The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad Pro vs Microsoft Surface Pro

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple iPad Pro.

Apple iPad ProMicrosoft Surface Pro
Owners with an opinion643157
Positive verdicts64% of 54961% of 135
Positive/negative since 2024150/11140/28
Happy after 3+ years4111
Longest happy owner10 yrs10 yrs
Praised forperformance and displayperformance and portability
Criticized forsoftware and ease of usereliability and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad Pro: NeutralMicrosoft Surface Pro: Doesn’t like it
I use mine to browse the web a bit after work and consume RSS feeds using Feedly - always with the type cover. But for productivity, even with the Office apps, the information density on the screen is too low. Instead, I use my iPad as a thin client to RDP to my desktop computer, running Windows 11. This is with an iPad Pro 2021. In hindsight I should have purchased a Surface Pro tablet again, but I was so angry on the constant driver issues and similar problems.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Pro: Doesn’t like it
Not many; the iPad Pro + Apple Pencil Pro is considered by many to be the best-in-class drawing tablet. And the Surface Pro frankly sucks for digital illustration — it's far less responsive, with far less control. The next-best option after an iPad Pro is a Wacom pad plugged into a PC. Also, there's no point in using Photoshop for drawing on a tablet. (It's not impossible to use it for that, but it's not what I'd call a good experience.) You really want domain-specific digital-illustration software that puts the artist in direct control of brushes, color-mixing, and layers (either by direct-manipulation gestures, or in floating palettes, ring menus, etc); and then gets everything else out of the way (or doesn't include it at all.) You use such software to draw the things you want, as separate layer-groups or images — and then, when you're done, you throw those drawings into an app like Photoshop to clean them up, put them together, and otherwise transform your "drawings" into "artwork." If you're familiar with audio production: think of Photoshop as a DAW, and illustration as a performance. Even a solo musician doesn't touch their DAW while they're playing an instrument; the only thing they're touching is their instrument . Digital-illustration software is an instrument.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Pro: Doesn’t like it
I don’t think versatile devices are possible. I love iPad Pro for what it is. I tried Surface Pro and it was a much inferior tablet experience, even though the device is more “versatile”. I just doing think that you can get an excellent tablet by trying to be a laptop at the same time.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Pro: Doesn’t like it
I'm writing this reply on a Surface Pro 9 - the hardware is underpowered but is also the only reasonable option if you need a tablet that runs a "real" PC OS. But MS has had a heck of a time convincing ISV's to make software for the platform - and even apps (like Adobe's Lightroom) that have tablet modes hide them away - so almost no one knows about them. iPads are better at being tablets, but can't run apps like Lightroom (the non cloudclown version) at all, so it's definitely a tradeoff. For the last class I taught, I ended up using both the Surface and an iPad Pro (10"). The Surface was used in situations where I needed a full OS (as it turned out running VM's was part of that) and the iPad got used during lecture as it was simply superior for presenting slides with sketched overlays in real time.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Pro: Doesn’t like it
My experience with Microsoft Surface began during my college years. Prior to that I was primarily a MacBook Pro user. I first adopted the Surface Pro 3 for note taking. Over time, I upgraded to the Surface Pro 4, and then to the Surface Book and Surface Book 2. In my full-time job I use a Mac. Around 2017, my company began divesting from Surface devices. The reason why (which also echos my experiences) is they often fell short of expectations. Official docks proved to be unreliable, and the battery life was never quite up to par, not to mention they weren't easily repairable. A notable issue I encountered with the Surface Book was electrical shorting by the connector between the detachable keyboard/GPU. After Surface I went back to Mac. Circa 2021 I became disillusioned with laptops with their poor performance, thermal issues, lack of repairability/battery replacements/upgradability and general ergonomics. For example, 4K is just a drain on performance and finding a 2K laptop with a nice all aluminum build has been impossible. Today I use an iPad Pro for personal creative work (photo/video editing, drawing, illustrating) and a mini-ITX PC which is portable and fits in my carry-on. Having spent a lifetime using laptops, my experience with a my mini-ITX PC build was nothing short of revelatory. It opened my eyes to just how fast a desktop computer can be.
Apple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Surface Pro: Likes it
I don't think I do. I used to own a Surface Pro with their Surface Pen, basically the same experience and I used it for everything from reading manuals to flipping comic book pages. It was great, but none of it's greatness was predicated by "the power" of it's chip. The iPad Pro would be equally as attractive if it used the base-model chip and ditched the LIDAR nonsense, and it would be cheaper.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Pro: Doesn’t like it
The M1 is neat but it's not worth it for me. I hate everything about OS X. BSD command-line tools, a slow-as-most-glaciers Terminal.app, constant nagging about some menial task I need to perform for the computer. Nope, nope, nope. ("But if you just screw around with it for 20 years, then it will be just perfect." I already spent 20 years screwing around with Linux, so that cost is sunk. Sorry.) I really don't like doing "computery" stuff on more than one machine, and I already have a 32 core desktop workstation for normal work. That will never go away, which means the laptop can't be at all "computery". I want to touch an app with my finger and have the app start up. Every time, no matter what. (And to be fair, the iPad Pro absolutely delivers on that.) To me, a laptop will always be the second fiddle, something I use once a month or so. I find that if I don't screw around with my computer for a month, everything has stopped working -- but with a tablet, it just turns on and all is well. So you just throw the thing into your backpack for a trip, then when you get to the airport it turns on and 4G connects to the cell network, and everything is great. You have a computer, not computer problems. (Other laptops I've used in the past... Surface Pro 4. Left it turned on on my desk, went to get it ready for a trip... BAM brand new version of Windows and everything was broken. I didn't take it on the trip and just used my phone to browse the Internet at night. Chr
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Pro: Doesn’t like it
No real OS but I use an iPad pro 11, mostly because it never fails to work (including it’s excellent battery life and fast charging). For a real OS; I am still looking; I found the surface pro annoying after a while (and the one I had had miserable battery life). For now only intentionally hampered devices work for me in commute; either too small (Pocket or Pandora) or limited OS (Android/iOS). All other I tried are either too big or crap battery life; even the big winners like Lenovo X* or T* or macbook pro really do not have more than a few hour battery for my workflow.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Pro: Neutral
I used OneNote on a Surface Pro 1 for several years, but recently switched over to Goodnotes on an iPad Pro with Apple Pencil. Goodnotes has fewer features than OneNote, but the auto-shape tool is pretty sweet and I actually like the fact that it does not have infinite-sized pages. I do miss OneNote's OCR, text indexing/search, and seamless cross-platform sync (web, mobile, laptop).
Switched from the Apple iPad Pro to the Microsoft Surface ProMicrosoft Surface Pro: Likes it
Yeah. It's actually one of the main reason I've switched to doing my lectures off a Surface Pro rather than my iPad Pro. Having to constantly change tools in the apps just to erase is a giant pain (Yes, I know about double tap, but it doesn't work half the time).
Switched from the Apple iPad Pro to the Microsoft Surface ProMicrosoft Surface Pro: Likes it
Disclaimer I code for the web, so I wouldn't be affected by the SwiftUI part. Trying to make the iPad thing work for almost 10 years, I finally gave up and bought a Surface Pro (7 first, and upgraded to 8). People use to joke about the length iPad user go to execute simple tasks. Like logging to a remote server to reboot it. You can do it on an iPad, you just need an SSH app, share your keys with it, and you're done. Then you push a bit further to check out some git repo, change it and push it, and have your server update. But you're probably three apps down the line at this point, they can't really share a common working directory in the way you expect it to work as files are managed individually, there is the backgrounding issues etc. You can make most things work, but through piles of hacks, workflow glue, paying for many more external services or basically moving everything remote, out of the iPad. At some point I had a RPi stuck to the iPad to locally ssh into it. Or you spend the same amount of effort and frustration, but on Windows, on a machine that has none of the silly limitations, can run an actual linux subsystem locally, Docker if you want to, a full VSCode available offline and any other real pro tool you need. Basically, for the same amount of pulling hairs a Surface Pro actually delivers where the iPad always falls short in some way.
Switched from the Microsoft Surface Pro to the Apple iPad ProApple iPad Pro: Likes it
I briefly considered getting a surface pro recently, but opted for an iPad Pro with keyboard. So far, it’s been really lovely. I wonder what it would take to make such a nice device for an independent company with Linux. The m2 chip is obviously out of the question, but I wonder how close a startup could get in 5 years given some funding
Apple iPad Pro: NeutralMicrosoft Surface Pro: Neutral
> But they are more cumbersome to take and to read I'm genuinely curious about what you find cumbersome. Granted I've never been furiously writing dozens of pages of notes to begin with (to me the most important thing you do is listen to the meeting/lecture/event, notes are bookmarks and comments). I've used an iPad Pro and then the Surface Pro for meeting notes for about 5 years now, and it's just an infinitely paging/scrolling canvas, nothing more nothing less.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Pro: Likes it
I've said this in other places, but the biggest issue with the Surface lineup is that the Go line is ... just garbage performance wise, absolutely unusable in my experience (despite really really wanting to use it, and basically just using it for PDF annotations!). And the Pro line is good! But it has no 11-inch line and (importantly) it costs so much compared to iPads. If you are looking for a high-end tablet with some pen/pencil input, an iPad Pro 11 inch is the cheap option! It's kind of frustrating, because I think what's happening here is that the Surface Go line makes a lot of money, and a 11-inch-but-fast thing would probably be popular but have less juicy margins.