The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad Pro vs reMarkable

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple iPad Pro.

Apple iPad ProreMarkable
Owners with an opinion643475
Positive verdicts64% of 54960% of 383
Positive/negative since 2024150/111101/101
Happy after 3+ years416
Longest happy owner10 yrs6 yrs
Praised forperformance and displayease of use and display
Criticized forsoftware and ease of usesoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad Pro: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I have an iPad Pro, daylight and remarkable 2. iPad Pro is definitely the fastest. The daylight and rm2 are slightly slower and I do notice it, but they are definitely fast enough. The RM2 is the slowest and that is just e-ink physics at that point. I was pleasantly surprised by the speed of the daylight when I used it. It's all lost on me although, since I don't really like pen input. I find the RM2 frustratingly slow for an epub e-ink reader. Compared to a kindle or others it's weirdly slow, even when pen input is fast. The daylight solves the outdoor computing problem for me.
Apple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like itreMarkable: Likes it
I had an RM2 it was great, love that writing texture feel and how you can program it yourself too that's nice. I never subscribed with mine or even connected it to WiFi. I'm still unsure if I will get one again as I think I would just use something like a Surface Book. My reasoning is financial mostly in the past when I was better off (like I am now) I bought so much crap like multiple G lenses (thousands $). Now I'm about avoiding being broke so just 1 type of similar device vs. multiple. I also had an iPad Pro which arguably their hardware is the best eg. built in lidar but I don't like the iOS ecosystem in an iPad so I got rid of that too.
Apple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like itreMarkable: Neutral
I concur. I switched from the very first remarkable to an ipad pro with paperlike but it's very different and much less paper-like. Also, the paperlike screen protector lost lost 100% of the roughness in just a few months, and now when I write it's basically the same as writing on the glass.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I had a remarkable 1 that I used primarily to read epub/pdf and my enduring memory was how slow it was to wsitch pages. Realise this is mostly a hardware limitation of the screen, but I found it frustrating. With some sadness I went to an iPad pro 12.9 which was very fast to switch pages, and I don't have that same sense of frustration.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I love e-ink and simple interfaces. I don't believe in low-powered hardware, however. This said remarkable 2 is so underpowered it's impractical. I love the paper-like experience, but I never use it for any important notes because I can't find anything ever. For example copying and pasting more than a trivial amount can take minutes (i.e. it blocks for minutes) and scrolling is just painful. Writing is not always accurate and you can get weirdly thick lines, etc. All of this can be fixed with better hardware and more performance, but I suspect the experience vs cost ratio is logarithmic/exponential. While scribbling in Goodnotes an iPad pro is not as "rewarding", actually working is so much better.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I had a ReMarkable 2 last year, but sent it back. For reading PDFs my iPad Pro 12.9 inch is way better, and for taking notes and scribbling paper is way better. I can also have 10 sheets of paper or more next to each other on my desk, try that with a ReMarkable. It's a beautiful device, but inferior to the alternatives, at least for me.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
Bigger screens are essential for scientific papers that have lots of charts and other figures. For eink-type screens there's not a lot type choose from. Fujitsu has a couple of A4 size models that look pretty good. If you can deal with traditional screens, the biggest iPad Pro is great. Remarkable and some other companies have A5 or 10.3" screens but these are too small IMHO. You will still end up zooming and panning.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itreMarkable: Likes it
I haven't been as excited about technology in a very long time as I have upon discovering eInk devices this year. Most of my Internet usage is skimfeed/Hacker News and the occasional jaunt on Reddit. I've also gotten back into books given how parasitic the Internet has become writ large. The iPad Pro is overkill for this use case, and its screen is harsh on the eyes (unless you use it in what I call "red mode", i.e. dark mode with a 100% red filter overlay). Given this, I wanted an eReader that I could read articles on the Internet with. The Kindle nails the first part, but its web browser sucks all sorts of shit. Enter the BOOX Go Color 7. This thing is exactly what I wanted: a super-capable eReader that's easy on the eyes and small enough to fit in my bum bag. It sucks at videos and is kind of slow, which makes it a slam dunk for my narrow use case. This inspired me to get a reMarkable 2 for keeping track of customer notes (I'm a sales engineer at the moment) and journal my work when I'm hacking on stuff. Loads of people have gushed over how much better this is than an iPad for writing; they are 100% correct. Having a paper feel is everything. No good solutions exist for this on an iPad, but it's totally possible with eInk displays. The rM2 inspired me even further to ditch my iOS weightlifting journal app (Strong) for a Go Color 10.3. I've used all sorts of apps for this purpose over the years (Google Sheets, then JEFIT, then Hevy, then Strong). Since there isn't an open…
Apple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like itreMarkable: Doesn’t like it
I’m not the op, but I am a “pen based note taking enthusiast“. I have owned both a gen 1 remarkable, and an older iPad Pro. In my opinion, the remarkable is garbage in comparison. The note taking app is just so far behind. And cross platform seems it’s never going to happen. My note taking app of choice is always: write, by stylus labs. It’s wonderful, and really expresses what I hoped pen based writing would always be. Especially the undo-wheel. For quickly scrolling back a whole word or sentence. But the real killer here is that it’s cross platform. I can move the notes to the native Linux app or the native windows app. That having been said, I am forever annoyed that I can’t run Xcode on either Linux or my $1000+ iPad. Also, on the iPad, there are ridiculous restrictions in how you are allowed to run apps side by side in split screen. /sigh So the race for the good pen note taking device is still on for me. I have hope that soon the Pine Note will take off and allow me to finally run write by stylus labs on a platform with development tools. In this case Linux. Again, Apple could win me back by opening access to dev tools. Either in the iPad itself or cross platform on Linux/windows—or by allowing me to install macOS on the iPad. Remarkable could win me back by opening the platform and allowing my to install write by stylus labs. Dell or Lenovo could win the race by shipping a 2-in-1 with a current generation processor and Linux officially supported, and preferab…