The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Tablets

Apple iPad Pro vs Apple Pencil

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple Pencil.

Apple iPad ProApple Pencil
Owners with an opinion64397
Positive verdicts64% of 54974% of 87
Positive/negative since 2024150/11120/11
Happy after 3+ years410
Longest happy owner10 yrs2 yrs
Praised forperformance and displayease of use and performance
Criticized forsoftware and ease of usevalue and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Pencil: Likes it
The iPad Pro is pulling double duty as both a professional workstation and a CEO laptop. Tim Cook has bragged about being able to do most of his work on an iPad, and I believe him, because executives spend most of their time reading and replying to e-mail. The iPad does that well because it inherited the Mail app from iPhones, which was already pretty good and just needed to be blown up to a larger size. And iPads make your organization look futuristic, at least to all the other executives you're talking to. The only reason why people are complaining about iPadOS' limitations is because Apple made the mistake of making it useful for creative professionals. They wanted to ship the Apple Pencil and wound up making it an iPad accessory rather than its own thing. So now people who want to draw with the Pencil - which is an amazing drawing experience - are saddled with the limitations of an iPad.
Apple iPad Pro: Doesn’t like itApple Pencil: Likes it
> Anyone have experience of using an iPad mini for this. Is the form factor do-able or really too small? I contemplated doing that, but went with an iPad Pro instead (11’’, second hand). Even 11’’ felt a bit small and I got a 13’’ eventually. Besides screen size, the Apple Pencil 2 is miles better. > I like that I could read lying down with one hand, which I can’t achieve with a full-sized iPad. Yes, for reading a Mini would be much better. More Kindle-like. The 11’’ Pro is still manageable with one hand (but without a case), but it’s not comfortable.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Doesn’t like it
I'm a pro musician and play a lot of gigs (and mix a lot of live music) on a 2016 12.9" ipad pro. I used Forscore and have a bunch of fakebooks and custom charts on it. Even with a regular stylus it's been very useful (though I occasionally wish my 1st gen pencil had not died). If I had to replace it I don't think I'd bother with a super new one, as this is plenty of horsepower / memory for the things I use it for. So probably way less than $1k, I'd think.
Apple iPad Pro: NeutralApple Pencil: Likes it
Some things work great on the iPad, and for those things the iPad is absolutely fantastic and I will often prefer to use it. If you want to infinitely scroll, the iPad is unparalleled. It is great for reading and watching. I like it as a game device. It is great for reading news and I enjoy apple's news widgets. Kindle works well. If you want to consume, the iPad is an amazing tool for consumption. Additionally in the last year, apple made it really easy to use your iPad as a second screen, either as an iPad or as a literal second screen for your macbook. I found myself doing that more and more. I bought the apple pencil thinking it can't possibly be worth the money, but it is an enjoyable device to use. Writing text on an iPad is more gimmick than feature (for me), but I find it a pleasurable way to scroll or navigate apps. That being said, once you want to do a task with a keyboard, there is no replacing a laptop. The iPad is also locked down (no terminal, only safari) such that a laptop is still necessary. The iPad is still very much a luxury device and could not stand on its own. Phones and laptops both have features that the iPad does not have that make them necessary. The iPad offers nothing that makes it necessary unless you consider an ancillary screen for your laptop necessary.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Recommends it
The Apple Pencil is the best stylus I’ve ever used. The 13” size is perfect (it’s basically an A4 page). The handwriting recognition on the iPad is amazing. But mostly, it’s the software. GoodNotes and Procreate are my two killer apps. There’s nothing as good on any other platform. For me, the iPad Pro I have is justified by those two apps alone. Aside from an iPod a bunch of years ago, the iPad was my first Apple platform product. Last year I switched from a Google Pixel to an iPhone, so now I have two Apple products. The phone is fine but I was pretty happy on the Pixel too. The iPad though us my favorite computer to use.
Apple iPad Pro: Recommends itApple Pencil: Likes it
I've been drawing digitally for around 15 years, starting with the original Wacom tablets. For drawing, my iPad Pro (2018) with the Pencil 2 feels like magic. In my experience, its latency is much better than the Cintiq or the Surface. It feels so much like drawing on paper, especially with a matte screen cover. Every time I use it to draw, I feel like I'm living in the future. No piece of technology has impressed me to this degree. That being said, outside of digital art, it's pretty clunky. The lack of a mouse pointer and proper multitasking makes it less than ideal for business uses. But when I'm drawing on it though, man, I feel like Tom Cruise in Minority Report
Apple iPad Pro: Recommends itApple Pencil: Likes it
I also use Zotero, and use Box.Com for storage/syncing. Zotfile is a wonderful addon. I use Zotero in conjunction with Papership ( http://www.papershipapp.com ) on an iPad. Papership syncs with WebDAV storage, which means that, after syncing, downloaded PDFs are available on your iPad for reading offline. Any annotations are pushed back and available in the Zotero client. It's a great client and really stable. In conjunction with the Apple Pencil, it's a really nice system. I'd advise an iPad Pro 12.9" if you do a lot of reading. The extra size means that you spend less time zooming in and out, and an app like Liquid Text ( http://liquidtext.net ) comes into its own for bringing text and figures into the same region of the screen and reduce the amount of time you spend flipping between the two.
Apple iPad Pro: NeutralApple Pencil: Neutral
I have a M1 iPad Pro and I'm open to doing a trade-in for a new M5 iPad Pro: however the problem is the accessories. I rely on the Magic Keyboard and Apple Pencil and they would have to be repurchased since they are not compatable, which upps the total price too much.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
It might be enlightening to find out a bit about the process of creating CGI; especially 3D scenes. Many works can definitely take over a year. I spent some time, making CG art, and found it to be very difficult; but that was also back before some of the new tools were available. Apps like Procreate, with Apple Pencil and iPad Pro, are game-changers. They don't remove the need for a trained artist, though. But really, some of the very best stuff, comes quickly, from skilled hands. Van Gogh used to spit out paintings at a furious pace (and barely made enough to live on. Their value didn't really show, until long after his death).
Apple iPad Pro: NeutralApple Pencil: Neutral
I have an ipad pro from 2015, an apple pencil 1, and a screen protector that gives it a bit more friction. It's pretty good for the most part, but since it's my only apple product, it doesn't integrate well with anything else I use. OneNote seems to work on multiple platforms but I never got into it. I mostly use goodnotes, and they seem to have released apps for web and non-apple stuff (finally). When I used it the most, the only export I had was as PDFs to Dropbox, which was fine enough but removed any possibility of editing outside of the ipad.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
I recently bought the M4 iPad Pro with the nano texture glass, etc. My goal in buying an iPad was to have a device that helps me focus more when doing certain kinds of work. I have ADHD and so my life is a constant struggle against distraction. A fully functional, fully customizable computer with overlapping windows and instant access to anything is totally counterproductive much of the time. I am probably using the iPad about 25% of the time for work now. During this focused time, I am far better at responding to emails and reading long documents than when I am back on my chaos machine - an M2 MacBook Pro with the Studio Display. Yes, I got the keyboard and the pencil; without a keyboard, I couldn’t be productive on the device. I’m not much of an artist, but I am gradually growing to love having the pencil. I’ve started using GoodNotes with the pencil to make diagrams like mind maps and to do brainstorms. My handwriting is awful so forget about handwriting with the pencil. It’s more useful for drawing pictures. If you are an attention-starved person like me, maybe give it a shot? You could do worse.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
As a very very regular iPad user, and this may be against Apple's intentions, if you're using the on screen keyboard for that stuff you're doing it wrong and are a masochist. I use the Mac for any text editing job because you really need a proper computer for that and the iPad is not a proper computer. For me, the iPad is mostly a surface for writing on, general admin tasks and basic image editing. The Apple Pencil is the best input device I find. It's not a complete replacement device - it's complementary. Also my 11" iPad Pro is smaller than any laptop and charges off the same charger as my phone so it goes everywhere with me. I'm about to jump on a plane and it has a week's worth of entertainment, music, textbooks, notepad and Lightroom on it and a pencil stuck on the side. This is just perfect for me. But try and replace a macOS machine with it and you might as well chop your fingers off. The keyboard case is mostly ok but I just never use it. I should probably bounce it on eBay at some point but I keep it around "just in case". Edit: most of the people I know who use iPads got them mostly for the Apple Pencil support.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
Yep, in most situations it is my preference to read directly from the manuscripts. I specialize in the 13 course Baroque lute and overall we are used to reading handwritten tablature as this was the primary notation for this instrument which predates the widespread adoption of modern notation. Because of the rarity of our instrument and its notation, it is often the case that there are no modern editions available at all, and even if there are, I tend to not trust the judgement of the editor and prefer to work from the original manuscripts. Because of the fact that the 13 course lute disappeared into more or less complete obscurity after around ~1785, we have been without a robust academic infrastructure to support scholarly research about the instrument for quite a long time- in fact until around the late 20th century, so even with a modern edition, I would venture to say that it would be irresponsible to play solely from it without at least checking the original source. What is great is that nowadays with an iPad Pro, and Apple pencil, we have an ideal situation to read directly from original manuscripts in full color and in high fidelity. It is especially helpful to have all of the manuscripts in your library and to be able to compare different concordant versions of the same pieces from different manuscripts. Regarding legibility, yes there are issues. For example, in the Dresden manuscripts, D-Dl Mus. 2841-V-1,1-6, which contain possibly the greatest collection of music…
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
Apple does not even advertise the Apple Pencil for use with iPhones. Because, as you say, it's a dumb pointer on your iPhone. I have an iPPro + Pencil, and it is astonishingly good. It is no 'dumb stylus' on the iPPro. The exquisite detail one gets from a writing implement is not quite replicated with the Pencil -- but! The fact that Apple does advertise the Pencil and its features is a hopeful sign that we will continued to see more, and more sophisticated Pencils & apps that use them. I hope.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
Linux can easily replace a Mac or Windows machine for me, but I’ve yet to see any device that could even come close to the iPad Pro. Apple’s second generation pencil is perfect to the point where I’ve never once had to consciously charge it or accidentally leave it somewhere. And the software support is amazing. Linux on phones, I can see becoming viable once the software improvements are there. Linux on tablets? No. Not until someone can come up with something like the Apple Pencil.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
How's the pen latency, esp. compared to iPads? I'm using an iPad Pro (2nd or 3rd gen) + Paperlike and it works lovely and even the 1st-gen pen is just so much better than anything else I've tried.
Apple iPad Pro: Likes itApple Pencil: Likes it
I used the iPad Pro for about 2 years for nothing but productivity apps and it was overall pretty great. It wasn't without issue though, here's what I ran into: 1. I didn't run any dev tools on the iPad. That's insane. I used a laptop running macOS for that. 2. Google Docs updates would always ship with weird bugs, like if I'm editing a cell in a Google Sheet and hit space, the space wouldn't insert. 3. There's loads of issues with drag and drop in most apps. Dragging and dropping a picture from Photos into a document is the most common flow which works in some apps, but not in others. The plus sides: 1. The built-in cellular connection is amazing. I wish MacBook Airs would ship with built-in cellular. 2. The Apple Pencil (2nd gen) is great if you design software or UX.