The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad Pro vs Microsoft Surface Go

Hacker News owners lean toward the Microsoft Surface Go.

Apple iPad ProMicrosoft Surface Go
Owners with an opinion64343
Positive verdicts64% of 54979% of 38
Positive/negative since 2024150/11113/6
Happy after 3+ years412
Longest happy owner10 yrs8 yrs
Praised forperformance and displayportability and performance
Criticized forsoftware and ease of usesoftware and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Surface Go: Likes it
With a bit of work, Apple could make iPad OS a much better system for tablets. I don't like newer iterations of GNOME, but it is a really decent user experience on a Surface Go. Given that an iPad Pro is a much better piece of hardware and linux-surface is made by some enthusiasts, there is no excuse for this. iPads are great, some apps are great, but the overall experience is simply not there. It is way too constraining.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Go: Doesn’t like it
I've said this in other places, but the biggest issue with the Surface lineup is that the Go line is ... just garbage performance wise, absolutely unusable in my experience (despite really really wanting to use it, and basically just using it for PDF annotations!). And the Pro line is good! But it has no 11-inch line and (importantly) it costs so much compared to iPads. If you are looking for a high-end tablet with some pen/pencil input, an iPad Pro 11 inch is the cheap option! It's kind of frustrating, because I think what's happening here is that the Surface Go line makes a lot of money, and a 11-inch-but-fast thing would probably be popular but have less juicy margins.
Apple iPad Pro: NeutralMicrosoft Surface Go: Likes it
I primarily use mine for content creation, reading/learning, and as a machine I can take with me when I'm out-and-about for those times when I need jump online and fix an issue. On the content creation side, I'm using Scrviner for writing, Snapseed and Lightroom for photo editing and LumaFusion for video production. I watch a lot of online courses on it and use it as my primary kindle reader. For those times when I'm out in the city, I keep it with me in case I need to jump online and troubleshoot an issue, do code reviews, etc. I'm using Terminus and Shelly for SSH, Github and Jira/Confluence apps, and of course, the AWS management console. A couple weeks ago I picked up a Surface Go2 and put Debian on it. So far, I'm finding that to be a better machine for taking with me while I'm out in the city. Being able to run VS Code and Linux CLI apps on a portable device is an big advantage over the iPad Pro. Also, as a lower cost machine, I'm less worried about it getting stolen or damaged relative to the iPad. I never would have imagined that one of my all-time favorite Linux devices would be made by M$... On my MacBook Pro, I have rules in my /etc/hosts that remap Facebook and Insta to a local page that reminds me to get back to work. So, I do all my social media from the iPad and prevent time-wasting and doomscrolling from my workhorse machine.
Apple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Surface Go: Likes it
I use a M1 12.9 iPad for mostly work. It is a glorified email machine that I use for the Microsoft suite of business products (Outlook, Teams, Office, etc.). I can either use an iPad to directly work with these apps, or use a laptop to Citrix in and have a Remote Desktop. The iPad is really fast and the display is amazing. But, I would gladly give it up for the small Surface Go that I own personally, but the apps running directly on my hardware are not supported or permitted by my IT group. So I am stuck with the iPad. It is heavier than a M1 or M2 air, and doesn’t have the same full functionality. Again, I would gladly give it up for small, light and convenient. It really isn’t even good as a media consumption machine because of the screen format. But is everything on it a smooth, buttery experience? You bet. But it isn’t worth the money for the beauty of the screen. I bought it as a hope to utilize it as a single device, but the limitations of the device and lock down strategy behind the os limits its true depth of functionality (at least what the hardware would permit) and forces me to keep a mini running as a home server to remotely connect to. I regret the purchase, if you hadn’t guessed.
Apple iPad Pro: NeutralMicrosoft Surface Go: Likes it
I have both a Surface Go and an iPad Pro, and while using the pen on the iPad Pro on its own offers a satisfactory experience, I find that it's not nearly as good as the Surface Go when it comes to accurately recognizing the correct input method when quickly switching between pen and touch inputs. My iPad Pro very often would treat my finger as a stylus and start drawing when I meant to use my fingers to scroll around, while on my Surface Go I honestly can't even recall that happening even once, and it's a night and day difference in terms of ergonomics for me. I think Microsoft's much longer experience in handling hybrid pen & touch input in OneNote for Windows still gives it an edge at the moment.
Apple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Surface Go: Likes it
I've been using a Surface Go after failing to get use from an iPad Pro. I find I use the Surface more than any of my other machines. Nearly perfect. Makes me plan on getting the next gen Surface Pro instead of a MacBook where the only hard requirement was for Xcode which can be relegated to any other old machine.