say the selling point of apple is the OS. I have an iPhone SE 2020 and the screen broke. This caused me to use my QA device (Samsung S21+) while I returned to the city from the mountains. It was a horrendous experience. The camera is unquestionably better in the Samsung but that is about all the positives I could take from my week of using it. Android was just an abysmal experience from my perspective. Nothing on it seems intuitive and everything feels like a ploy to get you to use a product which will siphon your data off to Google. Obviously this is just my own personal anecdotal experience so take it with a pinch of salt. But there will no doubt be others feeling the same. I miss my old 3310 if I am honest. I’ve been looking at dumb phones recently. I just need one with WhatApp so I can talk to my family around the world ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Apple iPhone SE: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
Same here. I've benefited from hand me down devices for a long time, and I wish I could still be using the Samsung S3- so light, I have several spare batteries, it fit in most pockets, and it has a 3.5mm headphone jack. The iPhone SE from 2015 that recently I gave to one of my parents was nice, too. My laptop is also from more than a decade ago, and I'm happily running LMDE 6 on it.
Apple iPhone SE: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
I was trying to take a passport photo, and one of the requirements is "has not been touched up". But when I took the photo with my phone, I noticed that it had been very helpful in touching up my face by removing almost all of my wrinkles and made my skin nice and soft. Even with all "enhancements" off. This was on an Samsung S10, I tried with an iPhone SE, it was slightly less visibly touched up, so I used that, but still definitely had a "beauty" filter built in. It's probably implemented in ASIC so you basically can't turn it fully off.
Apple iPhone SE: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
I disagree, I repaired in the past my old iphone se cheaply (replacing battery) or samsung sg2 (broken usb) and sg4 (broken camera). I could buy components either locally or cheap from aliexpress. In south east asia many wizards can even fix your macbook and even upgrade ram, ssd as a bonus. Repair can be cheap in the same way as car repair can be cheap. Currently iphone repair cannot be cheap because of their DRM. You mentioned before that cheap repair cannot be done because of more expensive labour. But I mentioned that authorised repair shops quotes me ~300euro for repair and apple for just ordering single component wanna charge me ~280usd - it's obvious they just price component so expensive to make it not worth making repair yourself.