The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone 11 vs Google Pixel

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple iPhone 11.

Apple iPhone 11Google Pixel
Owners with an opinion1271968
Positive verdicts66% of 10956% of 1602
Positive/negative since 202435/21503/387
Happy after 3+ years1154
Longest happy owner6 yrs10 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forbatterysoftware and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone 11: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Thats your experience. I've had the complete opposite. A 4 year old iPhone that still felt as snappy as it did the day I broke it out of the box. Never had an android that felt like that after 6 months. And Apple have generations of devices that have gotten a full 7 years of support. We still havn't seen a generation of Android do that since Google changed their policy. I sincerely hope it does happen. Competition is better. But here is a site with some EOL info on Pixel. Pixel 6 support looks like it ends in 3 weeks with a grand total of about 5 years of support. https://endoflife.date/pixel Compare this with the iPhone 11 that came out in 2019 that will be able to run iOS27 (comes out next week) and the Pixel 6 that came out in 2021. And the original point was, "why iPhone over cheap android $200." Pixel 6 was a flagship phone with a launch price of $599. You could have gotten an iPhone 13 mini (release in 2021) and for an extra hundred bucks, been supported until at least 2028.
Apple iPhone 11: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
In September they're bringing the latest major iOS version to the iPhone 11 which released 7 years ago. And from what I've seen on the iPhone 11 subreddit, it improves performance. What other device manufacturer does that? The Google Pixel 4 released the same year dropped major OS updates after 3 years. Same for the Galaxy S10.
Apple iPhone 11: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
"when pigs fly"... Edit: I've owned almost 10 Google android devices: nexus 5, 6, 5x, pixel 1, 2, 3, 6 pro, and a couple tablets Of those, maybe 2 of them were stable after 2 years. Who cares if Google "promises OS updates" for 5 years if the updates are so unstable that the phone is unusable. Meanwhile, it's not uncommon for people to be using 3+ year old iphones with no complaints. My iphone 11 (~4 years old) feels much snappier than my pixel 6 pro (~2 years old).
Apple iPhone 11: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Maybe for teenagers. I have yet to meet anyone over the age of 16 who cares what color their "bubble" is. iMessage is good, but I would never pick my phone based on it. My work issued phone is an iPhone 11, which was released in 2019. It is running the latest version of iOS and it is still buttery smooth and a joy to use. The equivalent Android phones released in 2019 would be a Samsung Galaxy S10 (last update was to Android 12) or a Pixel 4 (last update was Android 13).
Apple iPhone 11: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
> Stop buying Apple if you don't like it. I personally don't like it and will not stop buying apple phones. The CPU's on an iPhone are far ahead of Android. I could buy either the Pixel 4 or the iPhone 11 for the same $450 price a month after launch from my carrier. single-thread geekbench: iPhone 11 (September 2019): 1311 Pixel 4 (October 2019): 662 Pixel 7 (October 2022): 1058 The geekbench for the Pixel 7 is 1051 single thread... still slower than my three year old phone. Android needs to have better CPU's for me to consider it.
Apple iPhone 11: Recommends itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
I thought so too, but then I got a cheap return iphone and was blown away. I now help all my friends buy cheap iphones for about $150/phone. They are either openbox or refurbished by apple, still under apple warranty. Currently iphone 11 64gb is that sweet spot. Cpu is still faster than most modern androids. Nvme ssd doesn't wear out as cheap emmc on androids. Phone receives way better software tuning than any android because apple iterates slower. And best part: phone can be serviced on the cheap in almost any mall in the world. Everyone got spare screens, batteries,cases sell in dollar store. I get Latest ios releases. I was using pixels before and when they broke, esp during travel, it was a very uneconomical proposition. Only thing I miss is termux and gcam.
Apple iPhone 11: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
I don't know why you're being downvoted. They most certainly have had historically poor build quality. My Pixel 2 began boot looping after a couple of years of use and apparently that was motherboard quality issue that had been around since the Nexus line. I got a replacement and it happened again after another few months. Google "Pixel 2 bootloop" and you'll find thousands of threads from people with this issue. That was around four years ago. I switched to an iPhone 11 and have had a fraction of the problems that I had with Android phones.
Apple iPhone 11: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
So, I just switched from Android to iOS, and I've noticed that the bluetooth reliability is significantly worse than what I've become used to. I switch from a Pixel 4a to an iPhone 11, and both my Bose QC 35 headphones and Sony wireless earbuds are having lots of issue that I never head on the pixel. So, my takeaway is that iOS is behind here, though I don't know enough about the underlying tech to say anything for sure. Just my anecdotal experience...
Apple iPhone 11: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
I can't disagree that Brand Prestige is a big part of their marketing and branding. I used Android phones and linux or MS operating systems on PCs exclusively for my entire life, until the last 2 years or so. I was also quite zealously anti-Apple and anti-Apple-fanboy, and I considered their 1984 ad to be incredibly ironic. Once the fifth android device in a row bricked on me I made a decision to try an iPhone 11. I couldn't be happier. It just worked, never crashed, and certainly didn't brick during the time I used it, just under 2 years. I recently upgraded to an iPhone 13 and am still thrilled with it. I never had an Android phone that lasted longer than a year before issues started to surface, and I never had one make it 2 years ever. The performance of the iPhone made the take the plunge to try a MacBook Pro for my personal use. Couldn't be happier with that, either: it offers a linux-like experience on the command line, and provides a mostly great UI (I don't care for Finder--but I haven't any other real complaints). Edit: my Android phone purchases were top-of-the-line models: Nexus and Pixel phones purchased off Google directly.
Apple iPhone 11: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
What "modern smartphone" cannot "play music smoothly"? If you mean, "can't stream smoothly" - check your connection and your service choice (eg Paramount+ always seems to have problems for me ... regardless of the connection or device) But "play music smoothly" has been a core feature (with nary a problem) since the first iPhone Every one I have had runs all the audio I have ever wanted to run with no issue - 4G, 6S+, 8+, 11, SE, 14, and 15 My dad's and mother-in-law's Pixel 7 also have no issues
Apple iPhone 11: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
I agree with your comment. The camera was really impressive and it was first nexus phone where the camera outperformed an iPhone. But I think the video quality wasn’t that great when compared to iPhone. Mine started shutting down prematurely in Canadian winter after more than a year of use. But Google replaced mine for free even after the 1yr warranty expired. Ended up with Pixel 2 which had even better camera than Nexus 6P. The first iPhone to outperform Pixel 2 for low light was the iPhone 11. But during those times the video quality really sucked on both Nexus and Pixel, which it still does to the day.