The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad vs Samsung Galaxy Tab

Hacker News owners lean toward the Samsung Galaxy Tab.

Apple iPadSamsung Galaxy Tab
Owners with an opinion152560
Positive verdicts59% of 124573% of 48
Positive/negative since 2024320/25919/8
Happy after 3+ years614
Longest happy owner15 yrs7 yrs
Praised forease of use and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forsoftwarereliability and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy Tab: Neutral
I just bought a Galaxy Tab S8 after continually being disappointed with the iPad and lack of user-friendly multi-tasking capability. I was disappointed to find that Firefox's tablet interface is just a blown-up phone interface. I have switched to using Edge instead because it looks like a proper desktop browser with a tab bar, and has integrated ad-blocking. For me, the two biggest pain points I experience with Firefox is the lack of PWA support on desktop, and now the lack of a proper tablet interface. So I end up using Chrome/Edge on desktop for PWAs, and now I use Edge on tablet. It's getting harder to stick with Firefox...
Apple iPad: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy Tab: Likes it
I bought a Galaxy Tab S6 Lite last year and I prefer it over my iPad Air. I actually think the iPad has horrible usability. My only recourse is a friend who is an Apple Fanboy and can give me hints like "you can search for apps by swiping with your finger up (or down, can never remember) from the middle of the screen". Before that, I was unable to discover apps I was sure I had installed. Also every iOS app seems to have its own approach to navigation, as iOS doesn't have universal back and home buttons like Android. Unfortunately Android is also copying more and more of the Apple approch and introduces undiscoverable gestures. I personally hate gestures with a passion. But to each their own. Where Apple my score big time is with longterm support (security updates). Ultimately you have mostly the same apps on both platforms.
Switched from the Apple iPad to the Samsung Galaxy TabSamsung Galaxy Tab: Neutral
My take is that tablets are underrated, however I'd like to see more 'higher end' applications aimed at at 'lower end' tablets. For me the magic of tablets is that they are low cost, so I'm not afraid of losing or breaking them. They don't become a nexus of further expensive consumption: adding an expensive case, particularly one with a an expensive and special purpose keyboard, just takes something sleek and easy to handle and makes it klunky and awkward. Go to a hackathon? Get any Bluetooth keyboard and mouse and a $5 plastic clip from Amazon Basics and you've got something sleeker and more stylish than any Macbook or gaming laptop with which you can connect to a powerful desktop computer or a cloud instance that is anywhere from 50 cents to $4 an hour depending on your thirst for power. I started out with a B&N Nook, then Amazon Fire Tablets (amazing value for the money), then iPads, I had bad luck with my last iPad (either lost or stolen) and figured I'd use an old Samsung Galaxy tablet I had kicking around. Every time I got an iPad I looked at my options, hypothetically I thought I might like the Pro but a new Pro is crazy expensive (I couldn't afford to break or lose it) and an old Pro in my price range is old technology. (Note I'm a little weird because I've never owned a smartphone with a plan. Carriers choose not to serve my valley, why should I get an expensive plan? My data plan is WiFi, and my phone plan is Skype) The Pro, like the AVP, also seems…
Switched from the Apple iPad to the Samsung Galaxy TabSamsung Galaxy Tab: Likes it
Tachiyomi makes Android significantly better for comics/manga than iOS. It's one of the reasons I sold my iPad for a galaxy tab s7+. Every alternative I tried on iOS was just shit in comparison, paperback especially.
Switched from the Apple iPad to the Samsung Galaxy TabSamsung Galaxy Tab: Likes it
Wonder who downvotes this. The sole reason why I chose samsung tab over iPad is that iPad is essentially useless as a shared family device - the UX of switching accounts inside apps is just terrible. Tablet should definitely be a multiuser device and it's kinda stupid that Apple actually has multiple accounts functionality, but it only works for school or enterprise.