The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad vs reMarkable

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple iPad.

Apple iPadreMarkable
Owners with an opinion1525475
Positive verdicts59% of 124560% of 383
Positive/negative since 2024320/259101/101
Happy after 3+ years616
Longest happy owner15 yrs6 yrs
Praised forease of use and performanceease of use and display
Criticized forsoftwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I don’t use a remarkable but use an ipad and stylus for note taking a lot, so can totally get why people like remarkable even though I what I do is better for me[1]. The reasons for me: 1) I had a ton of paper notes, looking back, curating, finding old things etc is really hard. 2) An electronic device gives you the ability to cut and paste, move things around on the page, resize stuff, drop in screenshots (so I often screenshot a page of something I’m reading, drop it into a note and annotate it or make my notes about it all around the original) and (best of all) infinite erase with no skank left behind on the page and no surrounding myself with tiny little bits of eraser to clean up. 3) I have all my notes with me on my device even ones I made years ago vs in my study I have box folders and notebooks full of notes filling cabinet after cabinet, I couldn’t possibly carry all that around with me. 1 and 3 are nice, 2 is the killer app. Once I made the switch I find it painfully limiting to go back to having to make notes on paper. [1] My system in case people are interested is Notability and a paperlike screen protector. It is fantastic. All notes back up automatically as pdfs in box (which I then copy to my linux laptop) and I can search them using AI just fine even though I’m writing equations and my handwriting is god-awful. The notes are all pdf so if notability gets bought out and becomes terrible I just drop it like a hot potato and move on to something else no loss of…
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
My handwriting is roughly legible on paper (but getting worse). It is the same on an iPad+pencil with a Paperlike screen cover. It was impossible to read on my Remarkable 2 - the resolution just isn’t there for me. I think it’s important to have that friction between the stylus and the screen. And if you have that, I am pretty happy with notes on either my iPad or paper.
Apple iPad: Doesn’t like itreMarkable: Neutral
I've got one coming my way hopefully in next 2 months.. I kind of see it similarly to this review - a new category of device and not quite a 1-1 replacement of anything I have. I have reluctantly owned Kindles & iPads since v1 of each, and don't particularly like either. For me the iPad is always the 2nd (or 3rd) best device - if I'm seated indoors at a table or sofa, a MacBook is better.. if I'm on the go, a big iPhone is better.. if I am doing book length reading, a kindle is better. I can go a week or three without picking up my iPad. I find the OS annoyingly close to being a proper mini MacOS that never quite gets close enough in terms of multitasking/etc. It almost would be better by not trying to do so many things. That said I find Kindles to be the worst tech product I regularly use, hands down. It's good for reading books in bed, thats basically it. But its so much better at that, I use it daily. All the notetaking/highlighting/sharing functionality is garbage. Attempts to download/purchase more books on it are clunky enough I just wait til I'm back at phone/desktop. It also has the most bizarre ad targeting showing me content I would never read despite having nearly 20 years of my reading history. I've even tried the Remarkable (v1) for a couple years as a work note-taking device. So I'm hoping the Daylight solves the "3rd device" issue a bit better, but tbd. Light computing, mostly for reading, plus some light note taking, touch & keyboard, better battery lif…
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I’m currently doing a Masters in Computer Engineering, struggling through a lot of calculus and linear algebra. I have a Remarkable 2 for notes and working on math problem set homework to hand in as PDFs. It’s fine. It doesn’t do anything other than record your handwriting. You can try and have it convert it to text, this works for language but fails utterly at math. I got the better pen that you can turn around to use as an eraser as using the UI to change the tool from pen to eraser and back is incredibly annoying. I recently got an iPad to use instead mostly because I wanted one anyway, and because my handwriting is atrocious and iOS 18 pretties it up. I haven’t quite made up my mind on which one I’ll continue using. The iPad and its pen are more responsive, the fact that it improves my handwriting is a boon for the TAs, and solving some of the simpler math automatically is neat. The built in Notes app is garbage for handing in multi-page PDFs, bafflingly this is impossible, but the Goodnotes app is cheap and rather good. There’s other apps to convert handwritten math into Latex. The Remarkable produces much smaller file sizes (I’m not sure why I care, the web app I upload homework to sure doesn’t) and the battery lasts much longer. I find replacing the pen tips very annoying and have no idea why that is needed. I’ll probably end up using the iPad more, but I’ll guess I’ll see.
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
The main issue I had with my Remarkable 1 was that I couldn't quickly scroll through pages of e-books. If I was looking for something specific in the pages, an ipad allows me to swipe across rapidly. Remarkable was this tedious repeated button press, waiting each time for the screen to refresh. Had to go back to ipad although I loved the device.
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I bought and returned a Remarkable 2. I primarily wanted it for note taking but I found it actually felt worse to write on than the iPad with Apple Pencil and a matte screen protector. The iPad is also much more responsive and versatile when taking notes, e.g. better shape recognition, pressure sensitivity and palm rejection. As others have mentioned the Remarkable software is very limiting too in terms of reading, annotating and sharing documents. EDIT: one more complaint - the remarkable pencil nibs wear away very fast. They give you spares but they didn't last long.
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I had a remarkable and sold it for an iPad. Not only is the writing experience better, but the integration with my Mac is better. So for the same price it’s a much more versatile device. For example I write a note, I can incorporate PDFs/images, voice memos and other media. Then I can see all this stuff in my Mac. I can save websites and write on them. Nothing the remarkable can do. Also I don’t have to pay yearly to keep my notes synced.
Apple iPad: NeutralreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
Beat me to it. That was a dealbreaker for me. I got a couple of Rocketbook notebooks for when I want something that really feels like paper, plus an iPad for the large-screen computing bits. Pity, because I love the idea of the Remarkable and would strongly consider it were it not for the subscription.
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
Shocking to hear because it can’t even do OCR so you can search your own notes. So, you flip through page by page to find your notes? I’d rather buy an iPad for GoodNotes which lets you search your hand written notes
Apple iPad: Doesn’t like itreMarkable: Likes it
The use case for the ReMarkable is not the same as the use case for an iPad. There are other e-ink writing tablets out there besides ReMarkable obviously, but iPad did not at all satisfy what I was looking for in a note taking/paper reading tablet. It was like a glorified second phone with a shit writing interface. Very glad I switched to e-ink.
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
Can someone educate me why not instead buy an iPad for $50 (18%) more? Currently 9th generation iPad lists at $329 and reMarkable 2 at $279. Both devices have similar form factor, except iPad is slightly heavier. Yet, iPad is infinitely more capable compared to a reMarkable 2.
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
Sorry, but have you looked at Procreate? There is absolutely no comparison to what you can do on an iPad. It’s basically a Wacom plus one of the high end art apps. Anything that you can do on a Remarkable can be done better on an iPad with respect to drawing, once you add a Paperlike to replicate the texture. I guess if you only did pencil sketches outside, the Remarkable would win.
Apple iPad: Recommends itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I really wanted to like the Remarkable. I saw people using them at a couple of conferences the idea seems so great. So I tried it. Twice, for a couple weeks each. Had a couple of other people borrow in between and try it. We all reached the same conclusion: Solid implementation of a great idea! ... but ... An additional object to carry? Nope. Get an iPad or a Surface Pro, if you need to both write/sketch and do other computing work. Carrying both a digital writing tablet and a separate general purpose device is very unappealing.
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I can't think of any. There's the Remarkable, but I hear second-hand that it's poor at ebook reading. Does B&N count as a big evil corporation? I'm frankly surprised they're still going but the Kobo seems interesting and it purportedly handles epub natively. Myself, I just surrendered and bought a Kindle Paperwhite and paired it with Calibre. For tech books, I tend to prefer my iPad (I already have it, and it's easier to page flip).
Apple iPad: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I previosuly owned a reMarkable 1. Today I use an iPad Air with Concepts [1]. The iPad just works and the Apple Pencil smoothness and responsiveness is unparalleled. I was enamored by the idea of a "hackable" linux eInk writing tablet. But I found none of that matters when all you want to do is write/draw. The eInk offers great readability and battery life, but you still have to charge the tablet. With an iPad it's daily vs weekly with the reMarkable. But I found myself with a dead reMarkable during the most inopportune moments several times. When something only needs to be charged weekly you end up forgetting. Whereas everyday charging becomes habitual. Also I was never really outside or in brightly lit rooms where the eInk made sense. For me the eInk display was not a benefit. The pen had noticeable lag but was okay. What was really bad was the digitizer dead zones where the pen did not work at all, was overly sensitive (as in I could write with the pen a few mm above the display) or the writing had artifacts (stretching/jagged edges). Touch sensitivity wasnt great. Simple things like zooming and touch gestures was not intuitive. Writings had jaggeded edges and other artifacts. Never smooth like the Apple Pencil. None of the built in brushes where suitable for writing- either to thick, thin or just plain weird. The OS was not really hackable. Any changes might be blown away by software updates. It runs a closed source Qt app called Xochitl which does everything from the UI,…
Apple iPad: NeutralreMarkable: Likes it
No you're wrong. Its absolutely a selling point. When i got my remarkable i did what i do with any other tech, start searching the menus and features and trying things out. What i immediately discovered... theres nothing to do! Until you start writing, or you have something to read, the device is useless. I got mine for XMas, and a week earlier i bought myself an ipad pro to use as a digital notebook. Unboxing it and using it day one and i was immediately struct by the quiet tech that it is. Its unlike anything else i've used in a long time. Get an ipad and theres endless apps and accounts and notifications and a shiny bright screen begging for you to play with it. The ipad really wants to be your computer with a stylus attached, and that is great, i take it traveling instead of anything else and its really convenient. The remarkable is NOT a computer. The remarkable sits at my desk and is just ready for me, while the ipad is eternally charging, or chiming, or begging for attention and distraction. I can't have it at my desk while i work. The remarkable is literally a digital notebook and has about as much utility as a real notebook - a lot for writing and reading and almost 0 for anything else. It is honestly the first product i've used that actually replaces paper at my desk.
Switched from the reMarkable to the Apple iPadApple iPad: Likes it
I like using my iPad better than my RM2 for similar reasons (I have both, but really only use the iPad anymore). The pickup is much better on the iPad, in my opinion. However, one thing that I think makes the biggest difference is adding a screen protector. I particularly like the ones from https://paperlike.com/ . It adds a layer that makes it less like writing on glass and more like writing on paper. For me, this was the biggest increase in usability for taking notes.