The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone 12 vs Apple iPhone 13

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple iPhone 12.

Apple iPhone 12Apple iPhone 13
Owners with an opinion163161
Positive verdicts64% of 14055% of 140
Positive/negative since 202447/2342/39
Happy after 3+ years85
Longest happy owner6 yrs5 yrs
Praised forreliability and performanceperformance and reliability
Criticized forbatteryease of use and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone 12: Likes itApple iPhone 13: Neutral
There are a few available at retailers. I just traded my iPhone 12 mini for a 13 mini for 0 cost at Verizon but my only color choices were pink or red. My 12 mini was working just fine but I had been considering a battery replacement. And besides being cheaper than a new battery a new model will hopefully hold out a bit longer.
Apple iPhone 12: Doesn’t like itApple iPhone 13: Doesn’t like it
They nailed it. Big horizontal dimensions so it’s hard to hold in one hand (yes, I realize that many users want this, but many users don’t want this), a big thick camera so it doesn’t actually fit well in slim pockets (but lots of young people seem to like their phone sticking out of their pocket?!), and super thin everywhere else so a high capacity battery doesn’t fit. Nice job! Seriously, Apple has not attempted a narrow high-end phone since the iPhone 5. The 12 and 13 minis were not positioned as premium phones and they did not have great cameras or battery life. If Apple had tried for a 13 Pro Mini and it didn’t sell, then maybe I’d believe that their market statistics were worth something.
Apple iPhone 12: NeutralApple iPhone 13: Neutral
I used almost all the recent iPhones except 14. 11 is heavy and no MagSafe thus its a hard pass, the camera is also super old; 12 is lighter but poor battery life, camera improved a lot; 13 has better battery life but weird camera optimizations despite they tried to improve the low light performance; 15 Pro is good except the low light spatial video capture is noisy; happy with 16 Pro now.
Apple iPhone 12: Likes itApple iPhone 13: Likes it
I'm going to keep using mine for as long as I can, and just hope that Apple releases another one by the time I need a new phone. "shitty components and artificially disabled hardware" is one way to look at it. I think "significantly smaller battery and scaled accordingly" is more accurate, personally. I'm an undemanding phone user. I take pictures, catch rides, use the map, take calls, listen to stuff. I don't hang out on my phone. So I want a phone that's as small as it reasonably can be, it fits more places and I notice it less. However, I also want the battery to last a full day. The only way I'm going to get that is if the phone is somewhat less powerful than a phone running the same OS and apps with a rather larger battery. This is a tradeoff I am comfortable with, and was able to figure out from first principles when getting the 12 mini (and now the 13). It's fine to want a phone which is small like the mini, as powerful as the base model, and which lasts just as long on a charge. But I don't see how any company could deliver that phone.
Apple iPhone 12: Recommends itApple iPhone 13: Recommends it
Personally I don’t think Apple’s level of support is incredibly bad when you take a look at the used device market. Even with Apple’s famously high resale values, depreciation on smartphones is huge. Don’t buy brand new old phones new from Apple, they’re a ripoff. If you buy either an iPhone 12 or 13 used for $250-350 you can basically plan on a $50 a year budget to have a smartphone that always has the latest OS judging by their expected remaining lifespans. I think the big flaw with the status quo is e-waste more than cost to the consumer. I think an iPhone 6S or 7 are incredibly slow and outdated devices for today’s usage but in 5 years I don’t think we will be able to say the same thing about an iPhone 12 or 13. Smartphone hardware is far more mature now than it was even 6 generations deep into the iPhone product line. We should be able to replace batteries for $20 and replace things like broken screens for not much more, and Apple should be enthusiastic about it considering how services are their bread and butter moving forward. Apple should be happy to produce fewer phones and keep more consumer dollars allocated toward the purchase of high margin digital goods.
Apple iPhone 12: Doesn’t like itApple iPhone 13: Doesn’t like it
The glass prior to iPhone 14 is UNREPAIRABLE as well. You are better off breaking the screen. The Apple repair process for iPhone 12 and 13 is to replace the entire chassis. Ebay sellers will sell you a replacement back glass but you have to painstakingly break off all the back glass including a sensitive microphone near the cameras and also the chances you don't break the wireless charging is zero. Polycarbonate plastic would have been ideal
Apple iPhone 12: Doesn’t like itApple iPhone 13: Doesn’t like it
> The improvements in camera, screen brightness, colors and many others strongly disagree with such claims. I've owned an X, a 12, a 13 (after the 12 got water damage), and have ordered the 15 (but not received it yet). With the caveat of not having used the 14 or 15 (but just looking at the specs on paper), I would have to agree with the comment you're responding to that all the changes since the X have essentially been incremental. Not only that, completely and consistently annoying UI bugs such as the one where you accidentally tap a notification when you intended to tap a UI element at the top of the screen (which I blogged about way back when: https://medium.com/p/31773fe6bbd5 ) have not been fixed despite the fact that my solution (adding a small input "debounce" or timeout whenever the UI changes, where inputs are ignored) would likely solve this problem. (This problem has likely annoyed YOU, even if you haven't heard about it until now! More generally, it's also a problem with websites that let you accidentally click or fat-finger on elements while they're still re-rendering and shuffling around, which my post also includes.) Of course, that's a software problem... The hardware is largely exactly the same. There's still no way to TouchID through the screen (like Android has had for years... I absolutely cannot stand FaceID and just use an alphanumeric code to unlock with a long unlock time now), there's still no models with a foldable screen (again, like Android ha…
Apple iPhone 12: Doesn’t like itApple iPhone 13: Doesn’t like it
Only thing I really don't like about my 12 and 13 minis is face ID. It is SUCH a pain to always have to bring it in front of you, or turn your head, or whatnot. Yes, it works in the dark, mostly, and yes, it's "one less thing to do" but... if I'm grabbing my phone, I'm already holding it. Putting my thumb on a button to unlock so that it's already usable by the time I bring it to my eye level saves so much time. And... by pressing the button, I'm always 'back to the home screen' instead of whatever app I was on before, or 5 pages in. Thumb on touchID button I get a faster and more consistent unlocking experience.
Apple iPhone 12: Doesn’t like itApple iPhone 13: Doesn’t like it
Not shocking - between the "use icloud" nag screen when attaching photos in Messages and basic stuff not porting over with local backups instead of icloud (weather, health, stocks etc), this is another yet another customer-adverse step that substitutes montly sub for "just works". This past month I migrated from iphone 12 to 13 and it involved manually reloading/resetting virtually everything, despite making a local backup of the old phone. It would seem that the apple builtin apps specifically just don't restore without icloud - it's almost as if there's a product manager somewhere that's using icloud utilization in GB as their OKR benchmark, and that's one way to hit it. Apple discontinuing TimeCapsule and disbanding the team couple years back isn't lost on me either.